15 TV Shows That Somehow Got Away With the Weirdest Storylines

Television has always been willing to take a strange turn, but some shows pushed their stories into territory nobody could have predicted. A perfectly normal episode could suddenly involve a bizarre disappearance, an unbelievable secret, a character making an absolutely wild decision, or an entire plot built around an idea that sounds ridiculous when explained out loud. Somehow, viewers kept watching, and the story moved forward as if nothing unusual had happened. These moments are especially fun to revisit because they remind us just how much television can get away with when the characters are compelling enough. Here are 15 storylines that still make viewers wonder how they actually made it to television.

The X Files (1993) — The Cigarette Smoking Man Is Somehow Behind Everything

The show eventually suggested that the Cigarette Smoking Man had been secretly involved in an astonishing number of major historical events. The idea that one mysterious government figure could have been connected to everything from JFK’s assassination to famous cultural moments became one of the show’s wildest recurring ideas.

Friends (1994) — Joey Learns French

Joey Tribbiani deciding to learn French for an audition should have been a simple comedy storyline. Instead, his complete inability to understand the language led to him essentially inventing his own version of French while Phoebe desperately tried to teach him.

The Simpsons (1989) — Homer Becomes an Astronaut

Homer Simpson going into space sounds like exactly the kind of storyline that should have broken the show’s universe. Instead, it became an entire episode, complete with Homer causing chaos aboard a NASA spacecraft and accidentally becoming one of the least qualified astronauts imaginable.

Grey’s Anatomy (2005) — Meredith and the Bomb

One of the show’s earliest seasons put Meredith Grey in a situation where a bomb was lodged inside a patient’s body, and someone had to physically hold it in place. The storyline was so tense and bizarre that it remains one of the show’s most memorable examples of going completely over the top.

Lost (2004) — The Island Has a Giant Smoke Monster

Lost began with survivors trying to understand why their plane crashed on a mysterious island. Eventually, viewers learned that one of the island’s biggest threats was a gigantic supernatural smoke creature capable of appearing as different people.

Riverdale (2017) — Archie Fights a Bear

Riverdale had already established that almost anything could happen, but Archie Andrews literally fighting a bear became one of the show’s most unforgettable moments. Somehow, the storyline was treated with enough seriousness that viewers simply had to accept it and keep watching.

How I Met Your Mother (2005) — Barney Has a Fake Family

Barney Stinson’s increasingly elaborate lies were a regular part of the show, but one storyline revealed that he had recruited actors to pretend to be his family. It was ridiculous, completely unnecessary, and somehow perfectly suited to the character.

Supernatural (2005) — The Winchesters Become Characters in a TV Show

Supernatural eventually went meta by having Sam and Dean discover a television series based on their own lives. The show then leaned even further into the idea, allowing its characters to interact with the actors who were supposedly portraying them.

Scrubs (2001) — Dr. Cox Imagines Everyone as His Ex Wife

Scrubs regularly blurred reality with J.D.’s imagination, but one particularly strange storyline involved Dr. Cox seeing his former wife, Jordan, in various women around the hospital. The gag became increasingly absurd while the characters around him had no idea what was happening.

Glee (2009) — Sue Sylvester Runs for President

Sue Sylvester was already one of television’s most unpredictable characters, but Glee eventually had her launch a political campaign. Her campaign fit perfectly into the show’s anything goes approach, complete with bizarre policies and even stranger campaign behavior.

Desperate Housewives (2004) — Edie Gets Haunted by Her Dead Husband

The show was never afraid of melodrama, but eventually took things into supernatural territory when Edie’s dead husband appeared to her. The storyline was brief but strange enough to make viewers question exactly what kind of world Wisteria Lane had become.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1997) — Buffy Dies and Comes Back

Buffy’s death was already a dramatic moment, but the show then brought her back after her friends performed a magical resurrection. The consequences of pulling her out of the afterlife became an entire storyline, proving that even death was not necessarily permanent in Sunnydale.

The Office (2005) — Michael Thinks a Mallard Is a Goose

Michael Scott’s confidence regularly exceeded his actual knowledge, but his bizarre certainty about animals produced some wonderfully ridiculous moments. His ability to confidently misunderstand basic facts became one of the show’s most reliable sources of comedy.

Modern Family (2009) — Lily Accidentally Shoots Someone With a Toy Gun

Modern Family turned a child’s innocent toy into the center of an unexpectedly chaotic storyline when Lily accidentally shot a neighbor. The situation escalated into classic family confusion while everyone desperately tried to figure out what had actually happened.

Pretty Little Liars (2010) — A Character Is Buried Alive

Pretty Little Liars repeatedly pushed its mysteries into increasingly unbelievable territory, but having characters survive being buried alive was especially wild. The show somehow made this kind of impossible situation feel like another Tuesday in Rosewood.