15 of Fiction’s Least Believable Love Stories

Some fictional couples have incredible chemistry, while others leave you wondering how they even made it past the first date. Writers love bringing opposites together, but sometimes the differences are so big that the romance becomes harder to believe than the rest of the story. Characters who spent years ignoring each other suddenly fall in love, longtime friends develop feelings out of nowhere, and people with completely incompatible personalities somehow end up planning a future together. Sure, love doesn’t always make sense, but a few of these relationships require a serious suspension of disbelief. These movie and TV couples had us questioning what exactly they saw in each other.

IMDb

Padmé and Anakin, Star Wars

Padmé is a respected senator, while Anakin is an impulsive Jedi who keeps making terrible decisions. Somehow, his complaints about sand help kick off their romance.

IMDb

Natasha and Bruce, Avengers: Age of Ultron

Black Widow and Bruce Banner suddenly develop romantic feelings after spending most of their previous appearances focused on saving the world, with little buildup to their relationship.

IMDb

Rey and Kylo Ren, Star Wars

Kylo spends much of the trilogy threatening Rey and everyone she cares about, yet the two eventually share a kiss after a particularly complicated relationship.

IMDb

Harry and Ginny, Harry Potter

Ginny spends years crushing on Harry, but his romantic interest seems to arrive rather suddenly, especially in the movies, where their chemistry feels surprisingly awkward.

IMDb

Rachel and Joey, Friends

Rachel and Joey have years of comfortable friendship behind them, so their sudden romantic feelings feel strange, particularly when they can barely handle kissing each other.

IMDb

Barney and Robin, How I Met Your Mother

Robin values independence and honesty, while Barney spends years manipulating women and avoiding commitment. Their eventual marriage is quite a leap for both characters.

IMDb

Blair and Dan, Gossip Girl

Blair spends years looking down on Dan’s background and social status, then suddenly starts dating him after they bond over their shared interests.

IMDb

Jackie and Fez, That ’70s Show

Jackie repeatedly rejects Fez throughout the series, only to develop feelings for him near the end, after years of treating him as anything but boyfriend material.

IMDb

Penny and Leonard, The Big Bang Theory

Penny and Leonard have wildly different interests, social circles, and personalities, yet their unlikely romance somehow survives years of awkward conversations and relationship drama.

IMDb

Carrie and Mr. Big, Sex and the City

Big repeatedly avoids commitment while Carrie desperately wants a serious relationship, but she keeps returning to him despite years of disappointment and mixed signals.

IMDb

Amy and Laurie, Little Women

Laurie spends years hopelessly in love with Jo before eventually marrying her younger sister Amy, whose feelings for him develop after watching his devotion to someone else.

IMDb

Bella and Edward, Twilight

Edward is a century-old vampire who watches Bella sleep, while Bella somehow finds his unsettling behavior romantic enough to build her entire future around him.

IMDb

Elena and Damon, The Vampire Diaries

Damon begins the series as a dangerous, unpredictable vampire who repeatedly hurts people Elena loves, yet she eventually falls for him despite their complicated history.

IMDb

Izzie and George, Grey’s Anatomy

Izzie and George spend years as close friends before a drunken encounter suddenly becomes a romance, despite their complete lack of convincing romantic chemistry.

IMDb

Andy and Angela, The Office

Andy showers Angela with attention and elaborate gestures, while she barely seems interested in him and continues seeing Dwight behind his back.