Requiem for the Red Shirts: Remembering the Best Deaths of Inconsequential Star Trek Characters
We celebrate those unheralded crewpeople who gave their lives to prove that space exploration is scary.
Even if you don’t know Star Trek, you know about Red Shirts. The term has seeped off the Enterprise and into popular culture, a way to describe a meaningless character who exists only to die, thereby establishing the threat to other characters, presumably those we care about. The term came from The Original Series’ tendency to introduce someone in the Operations department, identified by their red uniforms, only for them to die in front of Kirk and Spock.
Star Trek fans know that the red shirt phenomenon persisted even after The Next Generation changed the uniform color scheme, so that now Command officers wear red and Operations officers wear gold. They also know that crewman across all of Starfleet can be Red Shirts, as long as they die in memorable ways. Most importantly, they know that Red Shirts deserve respect as important storyteller engines.
Those are the Red Shirts we’ve come to praise today, the minor characters who gained meaning by dying so that the rest of the story could be told.
Crewmen Mathews and Rayburn, “What Little Girls are Made Of” (TOS)
We have to start with Crewmen Matthews and Rayburn (Vince Deadrick and Budd Albright), if only because they kicked off the phenomenon. The duo accompanied Kirk and Nurse Chapel to the Planet Exo III, to visit the latter’s former fiancé, Dr. Roger Korby. As they dig into Korby’s strange behavior, they encounter Ruk, a gigantic android, who proves his might by dispatching the two security officers. Ruk knocks Matthews off a precipice and strangles Rayburn, shuffling them off this mortal coil and into pop culture history.
Lieutenant Arlene Galway, “The Deadly Years” (TOS)
Sometimes, Red Shirts catch our attention because of the danger posed by the baddie, as in the case of the menacing Ruk and the secret of Dr. Korby. Sometimes, Red Shirts catch our attention for the terrible way that they died, as with Lt. Galway (Beverly Washburn) in the TOS season two episode, “The Deadly Years.” Shortly after returning from an away mission, the young Galway begins showing signs of old age, and quickly dies. Although the limited budget prevents Galway’s expiration from looking like, say, Donavan’s death from Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade, the obvious makeup and wig only make Galway look all the more unsightly, and her death all the more upsetting.
Commander Sonak and Unnamed Female Officer (Star Trek: The Motion Picture)
For the most part, the first Star Trek movie emphasizes contemplation over action. Furthermore, the crew had moved from the bright colors of their original uniform to comfy earth-tone pajamas. But The Motion Picture did carry on the Red Shirt tradition, in the most horrifying way possible. As Captain Dekker’s crew comes together on the Enterprise, they hit a snag when science officer Sonak (Jon Rashad Kamal) and an unnamed officer meld together in a transporter accident. The scene seems to go on forever, as the two melded figures scream in agony. We never get a good look at what actually happens to the duo, but the transporter chief back on Earth tells us everything we need to know, saying, “What we got back didn’t live long—fortunately.”
Ensign Peter Preston (Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan)
Even in a utopian future, nepotism still happens. So even though Ensign Peter Preston (Ike Eisenmann), who gets burned alive during Khan’s attack on the Enterprise in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, is no more than a Red Shirt, we feel something for him. That’s because he’s the nephew of Montgomery Scott, who memorably carried Preston’s body onto the bridge and lamented, “He stayed at his post.” In that moment, Scotty’s sadness becomes our own, reminding us that Red Shirts are people who matter beyond their story purposes.
Ensign Haskell, “Where Silence Has Lease” (TNG)
More than any other post-TOS series, The Next Generation kept the tradition of the Red Shirts going. In fact, it gave us one of the most famous Red Shirts in franchise history, thanks to the meme made from his sudden death scene in the season 2 episode, “Where Silence Has Lease.” Played by Charles Douglass, Ensign Haskell is serving as conn officer when the Enterprise encounters a godlike being known as Nagilum. Upon learning about humans’ limited lifespan, the Nagilum explores the concept of death by killing Haskell. The officer suddenly grabs his forehead and falls to the floor, a cruel fate that reminds us of the dangers in exploring the unknown.
Lieutenant jg Van Mayter, “In Theory” (TNG)
The fear of liminal spaces may be a modern phenomenon, but as the movie Backrooms showed us, it’s a fear rooted in the media of the late ’80s and early ’90s. So we shouldn’t be a surprise to find a bit of liminal space horror in the season four TNG episode “In Theory,” first aired in 1991. As the Enterprise goes through a nebula, strange things begin happening on the ship. The most memorably occurs when Lt. jg Van Mayter (Georgina Shore), the rare Red Shirt who appeared in several episodes, turns down a corridor and screams. When Geordi rushes in to help, he finds her stuck in the floor, having briefly phased through the deck and rematerialized in solid metal, crushing her organs.
Ensign Sito Jaxa, “Lower Decks” (TNG)
Most Red Shirts only appear in one episode, and most play only supporting roles. But we need to bend the rules a little for Ensign Sito Jaxa, the Red Shirt who gives true meaning to the phenomenon. Played by Shannon Fill, the Bajoran Sito was one of four minor characters who get the spotlight in the TNG season seven classic, “Lower Decks.” Most of the episode focuses on the daily lives of the people who do the grunt work while the bridge crew has adventures, so she functions like a Red Shirt, right up unto her death on a secret mission to Cardassia Prime. But the attention she received on “Lower Decks,” and in the animated series Lower Decks, shows how much Sito mattered to the people who loved her.
Crewman Amaro, “Empok Nor” (DS9)
With Deep Space Nine came a break in the standard Trek format, and with it, a move away from the Red Shirts. With surprising regularity in Deep Space Nine, Voyager, and Enterprise, random crew people would either die off-screen, or as part of a group, diminishing their individual significance. One of the most important exceptions came in the excellent DS9 season five episode, “Empok Nor.” As O’Brien and Garak lead a crew of Starfleet officers to the titular abandoned space station, they find themselves hunted by an unknown enemy and threatened by paranoia, especially as their members die. One such victim was security officer Amaro (Jeffrey King), who gets killed by Garak, driven mad by the drugs. Amaro’s death shows us not just the danger posed by the space station, but also serves as a reminder that Garak cannot be trusted.
Lieutenant Pete Durst, “Faces” (VOY)
For all Voyager did right, it was a show marked by missed opportunities, such as making the forgettable Kazon the big bads instead of the truly terrifying Vidiians. A race of scavengers suffering from degenerative diseases, the Vidiians travel the Delta Quadrant to steal body parts from their victims to replace their own deteriorating pieces. The results were horrifying, as when Lt. Pete Durst (Brian Markinson) dies in Vidiian captivity. Rather than let his organs go to waste, the Vidian surgeon Sulan grafts Durst’s face in place of his own, resulting in a visual worthy of Leatherface.
Lieutenant Saul Ramon (SNW: “Lost in Translation”)
For all the throwbacks it does, the prequel series Strange New Worlds hasn’t fully revived the Red Shirt tradition. Yet, it does sometimes kill off a minor character on screen, as demonstrated by season two’s “Lost in Translation.” Throughout the episode, Lt. Saul Ramon (Michael Reventar) has strange responses to an unidentifiable sound. He grows increasingly paranoid, trying to destroy the ship before finally destroying himself by ejecting a fuel pod. Despite Uhura’s attempts to reach him, Ramon blows up the pod, ripping a hole in the ship and sucking him out into the emptiness of space.