Invasion Of The Body Snatchers 1978: a remake done right

Feature Ryan Lambie 13 Dec 2013 - 06:52

Few remakes are as clever or scary as 1978's Invasion Of The Body Snatchers. Ryan explains what other directors could learn from the film...

Walk into any DIY store or cut-price supermarket, and you're likely to hear a familiar tune sung by an unfamiliar voice. It might be a cover version of Tracy Chapman's 80s hit Fast Car, or maybe Queen's Crazy Little Thing Called Love.

There's nothing necessarily wrong with these alternate renditions of well-known songs - the singing's in key, the guitar playing's perfectly confident, but at the same time, there's no escaping that something's missing. An edge has been knocked off somewhere. It all sounds a little bit too sanitised.

Predictably, this brings us to the headline topic: the movie remake. They're nothing new, and we're all familiar with the process of plucking an old, familiar name from the archives, and producing a new version of it with current actors and sharper special effects. And while there are plenty of examples of great, even brilliant remakes - we'll be getting to the pertinent one very shortly - it's often the case that remakes end up like the cinematic equivalent of those songs mentioned above: perfectly competent, yet missing a vital bit of creative warmth.

Take, for example, 2012's Total Recall. Despite producer Neal Mortiz's pre-release insistence that Len Wiseman's film would be a "closer" new interpretation of Philip K Dick's We Can Remember It For You Wholesale, it actually bore a far closer resemblance to Paul Verhoeven's loose adaptation released in 1990. There wasn't necessarily anything wrong with the resulting film - it looked slick, and it ticked along at a decent pace - but again, something was missing. That spark of absurdist Verhoeven anarchy. That sly humour lurking beneath the surface.

Philip Kaufman's 1978 remake of Invasion Of The Body Snatchers is the absolute antithesis of something like Total Recall. It doesn't play out like a broadened, flattened reworking of Don Siegel's classic original, but an inspired companion piece. Naturally, it takes ideas from the 1956 version, but it does new things with them, subverts them, and presents them in unexpected ways. 

Don Siegel's original Invasion Of The Body Snatchers, adapted from a novel by Jack Finney, saw a small Californian town subjected to an extraterrestrial takeover of the most insidious sort. One by one, its inhabitants are replaced by expressionless clones hatched from pods, and while mild-mannered local doctor Miles Bennell (Kevin McCarthy) uncovers the whole plot, he's too late to prevent the invasion.

Arriving at a time when anti-communist paranoia was at its height, Invasion Of The Body Snatchers is widely described as one of the finest examples of the era's 'reds under the bed' science fiction films. But beyond the political allegories that have been read into it over the years - allegories that author Jack Finney and actor Kevin McCarthy have said were unintentional - Body Snatchers is also a chilling film about conformity and free will. That it takes place in a sleepy town where everyone knows each other is what makes the eventual takeover all the more effective; a society connected by familiarity, warmth and friendship is quietly replaced by one devoid of emotion.

Phillip Kaufman's remake cleverly shifts the Body Snatchers location from a small town to San Francisco - a sprawling city where warmth and familiarity are already in short supply. In Kaufman's version of Body Snatchers, the invasion is horrifying not because family and friends are being replaced by emotionless copies, but because everyone's too busy and self-interested to even notice. 

In remaking Invasion Of The Body Snatchers, Kaufman also had the opportunity to fix the original's studio-enforced happy ending. Siegel had originally intended for his movie to end with the unforgettable sight of Kevin McCarthy's doctor standing on a freeway, cars hurtling left and right, as he bellows into the camera, "They're here already! You're next!"

Unfortunately, Allied Artists found the conclusion too bleak and disturbing for comfort, and made Siegel add a wrap-around pair of scenes which implied that, despite the invaders' seemingly unstoppable advance, the FBI had rushed into action just in time to stop them from taking over the rest of America.

Kaufman's film not only avoids such a compromise, offering up its own brilliantly bleak conclusion, but even finds a way of tying the remake's events to the original. In one brief scene, we see a cameo from McCarthy as an older Miles Bennell, yelling the same anguished lines he gasped out in the 1956 film before being chased away to his doom by a screaming mob. 

More than a throwaway call back to the earlier film (like the three-breasted lady shoehorned into the Total Recall remake), McCarthy's cameo implies that the invasion has spread very slowly from Santa Mira in California, and is now ready to advance on San Francisco. It's only a brief moment, but it's an example of the thought and ingenuity Kaufman and writer WD Richter put into the new film.

