Star Wars: The Mandalorian Season 3 Episode 3 Review – The Convert
Chapter 19 of The Mandalorian, "The Convert," takes us to one of the most beloved locations in Star Wars while also setting up what's next for Din and Bo-Katan.
This Star Wars review contains spoilers for The Mandalorian.
The Mandalorian Season 3 Episode 3: Chapter 19
What’s become increasingly clear about The Mandalorian season 3 is that it feels deliberately paced and plotted, with much of these early chapters being devoted to setup for bigger, more raucous moments and reveals down the line. Is this a good thing or a bad thing? It’s impossible to tell at this point if all of these moving plot pieces will ultimately assemble in a satisfying way, but so far, the story is developing nicely and revisiting some intriguing characters and locales to give them more space to breathe.
The episode, aptly titled “The Convert,” picks up right where “The Mines of Mandalore” left off, with Din Djarin coming to moments after Bo-Katan Kryze rescued him from the depths of the Living Waters, where she witnessed with her own eyes the majesty of a living, breathing Mythosaur. Curiously, she doesn’t share her sighting with Din, which speaks to her rocky relationship with The Creed and her personality-defining denouncement of the old ways. Still, it’s clear her faith in her own beliefs has been somewhat shaken after this experience, as we’ll say later in the episode.
The dynamic and rapport between Bo-Katan and Din has consistently been one of the best aspects of the show, and watching them spiral around each other and their respective ideologies doesn’t feel like it will get old anytime soon. And the fact that we see neither’s face this episode speaks to how uniquely talented Katee Sackhoff and Pedro Pascal are. Many actors would be impaired by the armor, but these two seem to have found the power in it.
The aerial dogfight with Din’s Naboo Starfighter and Bo-Katan’s Gauntlet taking on the squadron of TIE Interceptors was chef’s-kiss phenomenal. As an aerial fight scene it’s got everything you’d want: a crackling sense of speed, thrilling mid-air maneuvers, huge explosions. And what makes Star Wars so great in this particular arena is that each spacecraft has its own personality to it. From the way the Gauntlet flips its wings to drift and get the drop on the Interceptors, to the modded N-1’s nimbleness and breakneck speed, to the iconic, almost animalistic screech of the TIEs, this scene was nerdy as hell, and gloriously so.
But there’s even more to it than that. As The Mandalorian does so well, the aerial display isn’t just in there for show, as it ended with TIE Bombers laying waste to Bo-Katan’s home. There’s a pull in the episode’s final act for her to return to the religion she was baptized into as a child, and again, however inadvertently, as an adult. She and Din are accepted back into the Tribe, but she’s keeping the Mythosaur-sized secret close to her chest for now. It leaves a lingering question for us to discuss in the coming weeks: will Bo-Katan use the Tribe’s invitation to further her own plans to rule Mandalore, or is she starting to actually believe in The Way after her encounter with the Mythosaur? She doesn’t take off her helmet after witnessing the Mythosaur, after all. This aspect of the narrative is developing nicely and propels the story forward in a way that’s more character-driven and personal, which counter-balances all of the action and world-building perfectly.
And speaking of world-building, the touristic element of the show is as impressive now as it’s ever been. Spending time on Coruscant with Dr. Penn Pershing (Omid Abtahi) and Elia Kane (Katy M. O’Brian) is interesting on several levels, but one nuanced benefit of this side story is that visually, the mostly nocturnal Coruscant serves as an appealing contrast to the diurnal dogfight we just watched on Kalevala. But truthfully, it’s just freakin’ great to explore the streets of Coruscant from the ground level and spend time in one of the most beloved locales in the entire Star Wars universe.
Following Dr. Pershing as he navigates the New Republic’s Amnesty Program and gets close to Elia Kane is compelling at times, although a few of the dialogue driven scenes sort of fall flat due to some uninspired writing and uneven performances. The ideas in play here are worthwhile, though. Elia and Pershing (or G68 and L52, respectively) connecting over their refusal to just be cogs in whatever oppressive, proverbial machine they’re ensnared by gives their stories a bit of thematic heft, and Elia’s deception at the end is a nice twist that points to some dark days ahead for Pershing and perhaps the reintroduction of Moff Gideon, who is clearly pulling the strings, especially after it’s hinted he’s already escaped captivity.
One of the best things about Pershing and Elia’s mission to get equipment from the junked Star Destroyer is the train scene, which has, of course, been done countless times before, but is welcome here in that it adds a bit of tension and danger to what had been a bit of a drag to that point. Abtahi is a great performer, but the office work malaise scenes and the interactions with Elia and the other New Republic converts mostly come off as stilted and forgettable, so the train and creaky Imperial Cruiser scenes are like breaths of fresh air. Also, the physical sets of the Star Destroyer interiors are just sublime. In a time when seemingly every scene in every Disney production is shot on some kind of sound stage wrapped in digitally-implemented scenery, tactile sets like these make all the difference. Overall, it feels like The Mandalorian took a page from Andor for this Coruscant section — in a good way.
There are so many things to look forward to as this season of The Mandalorian continues. How long will Bo-Katan hold on to her secret? What role will Pershing and his expertise in cloning play in the grand scheme of things (Palpatine, perhaps)? Will we get the epic IG-11 return we all deserve? When will we see Gorian Shard and his gaggle of pirates again? Will we see Din ride a mudscuffin’ Mythosaur? What will Grogu’s first words be?! Brick by brick, the foundation is being laid for something huge to go down in the season’s latter half, and so far, the build-up has been a joy in and of itself.
Written by
Bernard Boo is a writer and geek enthusiast living in the San Francisco Bay Area. Movies, TV, video games, and comics are constantly rattling around in his brain,…