Den of Geek

V episode 2 review

Ron Hogan


Can the second episode of the new take on V match the standard of the first?

Published on Nov 11, 2009


2. There Is No Normal Anymore

One of the elements of V that I find myself really enjoying as we go into the second episode is the paranoia. Really, one of the things the show has done incredibly well with the sleeper alien cell angle is establish that pretty much anyone can, and just might be, a Visitor. I mean, in the first episode we had two surprising reveals of various Visitors, so it's obvious that V is living by the old Joe Bob Briggs Drive-In Rules, except replace "Anybody can die at any moment" with "Anybody can be a secret lizard".

As I watch the show, I find myself studying each character that pops up intently, attempting to determine just what their true motivations are. I'm getting paranoid, staring intently at my television as if I can somehow read who is a V and who isn't based on their expression or their body language. Yes, I know it's a TV show and that they're all (probably) human actors, but the show is doing a great job at pulling the viewer into the mindset of FBI agent Erica and Father Jack.

As the two definite humans in the cast, they have no one they can really turn to but one another, and Erica is working overtime to remind Jack of this fact. Jack, whom I have nicknamed Father Voice of Reason in my copious show notes, isn't quite getting the whole ‘Anyone can be a V agent' thing, and keeps stumbling, thanks to his more trusting nature. While he's definitely more representative of how a normal person would respond to the V introduction (thanks to being confused and blindly trusting the authorities to do the right thing), Erica is definitely more along my mindset and, for that reason, she's more of the focus of the show as I think the average viewer is going to be reading the show and its characters as closely as I am in an attempt to pick out the V's before the reVeal. (I already have a couple of them I suspect strongly, though I won't reveal them yet.)

Part of the fun of this kind of show is that mystery. I like that we're basically playing Spot The V, The Home Game.

This episode, in particular, does a good job at using the extras to provide that extra layer of paranoia. It's shot well in general, actually; there's a dueling interrogation scene in which Erica meets with the Visitor Threat Assessment Joint Taskforce while Father Jack gets interrogated by a different agent from the VTAJT at the church regarding the stabbing from the first episode. It's really well cut together. V is really well made by television standards, thanks in no small part to the special effects budget.

However, while some people, like Erica's son Tyler, have completely embraced the Visitors, this episode papers over a problem a lot of people had with the plot by emphasizing that not everyone is all keen about our new alien overlords. Indeed, outside of the V ship zone in Manhattan is a loud, angry group of protesters that Tyler scuffles with. It's not the best idea for a Peace Ambassador to get in public fist fights, and that gets Tyler banned from Lisa and the V compound.

It also sets in motion what is obviously going to be a Romeo And Juliet plotline with Tyler and Lisa. After all, Erica is insistent that her son not have any contact with the Visitors, since she knows what they're up to. Lisa is also banned from visiting Tyler by the dueling forces of the US government's careful relationship with the Visitors and Tyler's banning from the V ship as a result of his fisticuffs.

That makes it all seem like a big set-up to ingratiate Lisa with Tyler, due to the forbidden interspecies love affair. Given that anyone can be a V and that they've already infiltrated one anti-Visitor resistance group, it makes me wonder if this wasn't all set up by the Visitors from the beginning, but for what purpose?

They've proven themselves to be master manipulators of the humans' emotions (Anna's soft voice, symmetrical features, non-threatening haircut, and the omnipresent halo of white light behind her every public speaking appearance is proof of that), and when they can't get the reach they need, their human collaborators (like self-serving Chad Decker) are more than willing to help them out for short-term gains.

The interplay in this episode between Decker and Anna is spectacular. It's fun to see both sides playing against one another for power and control in the relationship. Normally, I'm not a Scott Wolf fan, but he's really good as a sleazy news opinionist.

Love is going to be a big player in this show, since the relationship between V Ryan and (apparently) human Valerie also gets a lot of attention. Being a member of the pro-human V resistance, as Ryan seems to be, is dangerous. They're everywhere, and can access any information. No wonder Eric is so pants-soilingly paranoid.

That makes me wonder, why would there be more than one Visitor working with the resistance? Or any V willing to turn against his own people, obviously risking everything, to aid the humans? Just exactly how bad are the plans the V's have for us?

It's telling that the show has me second-guessing pretty much all the interactions between every character save the definite aliens like Dale (who isn't off the show yet, Alan Tudyk fans!) and the definite humans like Erica, Father Jack, and Tyler.

Even in situations where a character's motivation is obvious, I'm still studying all the angles trying to tell just what is going on and who is leading whom. I'm hooked.

Read our review of the pilot episode here.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: V episode 2 review
Posted By cordas 1 November 11, 2009 03:28:57 PM

I don't share your rose tinted vision of V the remake, I have found it to be really quite clunky and awkward with over dramatic acting and scripting that just makes me cringe. This show feels dated when compared to some of the best silky smooth TV that is being produced today.

Re: V episode 2 review
Posted By RobGordon23 1 November 11, 2009 05:44:20 PM

Cordas, what silky smooth TV are you referring to?

Re: V episode 2 review
Posted By bytat 1 November 12, 2009 12:31:02 AM

"They've proven themselves to be master manipulators of the humans' emotions (Anna's soft voice, symmetrical features, non-threatening haircut, and the omnipresent halo of white light behind her every public speaking appearance is proof of that)" that part cracked me up.. xD you fanboys.

