The Worst Recasts In TV History
When an actor takes on a role in a TV show, it’s often expected that they’ll stay as that character for the whole run of the show. However, not everything always goes according to plan, and when an actor leaves and the character is still needed, a recast is required.
Whatever the reason, this is something that often happens, but not always with the best results. What we’ve gathered here today are, at least according to us, the worst examples of this practice in television history. Some faces were better left unchanged.

Sarah Chalke as Becky Conner in Roseanne
When Lecy Goranson left Roseanne in season 6 to attend college, producers brought in Sarah Chalke to play Becky Conner. Fans found the swap incredibly distracting, making it one of the most famously awkward sitcom decisions ever broadcast.

Dick Sargent as Darrin Stephens in Bewitched
Replacing the main husband on a hit comedy is a massive risk. When Dick Sargent stepped in as the second actor to play Darrin Stephens on Bewitched, many viewers simply could not accept him as the same character.

Michiel Huisman as Daario Naharis in Game of Thrones
Ed Skrein originally established the cocky mercenary Daario Naharis on Game of Thrones before Michiel Huisman took over as a series regular. The two actors looked and acted so fundamentally different that audiences were left feeling totally confused.

Christina Moore as Laurie Forman in That 70s Show
The sneaky, manipulative sister on That 70s Show was a fan favorite before season 6. Christina Moore took over as Laurie Forman in 2003, but the original spark was missing, leaving the character feeling flat and easily forgotten.

Brooklyn Sudano as Vanessa Scott in My Wife And Kids
When Brooklyn Sudano stepped in to play Vanessa Scott on the ABC comedy My Wife and Kids, viewers immediately noticed the jarring shift. It is always tough to replace an established girlfriend character without disrupting the established chemistry.

Patricia Velasquez as Marta Estrella in Arrested Development
Arrested Development thrived on its highly specific comedic timing, making any cast change a massive gamble. Swapping actresses for Marta Estrella totally threw off the awkward romantic tension, leaving fans wishing they had kept the original performer around.

Lindsay Ridgeway as Morgan Matthews in Boy Meets World
Little sister Morgan Matthews disappeared for quite a while on Boy Meets World before mysteriously returning in season 3. Lindsay Ridgeway took over for Lily Nicksay, stepping into the role with an entirely different energy that felt unnatural.

Nathan Parsons as James Kent in True Blood
Changing actors right before a show ends is a massive risk. Nathan Parsons took over as vampire James Kent for the seventh and final season of True Blood, forcing fans to accept a stranger right at the finish line.

Toby Onwumere as Capheus Onyango in Sense8
A show built on intense mental connections needs a rock solid cast. During the second season of the Netflix series Sense8, Toby Onwumere replaced original cast member Aml Ameen, creating a noticeable disconnect for fans who loved the original dynamic.

Molly McCook as Mandy Baxter in Last Man Standing
Molly McCook stepped into a leading role as Mandy Baxter on the Fox run of Last Man Standing from 2018 to 2021. The sudden change to the middle daughter completely altered the family banter audiences had grown used to.

Cynthia Addai-Robinson as Naevia in Spartacus
Recasting a deeply emotional role is always an uphill battle. Cynthia Addai-Robinson took over the part of Naevia in the Starz television series Spartacus, but many viewers felt the romantic chemistry with her on-screen partner never quite recovered.

Noah Centineo as Jesus Foster in The Fosters
Noah Centineo secured a breakout role playing Jesus Adams Foster on the Freeform drama series The Fosters between 2015 and 2018. While he eventually won fans over, stepping into an already beloved family unit initially felt incredibly jarring.

Robert Wightman as John Boy in The Waltons
Richard Thomas originated the iconic role of John-Boy, making him the heart of The Waltons. When Robert Wightman eventually took over the character, it was widely rejected, ultimately earning a reputation as one of the worst replacement choices ever.

Skylar Astin as Greg Serrano in Crazy Ex-Girlfriend
Santino Fontana originally brought a very specific charm to Greg Serrano before leaving the show. Skylar Astin eventually took over the part for the final season of Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, but the meta explanation for his new face felt forced.

Mason Vale Cotton as Bobby Draper in Mad Men
The AMC drama series Mad Men went through several young actors to play Don’s son. Mason Vale Cotton took on the role of Bobby Draper from 2012 to 2015, but viewers struggled to keep track of the constant swaps.