Why The Hunger Games Outlasted its YA Counterparts
Sunrise on the Reaping proves that The Hunger Games is the undisputed champion of young adult literature.
This week, The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping hits theaters, adapting Suzanne Collins’s recent prequel novel. Said prequel digs into the early years of Haymitch Abernathy a.k.a. Katniss Everdeen’s surly mentor, and how his time in the Games left long-lasting scars on him. Some fans have questioned the necessity of Sunrise on the Reaping in both novel and movie form; those same fans also raised similar concerns following the release of the first Hunger Games prequel, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. Given how derivative most prequels usually tend to turn out, and the dominance of IP in Hollywood, the question remains: “How much can you still squeeze out of the Hunger Games?”
The answer, as it turns out, is quite a bit! Both The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes and Sunrise on the Reaping take place years before the events of The Hunger Games, and cover the 10th Hunger Games and the 50th Hunger Games, respectively. That means there’s a lot of potential ground that Collins could cover. How did the Hunger Games begin? What led to the rise of Panem and the 12 Districts? Those events have remained a mystery, but if Collins plays her cards right, she can build out this universe in ways that are unexpected and add more depth to the original series.
Speaking of the original series, the reason The Hunger Games franchise continues to thrive is that many of its books feel timely. Collins has said that the original was born out of channel surfing and stumbling upon a reality show at the same time she witnessed a news report on the invasion of Iraq; the unsettling mix led to her concocting the original idea of The Hunger Games (despite some claiming that she lifted it wholesale from the Japanese dystopian novel and film Battle Royale). Similarly, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes was released around the time of the COVID-19 pandemic, which caused a major upheaval in people’s lives, and Sunrise on the Reaping is a tale of revolution and struggling against a massive system in a time where many in the West don’t have much faith in their governments.
Those themes help keep The Hunger Games timely in a way that most young adult books struggle to achieve. The Twilight books wound up aging poorly due to people eventually clocking the power imbalance in the relationship between Bella Swan and Edward Cullen. Fifty Shades of Grey aged even worse because of its less than flattering depiction of BDSM relationships. Harry Potter has become a massive powder keg thanks to J.K. Rowling, and HBO’s upcoming adaptation is facing a massive uphill battle due to the Potter movies still remaining fresh in people’s minds (it also doesn’t help that this year marks the 25th anniversary of the Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone movie.)
What also makes The Hunger Games stand out from other book to movie adaptations is how it unflinchingly depicts the struggles within its world. Teenagers are forced to fight for their lives in a hostile, carefully crafted environment. Any threat to the ruling class is quickly snuffed out or brainwashed away. Even original series protagonist Katniss Everdeen struggles with becoming a symbol for a revolution, as the televised propaganda and the plans of would-be president Alma Coin run far too close to what she went through in the Games. In a world where many books are either fanfiction with the serial numbers filed off or heavily curated for “BookTok,” the Hunger Games saga sticks with readers thanks to its shades of gray.
The reaction to Sunrise on the Reaping more or less proves The Hunger Games is here to stay. Reviews are turning out to be mostly positive, fans are ecstatic to see original Hunger Games stars Jennifer Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson reunite on the red carpet, and McKenna Grace, who plays Haymitch’s fellow tribute and love interest Maysilee Donner, has been taking the fashion world by storm with her Hunger Games-inspired looks. While no future Hunger Games books have been announced, Suzanne Collins has created the rare young adult series that resonates to this day.