Amazon.co.uk Widgets
Den of Geek

Stargate Universe episode 5 review

Carl England


Stargate Universe continues to thrive, as co-creator Brad Wright takes on scripting duties...

Published on Oct 25, 2009


5. Light

I'm not a fan of 'previously's in the first place, but it's just struck me how annoying the one for Stargate Universe is currently. It's the same 30 seconds played every week, followed by a miniscule title sequence that pales in comparison to the previous series' epic efforts. I know it may seem a bit unfair to pick these little things out as faults when the rest of the series performs so well in other aspects, but for me it seems unfair not too.

In Light we pick up where we left off in Darkness, with the crew heading into the heart of a sun. All other options seemingly considered, it appears that the only thing left to do is fill the one remaining shuttle with as many members of the crew as possible, and take off for the one habitable planet in the system. With the shuttle only able to take seventeen people, a lottery is taken for the fifteen seats leftover, after a pilot and medic are chosen.

This being the fifth of a twenty-episode run, I don't imagine it's a spoiler telling you that they manage a way out of it. However, it's the way that Brad Wright writes this instalment that captures your imagination, as each person deals with the inevitability of their death in their own way. This episode continues to show us the entirely character driven show that was promised to us, and delivers a high quality script to do it with, too.

True enough, that there is a fair bit of science involved too, for those who have been missing out on that element of Stargate for the first month of the show. One of the best parts about the episode is that the science isn't even what saves them. It's the biggest character of them all that finally saves the crew, and it makes for an interesting turn that, by all rights, everybody on board should all be dead at the end of the hour.

Now, by any heroic standards I can see the readers out there saying 'Hold up, why is that?' but that is exactly the reason. The crew aren't exactly G.I. Joes and super geniuses, and they shouldn't purport themselves to be, either. Which means that it's superb that they don't, and are, in fact, scared and ill tempered about dying, making most of the characters a lot easier to connect with.

At this point it's fair to note that the show doesn't just throw all its cards down at once, and is, in fact, playing off the emotional storylines slowly, letting viewers digest the nibbles they get each week. It might sometimes feel like the showrunners are teasing you into watching 10 seasons before you find out someone's middle name, but in truth, having the series play out like this gives you a lot more chances to determine what each character is all about.

Take, for instance, Dr Rush, whose character seems to not only take the news rather well, but actually uses the opportunity to repair bridges which he may have already burned. It's not even what he does that's important. It's more likely why he does it, and it's something that will probably be picked up on in later episodes, showing great cause for this storyline to be shown so early on in the series.

With great close-ups on the sun and the exterior of the ship, we, yet again, get to see where the budget is getting thrusted into, as the special effects team have outdone themselves once more. It's admirable work, and really helps you to take what you're seeing as a matter of fact, not fiction.

What also truly helps the show seem like reality is the matter of makeup, which may not seem like a huge element at first, but when you take into account the sun damage a fair few of the crew endured in the third episode, it really comes into play. The characters still have the sunburn healing on their faces, and not in any way that makes it attractive or wanted, but that makes the shows continuity of obvious importance to the showrunners. Add that to the deliberate documentary style camerawork, and it seems like you are truly more involved in this Stargate series more than any other.

While there are still some major elements of the show yet to be explored fully, including a little bit of adventurism, I think we now know enough to say that this experiment has paid off in spades. Don't get me wrong, it could all go horribly awry in the rest of the first season's run, but I think that Stargate Universe has done more than enough to deserve it's lofty numbers thus far.

Check out our review of episode 4 here. Stargate Universe is showing in the UK on Sky1 and Sky1 HD every Tuesday.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Stargate Universe episode 5 review
Posted By cordas 1 October 26, 2009 10:44:03 AM

All I can say is its a shame they had that atrocious 3rd episode! If they had ditched the air problem (saved it till later on in the series) and merged this into the pilot it would have been a far stronger show.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 5 review
Posted By stuxmusic 1 October 27, 2009 01:44:26 AM

I think I may go into a bit rant on the next review about how theyve only used the stargate twice. To get to Destiny and to visit the sand planet. (return trips are one!)

Re: Stargate Universe episode 5 review
Posted By cordas 1 October 27, 2009 10:50:32 AM

Personally I think they have used the stargate once/twice too often! The ship should be the star of the early season not, the gates.... the air running out and the desert planet (with its use of jumping to a different gate so 3 times) where to predictable and cliché driven drivel.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 5 review
Posted By cptjackharkness 1 October 27, 2009 10:51:24 AM

this show along with Flash Forward have been big let downs but since i had such hope for both i am hanging in there on these 2 show for a but longer but now much longer both shows i feel are slow and going no where. we will see love the cast of SGU but that is not enough to hang around if it does not pick up soon

Re: Stargate Universe episode 5 review
Posted By cordas 1 October 27, 2009 12:17:30 PM

Each of those shows is 5 episodes old, and each show is angling towards having a multi-season run. If they shot their load in the 1st 5 eps then they would run out of steam byt the 2nd season.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 5 review
Posted By stuxmusic 1 October 27, 2009 12:46:02 PM

I get what you mean cordas, but remember, the show isn't called Stargate: Destiny. I was hoping for Stargate and new universe action. So far it's all been about the ship, which is cool, but why update the stargate and have it look pretty and just sit in the corner.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 5 review
Posted By Forecaster 1 October 27, 2009 04:01:13 PM

If they just had every episode vist planets thus far, then you would be complaining of why they dont explore and figure out the ship first. This is a first rate show - methodical, planning for long hall, figuring things out...much better than a 'Data' saying we should use the deflectro shield

Re: Stargate Universe episode 5 review
Posted By masteryoda007 1 October 27, 2009 04:25:21 PM

Begbie in space, whats not to like?

Re: Stargate Universe episode 5 review
Posted By cordas 1 October 28, 2009 08:13:27 AM

@stuxmusic - Its not called Stargate Stargate either ;). I just think that the show really needs to define itself as different from SG and particularly SG:A, SG:A left Atlantis as pretty much wallpaper and used the gate in pretty much the same was as SG did.... every week jumping to a story of the week. One of the things about SG:U is that they have said they want to move away from it... something they blew for me with the atrocious desert episode. If I was in charge I would have saved using the gate on Destiny for a while and then done something weird with it, before they did anything 'boring' like finding the stuff to repair the air leak.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 5 review
Posted By stuxmusic 1 October 29, 2009 02:30:50 AM

Don't get me wrong folks, I'm not against staying with the ship for a good while. In fact, I think it's definitely a smart thing to do. But in the same way, it's also smart not to derive storylines from Atlantis. They had the whole 'we've run out of power and we're going to die now' situation, and to see it repeated was a shame for what has so far been a widely better show. True also that the 'Kino' Diary Room moments were also nicked from episode 17(or 18) of season 1 of Atlantis when they all record messages that they don't even know if people at home will see. Now, If I were them, I'd be wondering how to make a show with a stargate, different from another show with a stargate. Unfortunately, taking a old bag of tricks and shaking them up can only last so long. The stargate at least affords them the apperance of change.
Post a Comment
 
Stargate Universe

Stargate Universe

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!