Den of Geek

Rock And Chips review

Alex Westthorp


The BBC tries to milk more from Only Fools and Horses with Rock & Chips, a prequel to the series. But is it any good?

Published on Jan 24, 2010

PLEASE NOTE: THIS EPISODE SCREENS ON SUNDAY NIGHT ON BBC ONE AT 9PM. THIS REVIEW CONTAINS MILD SPOILERS.

Only Fools And Horses was one of the most successful sitcoms ever broadcast by the BBC. Writer John Sullivan always hinted there was a story to be told about Del Boy's younger days. So, the time now seems right to explore that avenue.

The BBC has attempted prequels before, most notably 1988's First Of The Summer Wine, wherein Peter Sallis played Clegg's father, which lead to a six part series in 1989. In Rock And Chips, Nicholas Lyndhurst plays Rodney's father Freddie Robdal aka 'Freddy the Frog', a roguish safe cracker with artistic leanings and frogman diving skills (hence the nickname!).  

The main focus of Rock And Chips is the blossoming romance between Del's mum Joan Trotter and Freddie Robdal, a character first mentioned in the 1987 Only Fools And Horses Christmas special The Frog's Legacy.

Rumours abounded Freddie "The Frog" Robdal may have been Rodney's father. Joan Sims guested as Joan Trotter's friend Irene "Reenie" Turpin (also Trigger's Aunt) who tells Del the full story. In the final episode of Only Fools And Horses, 2003's Christmas special Sleepless In Peckham, Rodney discovers the truth when he finds a photograph of Freddie on the 1960 Jolly Boys Outing to Margate. Viewers aware of all this will get a lot out of this special.  

Curiously, the title was originally to be Once Upon A Time In Peckham, then Sex And Drugs And Rock And Chips, which was a bit of a mouthful. But why was it shortened? Perhaps not to be confused with the current Ian Dury biog film, Sex And Drugs And Rock n' Roll, or more likely it was the drugs reference (which is borne out in the drama, incidentally) or perhaps it was just too similar a title to the BBC's 1999 drama, Sex And Chips And Rock 'n' Roll...? 

The establishing shots are rather low key. The monochrome titles are a world away from the upbeat, jaunty Only Fools And Horses opening singalong. The interesting use of ungraded videotape (at least on the preview copy) and the opening scene of Joan (a standout performance from Kellie Bright), looking beehive glamorous, staring rather wistfully into her dressing table mirror, is (perhaps intentionally) startlingly reminiscent of a mid-70s Play For Today. Thus, the tone is set and the lack of a laugh track marks this out as more comedy drama than sitcom. The comedy moments take second place to the illicit romance of Joan and Freddie.  

Del Boy, for once, isn't the main focus of the show. Inbetweeners actor James Buckley plays the wheeler dealer at fifteen, hormonal and desperate to lose his cherry. Embracing under-age smoking and drinking (but drawing the line at drugs) and surrounded by all his mates, Boycie, Slater, Trigger (always a bit behind the others) and newly arrived from Liverpool, Denzil.

Del Boy's stance on drugs is interesting as it seems to support David Jason's perception of the character "...not always honest but moral".

Buckley is a talented young actor and deserves to be better known. He embellishes the part with some of David Jason's mannerisms, notably the forward pushing nod of the head. It's such a good performance, it feels churlish to suggest Buckley is about four inches too tall to be Del, though people do shrink with age!

Sullivan has included several characters and throwaway lines which explain many things in the parent show. The character of Jumbo Mills was seen in the 1986 Only Fools And Horses episode Who Wants To Be A Millionaire? returning from Australia to restart his erstwhile partnership with Del Boy. They used to sell things from a van outside the Nags Head in the 60s.

Here they are seen together selling 'hooky' carpets from a van. Only Joan's friend Reenie Turpin suspecting the carpets might not be from a reputable source.

