Revisiting Star Trek TNG: Angel One

Review James Hunt 4 Jan 2013 - 07:39

James' season one TNG look-back comes to a truly horrible episode...

This review contains spoilers.

1.14 Angel One

Oh good, it's Angel One. Wait, did I say good? I'm fairly sure that's not what I meant at all.

On the way to the Neutral zone where the Romulans are causing trouble, the Enterprise drops in on Angel One to search for the possible survivors of a freighter disaster some years earlier. The planet is a strange one where (if you accept the episode's highly dubious premise) social gender roles are flipped, so that the females are more dominant and physically imposing, and males are slight and weak-willed. You know, like the opposite of what is on Earth! (This might be a new record: a Star Trek episode whose ingrained prejudices undermine its point at the premise level, before a word has been written).

Subtle, it is not. The planet is a matriarchy when men are required to walk around in flesh-baring costumes and the woman do pretty much everything to subjugate them except slap their asses patronisingly and call them doll. Troi finally gets to do something: as the most female person on the bridge, she's given the task of calling the leader of Angel One, Mistress Beata, and asking if they can come look for survivors. Beata and her matriarchy get all cagey over the subject, which as we know, means there are definitely survivors and they're definitely causing problems.

Meanwhile, on the Enterprise, Wesley and his friends have caught a cold after going on a skiing trip on the holodeck. I'm not even kidding.

Back on the surface, Beata admits that yes, there were survivors, and that they and their leader – an eighties action-hero of a man named Ramsay, who sports a mane of golden mullet hair – are considered dangerous fugitives. In the interest of promoting good relations, Riker dons some of Angel One's traditional male clothing as an act of "diplomacy", which leads to a lot of audience gagging over the sheer amount of chest hair on display. Troi and Yar find it hilarious, justifiably.

Meanwhile, on the Enterprise, Picard has caught Wesley's cold and been ordered to bed. I'm not even kidding.

The crew manages to locate the survivors, and it turns out that Ramsay and his crewmen have started the local version of the suffragette movement, campaigning for male equality, and even taking indigenous wives from their growing supporters. They don't want to leave, and the crew can't make them. While this is going on, Riker and Beata are doing some wholly diplomatic making out, and Beata seems pleased to have a man around who isn't grimly subjugated and soggy-willed, begging the question of why she's so against male equality in the first place.

Meanwhile, on the Enterprise Geordi is in charge, but a third of the crew have colds and if the Romulans attack they'll all be too snotty to fight back. I'm not even kidding.

The away team return to Beata, interrupting that earth custom they call "kissing", and inform Riker that they've found everyone but can't really do anything about it because they're not Starfleet and don't have to follow orders. Beata responds by sentencing the survivors (and their sympathisers) to death. Because everyone knows all alien judicial systems have only two sentences: summary death sentence without trial, and mind-jail.

Meanwhile, on the Enterprise, everyone has a cold and the ship has been quarantined. I'm not even kidding.

Data is allowed to return while Riker and the others hang around hoping to avert the execution. While they do, thanks to a moralising speech and claims that killing Ramsay will result in nothing but his martyrdom. Ramsay and his sympathisers are exiled to a remote part of the world where they can build their equal civilisation in peace.

Meanwhile, on the Enterprise, Crusher develops a cure for the cold, the away team is allowed to return, and the episode ends with Picard unable to give his orders to leave due to a sore throat. I'm not even kidding.

TNG WTF: Let us leave aside the sheer WTF-ness of an episode that thinks it's holding a mirror up to our own society's sexism by showing an entire matriarchy going weak at the knees for Riker in an open shirt, and instead concentrate on the real stupidity of the episode: Did Wesley really catch a cold by going skiing on the holodeck? Does the writer of this episode not know that COLDS DO NOT WORK THAT WAY?!

TNG LOL: Beata addresses Ramsay as she demonstrates the execution vaporiser: "As you can see we are not without compassion. Your deaths will be swift and painless." I'm sure he's very comforted.

