Den of Geek

The Thick Of It series 3 episode 5 review

Andrew Mickel


The latest Thick Of It is arguably the weakest of the series to date, but still impressive stuff...

Published on Nov 21, 2009

This week saw a ministerial tussle on Radio 5 Live, which poses a minor problem: no-one actually listens to 5 Live's unique blend of local radio prattle and access to national broadcasting equipment, making it hard to judge how on the money the satire was.

Still, you can count on The Thick Of It to call the bluff of your expectations (if you follow me), letting what should have been a serious policy debate get overrun with listeners' texts about piercing - the best likening it to a robot wearing flesh earrings - and peaking with a producer producing the line of the episode: "I can't believe my ears, did we just break a story that wasn't that the Ipswich manager's got sacked?" I have no idea if that is fair on 5 Live, but I'm willing to believe it.

Anyway, the station was host to the still-bewildered minister Nicola Murray and her still-charming shadow Peter Mannion coming to blows on air. I started this series pondering why the show seemed to be slightly off the political pulse, but the answer does seem to be that the writers were trying to cover the last couple of years in sequence, rather than spending eight episodes in one political moment in time. So we're now up to the 'bash the bankers' era of politicking, watching Mannion be ordered by his party's command to perform a 'reverse Gecko' and turn on his friends in the City.

Still, this did feel like the weakest episode of the run - admittedly a relative position - with scatological references filling in the gaps around a fairly plodding plot.

Everything was referenced from Mark Kermode to Loose Women, and there were more casual insults than I could even keep track of (my notes only recording Pol Pottymouth, Bagpuss, Swiss Tony, Captain Mark Phillips and Princess Anne, and the remarkably kind Rupert Brooke).

This is all funny, yes, but it doesn't quite add up to the impact of other episodes this run.

Eventually, the PR heads, Malcolm and Stewart, got stuck in to what the writers, presumably, thought would be a clash of the titans, but something didn't quite work with the suggestion that Stewart is Malcolm's equal.

We've watched Malcolm chase opposition politicians as a blood sport and know that he is King Bollock. So far, Stewart has been an airy idiot with a mind matrix, worrying about how to "appeal to One Show man and Holby City woman".

This match up just wasn't convincing. Malcolm is by far at his best this episode when he is eating obscene cake, or comparing minister Nicola Murray to a cow running across a minefield, rather than facing what the writers have set up as a straw dog equal.

Let's hope they don't meet again any time soon.

Read our review of episode 4 here.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: The Thick Of It series 3 episode 5 review
Posted By bazellis 1 November 23, 2009 11:04:35 AM

Are you serious - this was the funniest episode of the series to date. I watched it again immediately after it was shown.

Re: The Thick Of It series 3 episode 5 review
Posted By mahuda 1 November 23, 2009 12:08:22 PM

People do listen to Five Live. Ignorant comment.

Re: The Thick Of It series 3 episode 5 review
Posted By bartyboy 1 November 23, 2009 12:33:43 PM

Bazellis - I agree, it was superb and the Five Live setting was perfect. The various plot threads worked together brilliantly. Richard Bacon was great too. Love Glen's comment "she's like a squirrel trapped in a pedal bin" and Malcolm interrupting the end of the sports report bellowing "...up a goose's arse" (or something similar) And wasn't Malcolm's comment about NM 'like a clown running across a minefield'?

Re: The Thick Of It series 3 episode 5 review
Posted By SeanFracture 1 November 24, 2009 09:29:32 AM

You not listening to Five Live does not mean nobody does. Oddly ignorant comment. Also, Malcolm vs. Stewart worked, in my opinion, because they are two sides of the same coin - both very switched on men, amazing at their jobs, just with a different approach. Plus, they both had equal amounts of dirt on the other's key players. At the end of the day, all they care about is their jobs and saving their own skin, so coming to a conclusion that would allow that made perfect sense.
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image
 
 
The Thick Of It

The Thick Of It

Untitled Document

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Coke Zero
Advertisement