Albie Littlewood appears too. He was mentioned in the 1985 episode Happy Returns as Del's love rival for the hand of the rather gauche Juney. Littlewood meets a rather tragic end in 1964. There were reports the special would feature the never-seen Monkey Harris; it doesn't, I'm pleased to say.   

Rock And Chips enjoys its nostalgia, giving us lots of big cars and 60s sounds as it charts the Trotter's move from their overcrowded home in Orchard Street to the legendary flat in Nelson Mandela House. The reason Joan was keen to have another child so many years after Del Boy was partly to make the move possible, the housing department wanting to be seen to do their best for families with young children.

The special ends with the birth of Rodney. Interestingly, the name Rodney was chosen by Joan after the actor Rod Taylor, star of the (superior) 1960 film of H.G. Wells' The Time Machine... 

The star of the drama is undoubtedly Kellie Bright. Recently seen in Catherine Tate's Nan's Christmas Carol and episodes of Horne And Corden, Bright was a juvenile lead in the 80s and 90s with parts in T-Bag and The Upper Hand. She brings just the right mix of sassy Cockney sparrow and struggling mother figure to Joan Trotter.

Nicholas Lyndhurst as roguish Freddie Robdal (in a suit and trenchcoat, reminiscent of his Gary Sparrow character) is just too likeable to convince as the hardman, but Robdal is more high-minded than the average villain, so Lyndhurst just about gets away with it. It's obvious where Rodney gets his artistic leanings from and his intelligence.  

Phil Daniels relishes his role as a middle-aged version of Grandad complete with the ever-present trilby. Shaun Dingwall (Rose's dad, Pete Tyler in Doctor Who) is seen here as Del's abrasive painter and decorator father, Reg.

Mention should be made of Emma Cooke who shines as the all-knowing Reenie Turpin and the ever-reliable Robert Dawes has a marvellous cameo as Joan's sexually repressed boss, cinema manager Mr Rayner. 

All in all, Rock And Chips is an enjoyable and nostalgic one-off. Don't expect a laugh-out-loud comedy, though. It's darker and more thoughtful, bittersweet, even.

The main story is relatively slight, but this allows a chance to catch up with all the Fools And Horses regulars in their younger days. Dedicated fans will appreciate the back stories of the various characters.

James Buckley does very well, but we don't really see enough of him. Also it would have been fun to see a teenage Marlene living up to the phrase "...all the lads remember Marlene!"  

BBC One has been carefully resting Only Fools And Horses for several years now to make it more welcome should it return in whatever shape or form. John Sullivan holds the record for the most-watched comedy show of both the Nineties and the Noughties: The Christmas specials of Only Fools And Horses from 1996 and 2001-3.

Whilst I'm sure it will be popular, it seems unlikely Rock And Chips will give Sullivan the record for the new decade, but I think the special may well lead to a series. Such a series could focus more on Del Boy and his mates as Rodney grows up, perhaps ending with Joan's untimely death and Reg's departure (with Del's sixteenth birthday cake!), leaving Del and Grandad to bring up Rodney, which would set the scene for the start of Only Fools And Horses... 

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By PeteDT 1 January 24, 2010 05:04:59 PM

I believe the sitcom's already been commissioned...

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By weazle 1 January 24, 2010 10:48:22 PM

i thhink it was a good programe and defenatly watch the series if it carries on 10 out of 10

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By autopian 1 January 24, 2010 11:30:24 PM

when taken in comparrison with 'only fools' rock and chips scores 5 out of ten for me, it was a love story we had heard a thousand times based around 2 characters we heard about but never met and so had little connection. maybe i expected too much but i was a little disapionted, more a chick flik than a propper comedy. Del boys character had non of the charm or comedy timing of david jason and felt wrong. non of the other characters were on screen long enough to form an opinion except freddie the frog and dels mom made it watchable. sorry but didn't rate it, should have watched slumdog on the other side.

