Forget Ebenezer: The Best Modern Christmas Carol Is Will Ferrell’s Other Christmas Movie

After headlining an all-time holiday classic in Elf, Will Ferrell returned to the genre with the surprisingly solid Spirited.

Ryan Reynolds and Will Ferrell in "Spirited," now streaming on Apple TV.
Photo: Apple TV

Ebenezer was supposed to be a big deal. Beyond serving as a potential comeback vehicle for Johnny Depp, it marks the first production under Skydance’s umbrella since it acquired Warner Bros. and an attempt to get ahead of the holiday season. Instead, critics and audiences alike have mostly responded with a “bah humbug” for taking unnecessary liberties with the story of A Christmas Carol, with Depp’s take on Ebenezer Scrooge feeling less like Scrooge and more like Jack Sparrow in Victorian garb.

On the one hand, director Ti West was fighting an uphill battle. Putting aside the baggage that comes with Depp and Skydance, A Christmas Carol is one of the most endlessly retold tales in history. A version with the Muppets still stands out. There’s also a 3D version with Jim Carrey that Robert Zemeckis unintentionally turns into nightmare fuel. For my money, the best version features the late, great Patrick Stewart as Scrooge. But if you want a version of this story that actually feels fresh, there’s Apple TV’s Spirited.

At first glance, Spirited feels like a more modern take on A Christmas Carol, as the three ghosts who haunt Scrooge have made a business out of picking one lost soul and pulling the same trick at Christmastime. However, the Ghost of Christmas Present (Will Ferrell) faces his biggest challenge yet in Clint Briggs (Ryan Reynolds), an amoral media consultant more concerned with his bottom line than the Christmas spirit. To make matters worse, he sees through the Spirits’ routine and causes them to question their life choices…or rather, their afterlife choices.

This is a take you wouldn’t expect, but makes sense. When Charles Dickens wrote A Christmas Carol, Victorian society was particularly preoccupied with ghosts and the afterlife, so the idea of being scared into becoming a better person had power. In contrast, Spirited debuted in 2022, an age of social media, COVID-19, and other events that chipped away at the era’s optimism. Most people would probably think the Spirits are an elaborate hoax, or question why they have to change, which adds an interesting wrinkle.

Ad – content continues below

The casting of Ferrell and Reynolds also works in Spirited’s favor. While audiences have oftentimes felt as worn out by Reynolds’ penchant for playing motor-mouthed jerks with hearts of gold as they have by Depp’s mugging, here it actually makes sense – especially as the movie gets to dig deep into Clint’s past and reveal why he’s become such a ruthless businessman. Ferrell provides a great counterpart, especially with a twist involving the Spirit of Christmas Present that will make fans look twice at A Christmas Carol. It also certainly helps that Ferrell has serious holiday movie bona fides thanks to modern classic Elf. 

Spirited is also a musical, featuring some show-stopping choreography in addition to its songs. Admittedly, this is the one part of the movie that’s hit or miss; while Ferrell and Reynolds have great chemistry together, their singing could use some improvement. Don’t worry – it’s not as ear-bleedingly obvious as Russell Crowe in Les Misérables, but you could have taken the songs out and not missed anything. Despite this, Spirited is still one of the better takes on A Christmas Carol, and more than worth watching if you were displeased by Ebenezer or need something to shake up the Christmas movie list.