The Following episode 1 review: Pilot

Review Ron Hogan 22 Jan 2013 - 07:33

Ron checks out the pilot episode of Fox's The Following, starring Kevin Bacon and James Purefoy...

This review contains spoilers.

1.1 Pilot

In the halls of a maximum-security prison in Waverly, Virginia, sits Dr. Joe Carroll, an English professor and fanatical Edgar Allen Poe fan turned serial killer. He's a very dangerous man, and when he ends up missing and half-a-dozen guards are found slashed to death, he proves just how dangerous he is. Now Carroll is free from justice, on the prowl for Sarah Fuller (Maggie Grace) aka the one that got away. 

Ten years ago, there was only one man able to stop Carroll's killing spree, and that's Ryan Hardy (Kevin Bacon), a brilliant FBI agent. In the course of stopping Carroll, Hardy suffered a stab wound into his heart which damaged the muscle and ended Hardy's career as a field agent. Now he's an author with a true crime book and a healthy disability pension from the government as a result of his injuries, and he's still the only one who can stop Joe Carroll. Hence, Hardy is called in as an adviser to a collection of field agents, including hero-worshiper Mike Weston (Shawn Ashmore), who are looking to stop Carroll before he kills again. 

Unfortunately, things are different this time around. All serial killers attract a certain amount of personal followers, either during their crimes like Charles Manson or after the fact. And Joe Carroll has himself quite a following (pardon the pun) thanks to the internet and his incredible presence on social media, blogs, chat rooms, and whatnot. Carroll is the mastermind; turns out he's got a whole bunch of puppets at his disposal and that makes things much, much trickier. 

The Following's debut episode seems to shoehorn a few episodes' worth of character introductions into an hour. I spent a great deal of time this episode simply typing character names and vague descriptions of the actors (Asian girl, black guy, Maggie Grace, dude who looks like fake Justin Timberlake) to look them up on the IMDb later. For the first half of the episode, a new character seems to show up every other scene and introduce himself to Hardy, and that makes the show a little too hard to follow at first. However, once the introductions slow down, the serial killer action really starts to kick up. 

Plot-wise, The Following has a great set-up for a television series. You've got your hero in the form of Kevin Bacon and his followers/FBI agents and your big-bad serial killer in James Purefoy and his followers/monsters of the week. That leads you to have the potential for both season-wide arcs and smaller multi-story or single-story episodes that serve to progress the plot along without making the villain too central. The show uses a lot of tropes and stock characters, but there's a trickling undercurrent of awareness that you'd expect from Kevin Williamson and the premise's literary back story. Hardy knows he's the tragic hero in Joe Carroll's literary masterwork; Carroll knows he's the villain and puppet master. 

That's a pretty good base for a television show, and it has the benefit of having two really solid leads in Kevin Bacon and James Purefoy. This is definitely Bacon's show, and he really embraces the role. For all the Six Degrees stuff, he's a really good actor when given material, and while this show isn't exactly the best stuff he's ever had to work with, it's interesting enough and he's able to make some hay with it. The other characters on both sides haven't really been explored, since you need to hook your viewers with the lead early and then flesh the others out when you have time. Kevin Bacon is really good at balancing tough and terrified at the same time, and giving him the physical limitation of a bad heart is a great way to keep him from becoming another Jack Bauer-type Superman.  

The show also feels very big, at least as the first episode goes. Having a bankable star and what appears to be a big budget definitely helps, and director Marcos Siega helps make The Following look slick and moody from his position behind the camera.It's definitely not afraid of gore and there are some very clever, disturbing set pieces. Some of it is simple shock value, but I am not opposed to that (after all, I watch The Walking Dead). I don't think it's tenable over the long term, but I think the show will find its feet in the coming weeks. 

US Correspondent Ron Hogan is always glad to see Kevin Bacon, and it appears that he's picked a pretty good project if he wants to be the best thing about his new show. Find more by Ron daily at Shaktronics and PopFi.

Follow our Twitter feed for faster news and bad jokes right here. And be our Facebook chum here.

Disqus - noscript

Just finished it. Solid start with lots of potential. Good program for a Monday night, not much else on.

Looking forward to this. Hope it's only a one season thing though. Hate how they drag ideas like this out across seasons.

Two of my favourite actors in Purefoy & Bacon; a solid beginning with potential to go anywhere...this could be truly excellent.

Remember watching this wayyyyy back in July at Comic-Con. It was bloody creepy back then, and it's probably the same now. I'm afraid it's not my cup of tea but there seems to be a lot of potential

So basically another cop show?

Unless "he's got a whole bunch of puppets at his disposal" is to be taken literally.

It's another cop show, but with a really good lead and an interesting gimmick. It could easily become another 24 but with a bit more brains.

Sounds like a bit of a "Red Dragon/Silence of the Lambs" mash up.

Spoilers -

Surprised at what happened to Maggie Grace's character, Purefoy better hope Liam Neeson doesn't find out....

It's actually more like Manhunter, the first Lechter movie, than Red Dragon.

cliches at every turn, beginning with a world-weary ex-fbi agent who is now alcoholic and called back to investigate a high profile crime.

Manhunter is Red Dragon dude, its based on the novel Red Dragon. Did I just feed a troll? ;)

So I watched this earlier. Yeah, I'm afraid it left me completely cold.

This offered nothing that hasn't already been done better somewhere else... e.g. Manhunter, Se7en, and most notably, 1995 Sigourney Weaver thriller Copycat.

My biggest problem, though? The fact that the constant flashbacks made it feel like the vastly inferior sequel to a previous, much more entertaining 2003 season of the show. A season which unfortunately doesn't, er, exist...

What a waste. I loved the idea of having a Kevin Bacon-fronted show to watch on tuesday nights...

Couldn't help thinking when Bacon went to abandoned lighthouse building he would start doing some footloose moves


How did the nanny leave the house with the boy? So many guards, police and protection agents and yet she just walks away with him while the mother is in the house?

I know they're based on the same book, but they're pretty different in tone (to me).

It's Not That bad.

Same here, I prefere monster of the week. I generally HATE serialised drama. But this looks good and Dark. It would be a good movie or mini series, I can't see this concept lasting one season, FOX will no doubt cancel it like they did with Alcatraz (to big a concept to carry a season)

I don't give it much hope. Aside from Kevin Bacon, I don't like any of the characters, the casting, or the acting. It's not even that dramatic. Where did this show come from? If they fire the director and get some writing it could work, or maybe it's the acting, but it's probably too late for change. Of course I could be wrong or maybe I am just spoiled from watching Dexter. ;) I'll stay tuned for Kevin Bacon's presence and hope that it improves.

Sponsored Links