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By talltony 1 January 25, 2010 05:24:09 AM

For me, this was excelent, and made the Only Fools saga complete. It had everything from Jumbo Mills to moving into Nelson Mandella House. I think everyone who starred in it played thier part fantasticly. Hats off to you John Sullivan, thank you.

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By A1nostalgia 1 January 25, 2010 08:21:32 AM

Did anyone else notice the sign outside Nelson Mandela House actually said "Sir Walter Raleigh House"? I'm assuming the name was changed later. This a subtle piece of historical detail. Nelson Mandela wasn't imprisoned until 1961 and wasn't a cause celebre until later...

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By Robmac 1 January 25, 2010 09:46:08 AM

I thought the show was superb, hinting and tempting at things that need following up. As with Only Fools the ideas didnt all need to put up on screen with the writing giving a vivid world seen 'just off camera' but some bits I would love to see if its commisioned for the series would be why Rodney is called 'Dave', the eventual passing of Joan and also if possible a cameo by a visiting Uncle Albert

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By A1nostalgia 1 January 25, 2010 12:47:31 PM

Overnight ratings just in: Rock And Chips got 7.4 million viewers. It beat Wild At Heart and the Dancing On Ice Results show... Good ratings in today's TV landscape but not the ten million plus the BBC were probably hoping for. Certainly enough to go to series, which the above correspondent suggests has already been commissioned.

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By clementine 1 January 25, 2010 01:01:52 PM

i absolutely loved this, i thought it was well cast and the writing was brill, i suspected that i would be disappointed but instead of trying to make something like ofah they went in a different direction the whole post war 60's theme wasn't done to death and it was subtle and i for one did not miss a laughter track. I hav4e to say the love story did take centre stage but it was so well acted that it made you want to keep watching and i even at one grossly disturbing point find myself thinking nicholas Lyndhurst was rather charming.. i'd give it an easy 8 and i genuinely hope thewy do, do a series.

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By shane 1 January 25, 2010 01:02:30 PM

Any true Only fools fan will aprieciate Rock and chips. Anybody who claims that it did not make them laugh so therefore did not like it are completly missing the point. Its not a Comedy, Its more then that. The same applied to Only fools, it was half comedy, half drama. Thats why it was so good. Anyone who has realy watched the sitcom will tell you that it can make you cry just as much as it can make you laugh. Rock and chips reflected Only fools perfectly in that aspect. As well as this,the casting was brilliant. Hats off to James Buckley, who played del brilliantly. I was worried that i would be watching Jay from the inbetweeners, but thankfully i was not, i saw a young Del boy. My only negative, is that Nicholas lyndhurst was to like rodney, but i have come to expect that from other shows he has been in. Having said that, he needed to play the role and the actors were all very good. And before anyone says, i am not a stubborn only fools fan that that insists upon likeing any only fools spin off, I thought green green grass was awful. This however was historicaly accurate, Well written, and a pleasure to watch. Well done John sulliven.

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By A1nostalgia 1 January 25, 2010 01:06:37 PM

Rodney asks Trigger why he calls him "Dave" in the episode Homesick from series 3. Rodney and Trigger are sat in the town hall waiting for a meeting to begin: RODNEY: Trig, why do you call me Dave? My name's Rodney NOT Dave... TRIGGER:Is it? I always thought it was Dave... you sure? RODNEY: YES!quite sure, it's on my birth certificate and everything and it's most definitely Rodney! TRIGGER: Oh, you live and learn! I shall have to get used to calling you "Rodney" then... Impatiently Trigger shouts at the chairman... TRIGGER: Come on mate, Dave and me ain't got all day! RODNEY: RODNEY!! TRIGGER: Yeah, yeah! ;O)

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By A1nostalgia 1 January 25, 2010 01:14:34 PM

Would have loved the scene where everyone expresses surprise at the naming of the baby (Rodney?!!)to have ended with a confused Trigger going "Dave?!!" ;o)

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By Robmac 1 January 25, 2010 01:39:00 PM

re: A1nostalgia - oh, i didnt know that about 'Dave'. I shall have to fish out my Only Fools videos thanks!

