14 Movies People Consume Both Ironically And Honestly

IMDb

There are plenty of reasons to enjoy a movie, meaning that two people can love a film for completely different reasons. Sometimes, those reasons can feel directly opposed, almost as if one viewer is making fun of the other. Even so, we shouldn’t judge why someone enjoys something.

This is why we’ve decided to gather the most divisive movies when it comes to why people enjoy them, ranging from honest viewing to ironic consumption. These two kinds of cinema enjoyers might not see eye to eye, even if they both can find something to enjoy from the same film.

IMDb

The Twilight Saga: New Moon

The 2009 sequel gave us intense teenage angst and arguably the best soundtrack of the era. Whether you were genuinely invested in the werewolf drama or just quoting the dialogue ironically, this romance completely took over pop culture.

IMDb

Star Wars: The Phantom Menace

George Lucas returned to the director chair in 1999 to deliver a wildly divisive prequel. While many fans ruthlessly mocked the political dialogue, an entire generation grew up genuinely loving the intense lightsaber duels and racing sequences.

IMDb

The Fast and the Furious

What started as a story about street racing and DVD players has evolved into a massive action franchise. Fans either genuinely care about the ongoing family drama or just show up to watch cars defy the laws of physics.

IMDb

Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again

Critics and fans alike found themselves laughing right along with this campy sequel. The sheer ridiculousness of the musical numbers combines with genuine self-aware comedy to create an experience that is impossible to watch without smiling.

IMDb

Venom: Let There Be Carnage

Audiences fully embraced the cheekiness of this superhero sequel. Viewers showed up specifically to laugh at the completely ridiculous humor, enjoying the absolute trashiness of the story while readily acknowledging that it was never aiming for prestige.

IMDb

National Treasure: Book of Secrets

This 2007 sequel directed by Jon Turteltaub leaned heavily into historical absurdity. Some viewers honestly love the fast-paced puzzle solving, while others treat the incredibly convoluted kidnapping plot like a brilliant, unintentional comedy masterpiece.

IMDb

The Cat in the Hat

Based on the famous 1957 children book, the live-action adaptation is a fever dream of strange creative choices. People either watch it for genuine childhood nostalgia or to mock the deeply chaotic energy of the entire production.

IMDb

High School Musical 2

The 2007 television sequel directed by Kenny Ortega gave us some of the most dramatic musical numbers ever filmed on a golf course. Fans still debate whether the intense teenage choreography is completely brilliant or completely ridiculous.

IMDb

Space Jam: A New Legacy

Directed by Malcolm D. Lee, this 2021 sports comedy threw every single corporate property into a basketball game. It is a completely chaotic visual experience that viewers consume either for sincere family fun or pure, cynical disbelief.

IMDb

Fifty Shades of Grey

Based on the 2011 romance novel, this adaptation became a massive cultural event. While millions of devoted readers eagerly bought tickets for the love story, plenty of others bought them just to laugh at the notoriously awkward dialogue.

IMDb

How the Grinch Stole Christmas

Ron Howard directed this 2000 holiday comedy that somehow manages to be deeply heartfelt and visually unsettling. People revisit it every December both for the genuine Christmas message and the completely unhinged performance of the lead character.

IMDb

The Lizzie McGuire Movie

Despite getting mixed reviews upon its initial release, this teen comedy eventually gained a massive cult following. Fans now watch it for the genuine early 2000s nostalgia and the wildly improbable pop star plotline that defines the era.

Spice World

The famous pop group played themselves in this 1997 musical comedy directed by Bob Spiers. It makes absolutely no logical sense, which is exactly why audiences still love to watch the completely random alien encounters and musical numbers.

IMDb

Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice

Zack Snyder directed this 2016 superhero film that remains highly debated. Some fans fiercely defend the dark cinematic choices, while others specifically watch it just to mock the incredibly famous and clumsy scene about their mothers sharing a name.