Den of Geek

Stargate Universe episode 10 review

Carl England


One or two spoilers if you've not seen the episode yet, but as Stargate Universe heads off on its break, it's in fine form...

Published on Nov 30, 2009


10. Justice

We've had sci-fi, and we've had drama, and this week it's time for a detective story.

When Sgt Spencer is found dead in his quarters from a gunshot to the head, each of the crew start to suspect each other. When an inquisition is held, the crew are put under the microscope, with Dr Rush getting a lot of the heat.

With this story, we get to see a lot of characters show a defensive side that we haven't seen yet. We've been seeing a lot of emotional scenes, but not a lot of true conversational back and forth with this much ferocity. A lot of the writing in this episode is about that kind of conversation, coming to a head between various characters, and as a result some of the best moments of the season crop up.

On the sci-fi side of things, Dr Rush pushes his research of the Ancient Repository forward, with differing results. As well as this, there's a new alien planet for the crew to explore with some interesting plot threads that begin there. Obviously, to say any more would leave this review unreadable to folks that haven't yet seen it, but let's just say there are some hugely interesting plot developments here.

Justice is one of those episodes that will be a turning point, not only for the series, but for the viewers too. For the series, there are a lot of good things going on, that ramp up every plotline to exactly where they need to be for the mid-season break. For the viewers, it's really the point where they decide not only if the series is worth watching more of, but also if they do, whose side they are on.

The tension between Col Young and Dr Rush really comes to a climax in the final scenes of the episode and it will most likely set the tone for the entire second half of the series' run. There are rivalries cropping up all over the ship, too, and the amount of tension felt through the screen is immense.

The performances here are some of the best certain characters have put in yet. Elyse Levesque's Chloe Armstrong has, unfortunately, been relatively forgettable up until now, but her few scenes in the inquisition are some of the strongest, not only of her work, but of the entire episode. I was quite surprised by the level of attitude she brings to the role, but Levesque shows that she is truly capable of better than how she was written previously, and hopefully, this will help her character bloom.

Of course, this episode turns out to be all about Rush and Young's clashing egos and Robert Carlyle and Justin Louis hand in the best performances of the episode. It's a testament not only to the quality of the actors, but also to the writing of their characters. Everything comes to a head so well and decisions are made that can never be unmade, leaving the series in an entirely different place from before. A place that will be interesting to pick up from when the series returns in the New Year.

I, for one, haven't seen a series with this many ups and downs in quite a while, but I'm happy to conclude that the ups outweigh the downs by a considerable amount, and that those ups make this a series worth watching.

Robert Carlyle has been an absolute dream pairing for the role of Dr Rush, and his work alone is well worth tuning in for.

This episode shows a series on a high, and hopefully, one that can continue for as long as is possible.

I am eagerly awaiting the conclusion to this cliff-hanger, and hope that the break will not be for too long.

Check out our review of episode 9 here.

Stargate Universe is showing in the UK on Sky1 and Sky1 HD every Tuesday.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Stargate Universe episode 10 review
Posted By iratecaller666 1 November 30, 2009 01:13:08 PM

So SGU is still all-drama- all-the-time. I'm afraid that it's no longer science fiction and that my worst fears came true. I stopped watching after the fourth episode and periodically check reviews to see if things get better. Episode 10, based on this article, is still all just talking and drama. I purchased everything this franchise had to offer until SGU. SGU , seems to be enjoyable by some, but it's a far cry from the action sci-fi that made this franchise what it is today. I'm glad some people like it, but I only wish that I could enjoy it as well. I was hoping that the show would carefully balance drama, science (fiction) and action , but with obviously more emphasis on action and science. I'm sad.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 10 review
Posted By masteryoda007 1 November 30, 2009 04:31:31 PM

I have to disagree with you there iratecaller. I think that SGU is really good. Maybe they shpuld just call it "Begbie is Space" but I would watch Robert Carlye paint a fence because he is that good of an actor and he raises this series up from the hum drum Stargate world of previous incarnations. The rest of the cast are growing on me too like the wee nerdy guy and the colonel. I find the series very watchable especially when compared to some other shite out there. Hey it is no Battlestar but it will definatley do.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 10 review
Posted By iratecaller666 1 November 30, 2009 11:34:58 PM

Fair enough masteryoda.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 10 review
Posted By starlight 1 December 1, 2009 09:50:54 AM

@iratecaller666: leave it, man. it is drama, it is not sci fi, it is not stargate and it will not change. i know how you feel, but our stargate is no more. it's not a mistake - it is the way the producers wanted it to be. so let masteryoda dance over the dead body of our show and enjoy the moment while he still can. -- my 2 cent

Re: Stargate Universe episode 10 review
Posted By stuxmusic 1 December 2, 2009 03:35:12 PM

See, I don't agree. SG-1 was brilliant, to a point. They ended up doing the same things again and again, and when it came to the switch up in season 9 that was it really, 9 and 10 had their moments but there were very few. Only the TVM brought back some fun and were much better. Another thing they put in there though, was drama. Watch them back, they are quite drama heavy. SGU is an inevitable step forward and I applaud them for not making SG-2 or some other re-hash.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 10 review
Posted By starlight 1 December 2, 2009 10:30:13 PM

@stuxmusic: let's agree to disagree.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 10 review
Posted By stuxmusic 1 December 5, 2009 12:14:29 PM

You're probably the only one, mate. You're probably the only one.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 10 review
Posted By cordas 1 December 9, 2009 12:26:29 PM

Just seen this episode and I think it was simply fantastic, not sure how its 'not scifi' that really baffles me as it quite clearly is scifi, just scifi thats light on aliens and space battles... That doesn't stop it being scifi. I would also like to drag Sgt Greer to the front as a a character who I am really wanting to see on screen more, the actor is really making a character I thought I would hate above all others into the limelight and doing him justice!

Re: Stargate Universe episode 10 review
Posted By Tippon 1 December 9, 2009 11:47:18 PM

Starting to really enjoy this now, after a slow start, but the ending of this episode was brilliant! Can't wait to watch the next one :)

Re: Stargate Universe episode 10 review
Posted By krissil 1 December 10, 2009 09:28:07 PM

I am a huge fan of the older stargates but i have to say i love the new direction SGU has gone in. I am dying to know where that little shuttle took off to episodes ago.
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image
 
 
Stargate Universe

Stargate Universe

Untitled Document

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Coke Zero
Advertisement