Who's that face?: Ariel, one of Beata's fellow rulers, is played by Patricia McPherson, who was KITT's mechanic Bonnie Barstow in the original Knight Rider series.

Time Until Meeting: A meeting-free episode. The mark of a writer who doesn't know how TNG works.

Captain's Log: Wow. When season one of TNG is bad, it's almost unapologetically awful. It's not quite Code of Honor levels of offensive, but it is notable for containing almost every terrible cliché about seen in TNG's first season in one episode. A virus on the ship, a "primitive" society based on laboured allegory, Prime directive hand-wringing and, let us not forget, a death sentence ticking clock. All it needed was Wesley to save the day and it would've been a full house. We've seen all of this before, and it was barely interesting the first time around. The second time, it's just tedious. A horrible episode on so many levels.

Watch or Skip? Definite skip.

Read James' look-back at the previous episode, Datalore, here.

Follow our Twitter feed for faster news and bad jokes right here. And be our Facebook chum here.

Disqus - noscript

After watching this again over Christmas on the Syfy re-runs I knew this review was going to be an especially fun read! Nice work, and it almost makes you wonder how TNG ever became the success it was with a start like this!

Just one question... are you kidding? :P

A lot of good will, plus the presence of Patrick Stewart and Brent Spiner...

Love the bit in this episode where they call the ship, expecting to speak to whoever's in command, and Crusher answers:

Riker: Riker to Enterprise
Crusher: This is Enterprise, Crusher here
*Yar looks at Riker, horrified*
Yar: It must be worse up there than we thought!

Love that the idea of Crusher in charge must mean things have gotten *really* bad.

If it were made today, considering how impatient TV networks are these days for a hit, there no way the show would have survived...

The Data subplot where he buys time for the crew on the ship is actually classy, well-written stuff...

...But it's a shame that every other scene in this episode of "Star Drek: The Horny Creator's Attempt To Ruin His Fledgling Sequel" was as poorly written, cliched, scribbled out, and as horned up as it got. Next to "Justice", also rewritten by the Great Hornball of the Galaxy, "Angel One" is almost a classic by comparison...

"Planet of the shoulder pads and big mullets" is easy on the eyes, but the story is sheer 1D garbage... which is not a sham because it manages to be far more original than, say, the movie "Avatar"...

And how the virus could be created on the holodeck, then spread throughout the ship... season 1 is so inconsistent with their new innovative invention, but in this 'story' it goes out of its way to be inept. Didn't previous episodes already confirm that no holodeck-generated matter can survive outside of the holodeck?

I'm surprised TNG survived back in the day, thanks to how bad half of the first season truly is... once Roddenberry was put on the back seat, the true nature of the show started to bloom... oh, don't get me wrong - he had a knack for finding the right actors (and was convinced by Justman re: Patrick Stewart), and TBH it's the actors' efforts that made and kept the momentum going, but Roddenberry's insistence on season 1 rewrites almost killed the show. "Gene Roddenberry - The Man and the Myth Behind Star Trek" is a great book to read...

Such a shame ST-TNG has for the most part dated so badly. It was good at the time though, and I'm thankful it happened when it did, but trying to watch a Next gen episode nowadays is simply an exercise embarassment for the most part.

DS9 ,Classic & seasons 3 & 4 of Enterprise are still the best of all the Treks in my opinion.

Slating


Apparently the writer also forgot they cured the common cold by the 24th century ( or at least by this time of season one) as established in the preceding episode 'Datalore'
Wesley: Have you got a cold?Data: A cold what?Wesley: It's a disease my mother says people used to get

this is one of several unexplained pre-warp contacts in the first season.....its just kinda lazy not to mention some history of pre-starfleet cultural contamination at least, but really why even put that pointless tid-bit in and let us just assume there early warp!

Sponsored Links