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By Robmac 1 January 25, 2010 01:41:53 PM

hmmmm - Nick Frost as Uncle Albert?

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By A1nostalgia 1 January 25, 2010 04:14:11 PM

According to the entry on IMDB, Uncle Albert was due to feature along with Juney Snell, Blossom and Monkey Harris. Tho if you check the biogs of the designated actors, they only appear to have worked on Rock and Chips.... hmmm! John Sullivan is on record as saying the title refers to his favourite meal in the sixties and it was shortened so as not to get the wrong audience as on EPGs it would be abbreviated to "Sex and Drugs...". The full title is indeed a homage to the late, great Ian Dury as the reviewer mentioned...

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By cordas2 1 January 25, 2010 10:06:02 PM

Damn that was good, I am sure there will be a series off the back of it. I liked how they didn't try to cram to much OFaH into it, but did get the little details right. The only missing was Marleen, but I am sure she will appear in the series.

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By bcns74 1 January 25, 2010 10:32:18 PM

Big thing I have against the old freddie robdel story is that it was developed to give an end when Sullivan had already finished the story (millionaire) but then had to bring it back... The real story in the frogs legacy was that Del didn't know Freddie and didn't meet him and had to ask Reenie about him. In truth the writing then would have had Del being nieve to his mums 'friends'. In legacy he didnt know his name or anything about him. In the rubbish last episodes they'd been to Margate on a JB Outing together.... To circulate Rock and Chips around this just highlights the one rubbish bit in an otherwise fantastic show...

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By A1nostalgia 1 January 25, 2010 11:07:39 PM

I enjoyed the drama and was prepared to suspend my disbelief.However, I agree with much of the above comment. There are several continuity errors if you really want to pick holes: Perhaps Del had some kind memory loss in Frogs Legacy?! Also the Joan Sims version of Reenie states Joan met Robdal "about 1959"! Rodney is also supposed to have been born in 1962 (like Nick Lyndhurst)as he states in And The Unlucky Winner Is... (1989) that he is 26 and a half. Joan died in 1963, the headstone seen in the Yellow Peril (1982) suggests yet the one seen in As One Door Closes (1985)Says 1965! Delboy's age is a bit of an issue too. Clearly he is supposed to be sixteen here, yet he states when Reg left the family, he took his 16th birthday cake! In Big Brother Del asks Rodney why he couldn't come along 2 or 3 years later... rather than 13 years later. In Go West Young Man (1981) Del tells Rodney not to mention the fact he is 35. This makes him 14 in 1960 but 16 in 1962 when Rodney is supposed to be born. In 1986's Tea For Two, however, Rodney tells Lisa Del's 46th birthday is coming up.This would make him the same age as David Jason at that time. But that would mean Delboy ages 11 summers in just 5 years...Talk about a tough life! Either the characters and actors ages are being confused or else everyone seems vague when dating things. Then again name a tv show free of continuity errors. If there was we wouldn't have as much to talk about here!... ;o)

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By clementine 1 January 26, 2010 01:47:32 PM

Dores it really matter in the greater scheme of things your being a bit pedantic about it, and it still doesn change the fact that genuine ofah fans really liked it.

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By A1nostalgia 1 January 26, 2010 03:30:40 PM

No it doesn't matter that much, just wanted to get it out of my system!;o)It's only TV after all! Unlike Green,Green Grass this was a great spin off idea with plenty to enjoy. I'm really looking forward to seeing a full series... maybe in the autumn? ;o)

Re: Rock And Chips review
Posted By clementine 1 January 29, 2010 01:31:52 PM

me too i really really enjoyed it. Green green grass was a spin off ot heartbeat was it? never a fan really i thought they overdid the whole sixties theme it always seemed forced to me.
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image
 
 
Rock And Chips

Rock And Chips

Untitled Document

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Coke Zero
Advertisement