The Wuthering Heights Trailer Is Peak “I Can Fix Him” Fantasy
The trailer for Emerald Fennell’s already controversial feature film adaptation of Wuthering Heights is here, and if this clip is anything to go by, the capital D-discourse around the movie is definitely not going to get any less divisive any time soon.
Plenty of Emily Brontë purists will — and quite rightly, if we’re honest — find much to complain about when it comes to our first real look at the movie, from its anachronistic costumes and vaguely inaccurate casting choices to its almost complete lack of the soulful grief that infuses so much of the original novel.
But for plenty of folks (read: me), there’s also something wildly appealing about its completely unhinged and vaguely demented approach to its source material, which here is reimagined as an almost peak rehabilitation fantasy. Fennell seems to want to sell us a Cathy and Heathcliff we can root for, or that at least will somehow be better together than they are apart. (To which, I say: Good luck, babe.)
The idea that some women prefer bad boys isn’t exactly new. In fact, it’s so prevalent that a lot of fiction in recent years has taken things one step further, embracing the idea that what women really love are the problematic heroes, the kind with deep-set emotional issues and psychological traumas that are probably best treated with therapy rather than a wedding band. The kind of man that needs saving — from his past, from himself, from his inner demons. Heathcliff, one of the most universally acknowledged Problematic Men in all of literature, can perhaps be read as a kind of prototype for this movement.
But the concept remains popular, and there’s admittedly something quite powerful in the idea that love — love with the singularly right person — can fix the most broken of souls is still the foundation of half of the modern-day romance publishing industry today. So, it’s probably only natural that Fennell is as susceptible to it as anyone else. Savior complexes, we apparently all have them! But can she make the ultimate bad boy hot again? (Even if he’s actually abusive and manipulative and cruel?) Is Heathcliff a character that’s possible to “fix”?
Look, if the release of Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein has taught us anything, it’s that Jacob Elordi can be hot in any form. He’s at Gothic Romance Final Boss levels of swoon in this trailer, as Heathcliff smolders in the rain, dramatically rides off into the literal sunset on horseback, and delivers lines like “So kiss me, and let us both be damned” without a single hint of irony or archness. For those of us (cough cough me again cough) who spent our youth loving movies like Bram Stoker’s Dracula and Kenneth Branagh’s take on Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, this melodramatic asshole is basically our dream man. And apparently, he’s Fennell’s, too.
The trailer—once more, completely unironically!—refers to Wuthering Heights as “the greatest love story of all time,” leaning into the star-crossed vibes of Cathy and Heathcliff’s romance and referencing several of the novel’s most iconic lines. (“Whatever our souls are made of, his and mine are the same” is an all-timer of a sentiment, and I will not be taking questions at this time.) Fennell seems to be approaching this story like she’s remaking Romeo & Juliet on acid—there’s licking of walls, artfully placed fingers in mouth, even shots of sensual breadmaking.
But for all the dizzingly strange visual elements and gorgeously out-of-place costumes, the trailer seems strangely honest and straightforward about one thing: the achingly romantic nature of Cathy and Heathcliff’s forbidden relationship. That Fennell ships it is evident; that she believes in the power of love to save a pair of broken and awful people, even more so. But it’s definitely weird that the film appears to be intentionally leaving out—or has at least declined to mention in its marketing materials thus far—the fact that their love story is also deeply and thoroughly toxic. Yes, their unabashed longing for one another can be read as a form of Peak Romance, but in the novel, their inability to be together is also what turns each of them into the absolute worst versions of themselves, ruining multiple lives (including their own!) in the process.
To be fair, it’s probably too soon to fully tell how this Wuthering Heights will handle its depiction of the (considerable) parts of Brontë’s novel in which Cathy does not appear, and where the full scope of Heathcliff’s viciousness is made plain. But since its twisted romance vibes definitely lean more toward the tragic than the cautionary tale, a not-so-small amount of viewers may well find themselves taken aback by how decidedly dark this story has the potential to become. Or maybe we’ll all end up wanting our own Heathcliff-style fixer-upper in the end.
Wuthering Heights will be released on February 13, 2026.