Re: V episode 2 review
Posted By bytat 1 November 12, 2009 12:35:06 AM

that is to say, the scriptwriters of V are obviously "master manipulators of the humans' emotions"

Re: V episode 2 review
Posted By cordas 1 November 12, 2009 12:05:12 PM

@Rob everything from Lost to Battlestar Galactica, from The Wire to Being Erica. I can't think of a decent TV show from the past 5 years that has had as many awkward clunky scenes and lines of dialogue in it.

Re: V episode 2 review
Posted By Naneek1 1 November 12, 2009 05:48:44 PM

I'm wholly impressed by both episodes, and almost as impressed by Ron Hogan's reviews which are clear, intelligent and which even follow the rules of English grammar, a lamentable rarity on the internet. His distillation of episode two is quite insightful, though I think he's being a bit hard on Decker's character. The guy seems to have at least some professional or ethical scruples, and he isn't so obviously "sleazy" as Hogan suggests. Perhaps Mr. Hogan's stated bias against actor Scott Wolfe plays a role in his interpretations. (and he should check out Wolfe's growth in "Go" as compared to "Party of Five") As for the reader-responses that whine about clumsy or contrived dialogue and particularly "cordas 1"'s decision to name shows like "Lost" or "Battlestar Galactica" as a better standard, it's sort of laughable. Some people just hate it when something's praised without their own aesthetic say-so, and no TV show I can think of, not even my personal gold-standard (BBC's Wallander) ever bares up under such biased scrutiny. As in the sciences, if you're looking for some flaw or fault in a testable theory prior to testing, it will cloud your interpretation of the facts. So too with the arts. If, for some reason, you're bent on exposing all the flaws of a work of art prior to appreciating it, it is more likely that you will find something to dislike than something to appreciate. If "cordas 1" treated his own favourites with the same attitude, they could hardly survive such a dissection. This is a phenomenon that affects the ability of people who work on films and shows to appreciate the end result. They are experts in spotting the artifice inherent in making-believe. To the script-bashers, I ask could you write it better? I don't know that I could with the economy that the V writing staff has, as it's a real art to appeal to a mass audience without overly compromising a narrative's integrity. It's a TV show! It's not reality, folks. Predictions: Having long been a fan of the original since it first aired in '83, albeit a sheepish fan due to its cheesiness by today's standards, I am familiar with its most powerful plot points, and predict that a) the original's cross-species experiment (Elizabeth, the half-visitor, half-human) will one day be the child of Tyler and Lisa; b) the lame attempt in the original to portray the general populace's sudden and total mistrust of scientists (standing in for the Jews of the WWII-era) will resonate better when they posit the very real and oft-justified paranoia continually growing in society towards the police and the FBI. I think that the Visitor Threat Assessment Joint Task Force (VTAJT) lady is being smartly played up as a visitor...But what if she isn't? Perhaps she and several others in her branch are onto the V's and have been for a while? Perhaps there are going to be attempts at Visitor exposure that will be quelled by Anna's denouncement of the task force and more generally police forces at large? Alternately, (or perhaps additionally) it might play out that organized religion instead becomes this kind of scapegoat. c) I also suspect that, as in the original, humans are being targeted as food, and that the Visitors who are helping the humans can't stomach the idea, so to speak. That could argue for the great risks the Visitor traitors are willing to take, if for no other reason than a philosophical notion that good and evil are universal to a point, and a natural outcropping of the emergence of intelligence. I guess what I'm suggesting is that, even when racism (read "species-ism" in this case) is rampant among a group, there will always be morally-bound thinkers who, despite the party line, recognize in another's intelligence the capacity for suffering akin to their own experience. Even the Nazis had a Schindler or two.

Re: V episode 2 review
Posted By Naneek1 1 November 12, 2009 06:04:07 PM

As a little add-on to my ridiculously long essay on V, I should retract my complaint about cordas 1, as my response obviously sounds as biased in the opposite direction. I mean I started off stating how much of a fan I was, didn't I?

Re: V episode 2 review
Posted By Cormac224 1 November 13, 2009 05:00:49 PM

Naneek1 -- TL;dr!

Re: V episode 2 review
Posted By syrdax 1 November 14, 2009 09:16:03 AM

One thing that bothers me in lots of shows is "wow-what-an-super-smart-agent-is" thing. In episode 1, FBI agents go and check some satelite image, they seem to have checked everything but a little shack, that, somehow, even is shown in the picture that the truck was parked just outside that shack, they didn't look there. What? That would be the FIRST place I would look, and I'm not a trained FBI agent. And then, wow, nothing there, but of course, the super intelligent agent manages to, well, just pull a cord and there it is! the secret entrance! Those things are the things that bothers me, when they try to make agents look super intelligent by discovering things that, at least me, are really easy to discover. I think that you can call that predictability, I really don't know to express myself in English as I'm a Spanish speaker, but I think you'll get my meaning. Every show that has two cops/agents/etc. is like the same. One finds something and the other acts like if that thing found could be known but just some super intelligent being. The show isn't too bad, but I find it predictable, like you know from the first look of the kid he will join the Vs the first time you see him. Watching Elizabeth act is like watching Lost again, I was expecting in any second to call someone Jack...
Post a Comment
 
V: There Is No Normal Anymore

V: There Is No Normal Anymore

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!