At its core, the 1978 Body Snatchers is a similar film to the original, with a central huddle of characters - headed up by Donald Sutherland's health inspector Matthew Bennell - gradually noticing the quiet invasion unfolding around them, and futilely attempting to escape it. Yet the 1978 film escalates the sense of creeping horror in clever ways. The growth of replacement people from gooey pods is brought to life with superb practical effects. There are flashes of quite shocking gore. A moment involving a dog and a tramp's head is bizarre enough to cause nightmares as well as nervous laughter.

What's more, the pod people themselves are truly menacing. Their habit of pointing and screaming at the humans who've yet to be taken over has been parodied repeatedly since the 70s, yet it still has the power to curdle the blood. But even when they're not shrieking and pursuing their victims, the pod people are as subtly disturbing as they were in the 1956 film; in the concluding part of McCarthy's cameo, there's something unsettling about the way the crowd simply stand and stare emotionlessly at the character's body lying in the street. 

It's in scenes like this that Kaufman's Body Snatchers reveals its lasting relevance. In taking the original film from the small town and into the city, it explores new themes of distrust, paranoia and individualism against a more contemporary backdrop.

It helps, of course, that the ideas present in Jack Finney's original novel are strong enough to withstand multiple takes on the same story, since there's also much to recommend about Abel Ferrara's 1993 remake, simply titled Body Snatchers (the less said about 2007's The Invasion, the better). But it takes a director and writer as clever as Kaufman and Richter to not just retell an existing story, but create something fresh and tonally different with it.

This, then, is why 1978's Invasion Of The Body Snatchers is the prime example of a perfect remake. it's more than just a reworking of the same elements, or a soulless cover version of a popular song. It's a remake that deconstructs the original film, understands what is great about it, and then reassembles those component parts into something new and quite, quite terrifying.

If only all remakes could be as intelligent as this one.

Invasion Of The Body Snatchers is available on Blu-ray now from Arrow Films.

Follow our Twitter feed for faster news and bad jokes right here. And be our Facebook chum here.

Disqus - noscript

Good to see some love for this great film. One of my all time favourites.

I watched it again about a month ago, for the first time in maybe two years and it's better than ever. The sense of paranoia created with sideways glances and whispers is excellent, the main characters are drawn really well - believable people in an increasingly unbelievable set of circumstances - and (as you say) some genuinely nasty bits of gore.
Also, shame Leonard Nimoy didn't get more roles outside of Trek, he's wonderful in this movie.
Also also, Brooke Adams is, like, super hot.

This film is excellent. Try watching the final scene without chills creeping up your spine.

The fact that Donald Sutherland's character was originally supposed to be a jazz musician (which was why jazz pianist Danny Zeitlin was brought on as composer) speaks to the feel of the entire movie. A relaxed, loose, unpredicable style that isn't normally seen in sci-fi.

There are still only three remakes that are worth watching if you've seen the original; This, the Fly, and the Thing

Since seeing that ending as a kid, even now, I still don't entirely trust any character that Donald Sutherland plays. He could play goddamn Santa, and i'd still expect him to point and screech at the line of of children waiting to sit on his knee!

How spooky, I've just pressed play on the Blu-ray Disc.

Fully agree with you there.

I watched this fairly recently and it's one of my favourite horrors. Some the special affects haven't aged as badly as you'd think for a 70s film and the overall tension makes it feel so creepy. Brooke Adams looked fantastic and also she's a talented actress as well.

This movie impressed me over 30 years ago and it still stands up to this day. This is how you do a remake. I found this movie in a 5.00 bin and was so happy.

This film encapsulates the phrase "underlying menace." Superb movie, The point and scream at the end....still scares me shitless.

Don't forget THE MAGNIFICENT SEVEN--after all, it is a remake of THE SEVEN SAMURAI.

Definitely agree with you about the '78 IOTBS, THE FLY, and THE THING--it's just too bad it took a few years for people to notice the brilliance of the latter film.

Nimoy was quite good in this--and curiously, Kaufman was originally set to direct the first STAR TREK movie....

2007's The Invasion was bizarre to watch. The first half featured some brilliant filmmaking, but then you could pretty much spot the EXACT moment that the reshoots with a different director began.

He 'could' play Santa, but instead he chooses to play creepy old men like in Backdraft and The Hunger Games.

Yeah - I found that such an odd film too.

I would also add Diabolique to remakes done well

I saw this years ago late one night on BBC2 and it scared the hell out of me. I've seen the other versions but they all pale in comparison with the chilling effect the end scene had on me. Great movie.

Totally agree: a wonderful remake.

Sponsored Links