Doctor Who: Nothing O'Clock review

Review Andrew Blair 21 Nov 2013 - 10:30

Neil Gaiman perfectly captures the voices of Eleven and Amy in his super-scary Doctor Who short, Nothing O'Clock...

This review contains spoilers.

Some people were holding out for J.K. Rowling being the final author of this book series (the collected paperback edition is out today), or were disappointed when a writer who had already written for the TV series was announced. Likewise, some people were hoping for a person of colour or a woman to be the Twelfth Doctor. However, in both cases there is a strong argument in the incumbent's favour: they're Neil Gaiman and Peter Capaldi. That's at least a little bit exciting, surely?

Gaiman now has the chance, albeit with a limited page count, to ignore the budgetary constraints of the TV show and write the most expensive Doctor Who story he can think of. He does not. Instead, he goes for a small town in 1984, and a timeless void. True, there are some hugely pleasing continuity references in there, but Nothing O'Clock does not feel like it is striving to be a huge addition to the lore.

Given that he has form with The Doctor's Wife, it's not a surprise that Gaiman writes the Eleventh Doctor and Amy Pond credibly well (especially Amy, and especially her motivations). Considering one chapter is almost just those two trading exposition, it flies by with the voices of Matt Smith and Karen Gillan captured perfectly. The Time Lords, however, are quite bad at capturing things perfectly. They were complacent with the Daleks, and also with Gaiman's creation for this story: the Kin.

The Kin are, like a lot of The Doctor's Wife, visually creatures of fantasy tropes who appear to fit in with Gaiman's reputation as a purveyor of gothic imagery juxtaposed with real-world scenarios. However, as with The Doctor's Wife, there's also a really good Science-Fiction explanation of the kind that Barry Letts might smile at (He probably would not be so pleased by the fate of young Polly Browning though). Terrance Dicks would, I assume, also nod appreciatively at the Kin's method of conquering the Earth, which is both horrible and incredibly cheap to realise on television.

On the downside, there are a few moments which remain undeveloped, most notably the reasoning behind the fur growing on the ceiling, which seems to be there just for an unexplained pun. The empty TARDIS also moves without explanation (though, admittedly, it could have been physically carried). These little moments suggest the sound of deadlines rushing past, or word limits being brushed up against. As with Nightmare in Silver, time is part of the problem when writing something as idea-driven as Doctor Who (and there are some very good ideas here). Possibly this served as an inspiration for the Kin's modus operandi? As it is, prose works better for Gaiman's Doctor Who than telly, but the reality of deadlines means that even a full-length original novel might occasionally suffer from these blips.

However, they are blips. Some people might find them developing into niggles which in turn bloom into disappointments, but this is a story that balances satisfying pseudo-scientific explanations with something Gaiman really wanted to do: scare people. The Kin are unnerving. For some, they might be downright terrifying. I suppose it depends on how willing you are to reap what you sow if you choose to read this to your child as a bedtime story, as that's really the tone I get from Nothing O'Clock: the sense of a spoken story that got out of hand. In this case, it's a good thing.

Now, let's see if someone can persuade Gaiman to write a Doctor Who comic...

Read Andrew's review of the previous story in the series, Derek Landy's The Mystery Of The Haunted Cottage, here.

Follow our Twitter feed for faster news and bad jokes right here. And be our Facebook chum here.


Disqus - noscript

Where can one read this?

It's a short eBook. Presumably available from all good ebook vendors? Its the last of a series of 11 stories that will appear in a few weeks in a printed paperback version.

Neil Gaiman + Doctor Who. Don't have to say anything else. Take my money!!!

Looking forward to reading more of Gaiman's Doctor and just how terrifying the Kin are. Had a copy of the printed anthology pre-ordered, so it will hopefully be soon!

And Neil Gaiman penning a Doctor Who comic? That would be absolutely brilliant!

I think everyone over-praises this mans work. While he might be a good novelist/comic book writer or whatever, his doctor who work is pretty average. The doctors wife was good but is way overratted (the plot was quite weak imo) and his cybermen story was just awful, absolutely atrocious. Personally I wouldn't mind if he returned to who, but at the same time I couldn't care less if he didn't.

I got the paper back and have just finished reading it. Maybe it was not so obvious reading each story with a month in between but I was very disappointed that the stories didn't related to each other in some way. I also thought these stories could of been a brilliant opportunity to relate to and lead up to the events in the Day of the doctor. Seems like a missed opportunity to me.

Sponsored Links