Den of Geek

Stargate Universe episode 4 review

Carl England


It's time for Darkness, as Stargate Universe continues to impress...

Published on Oct 19, 2009


4. Darkness

As episode four kicks in, we see two sides of how things are on the good ship Destiny. On one hand, you have Dr Rush, who is struggling with what appears to be his sanity and anger. On the other, you have the rest of the crew, who seem to be trying to get along and find out ways to muck in.

With power issues putting Dr Rush under a whole lot of strain, the rest of the crew are eager to find technology on board to help out. Unfortunately, that's just the kind of thing that will drag the power levels down, and god help anyone who gets in the way of the sleep-deprived Rush.

Robert Carlyle continues to be on top form and he had a lot of scenes in which to prove his worth, even if it's unnecessary to. The rest of the crew get a good chance to shine in scenes which bring them all together, and scenes which separate them and put them on their own. It's a mixture of these two that lets us see a complete picture of the crew.

First, we have scenes of the crew talking to each other about the problems and trying to at least see an upside, even it is a very small one. It gives us a good chance to see the crew relax, as with most of the series, they probably won't get many chances to do so. On the flipside, we get to see the crew at their most vulnerable, recording messages about themselves at Eli's request on the Kino (a self-powered floating camera that can be used for recording and/or seeing what is beyond a gate, found in Air part 2).

Life continues to be tough on board, with no real food to speak of, and a shortage of water too. With the ship only stopping when Stargate are in range, relying on those planets to have fresh water and food will be crucial in the upcoming episodes. Unfortunately, this episode creates a huge problem on that side of the story, as there are no new planets discovered and the huge power failures could cause all sorts of trouble for the ship and its de facto crew. A crew that could be having trouble dealing with the leadership as it is already.

Of course, Robert Carlyle continues to give a powerhouse performance, but other characters continue to surprise too. Justin Louis' execution of Col Young continues to strengthen with every scene, becoming the second actor for me to look forward to seeing every week. He has a few emotional scenes when he returns to Earth to talk to his wife using the ancient communication device, and they are played with a great wealth of character that Louis seems more than capable of. In addition, he shows both his light-hearted side and his aggressive side in the role of commanding officer. In that way, he reminds me of Edward James Olmos' incredible performance as Admiral Adama in Battlestar Galactica. It's perhaps not as good as that just yet, but still an impressive mix and a good character to empathise with too.

The wonderful visual style just gets better too, with a close pass around a gas giant providing an incredible visual stimulus for both the characters and the viewers at home. The cliffhanger, too, provides an excellent final image and an impressive cliff to hang from for a week.

Again, I am highly impressed with this week's instalment, and am impatiently awaiting the arrival of episode five, which should, hopefully, prove to be as remarkable as this week's, if not more so.

Check out our review of episode 3 here. Stargate Universe is showing in the UK on Sky1 and Sky1 HD every Tuesday.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Stargate Universe episode 4 review
Posted By RobGordon23 1 October 19, 2009 11:26:07 AM

I'm also very impressed with how this show has been. I actually sat up straighter when they didn't say what had gone wrong which let me appreciate just how good that last shot was. This is the reason I love/hate watching TV week to week!

Re: Stargate Universe episode 4 review
Posted By Tippon 1 October 20, 2009 10:19:16 PM

Really? I've found the show quite boring so far. The first, double episode was ok, but didn't really explain anything, other than there's a ship lost in space, and it's called Voyager, erm, sorry, I mean Destiny... The third episode was a handful of them walking around a desert, and not much else, and the latest episode revolved around a problem that would have been solved in minutes on either SG-1 or Atlantis, but was dragged out to fill a whole episode, with some really forgettable characters thrown in for no apparent reason. I hope it gets better than this!

Re: Stargate Universe episode 4 review
Posted By stuxmusic 1 October 21, 2009 01:18:22 AM

Interestingly Enough Tippon, I think that's part of the shows charm. In SG-1 and Atlantis, everything was easy, and if someone was ever injured, they'd be back next week (or the week after, it they went on holiday) perfectly fine! This show has that sense of realism which makes the other shows seem... clean.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 4 review
Posted By Aurorakat 1 October 21, 2009 03:16:54 AM

Most new television series get off to slow starts. There are always relationships to develop among characters and actors, as well. The birthing pains are always evident when you go back to watch the first episodes of any series, both those that have made a huge impact and those that fizzle. Stargate Universe is doing one thing very right from the start. Coming in as an additional series on the tails of two very successful predecessors, they are playing to an already expectant viewer base by leaving little bread crumbs that will keep us coming back while the flavors and relationships develop. I am already wondering where the disappearing team went and how they will be worked back in, what the little pod flying off the ship was about and whether or not the sand creature in the third episode will resurface. Kudos to the writers, producers and actors!

Re: Stargate Universe episode 4 review
Posted By gr81disp 1 October 22, 2009 12:32:46 PM

I am liking this episode although Eli is already beginning to wear on me a bit. He is good as the whiz kid slacker who can come up with the idea in crunch time, but as the smart ass he spends most of he time playing, his writing comes off as irritating.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 4 review
Posted By elmuzzerino 1 October 23, 2009 12:53:56 AM

Great review and so far this is shaping up to be a surprisingly good show. The first time I heard there was a Stargate show back in the 90's I had no interest in it. I figured it was just a cheap spin-off from a great film, but since then a colleague of mine presuaded me to watch Atlantis and I loved it. SGU seems to be a much darker incarnation and so far so good. Being from Scotland I am delighted to see a fellow countryman take attention as one of the top characters on the show. Robert Carlyle indeed seems to play an interesting blend of the grumpy mean bastard genious guy and is awesome! http://www.sciencefictionstuff.com/

Re: Stargate Universe episode 4 review
Posted By Aurorakat 1 October 23, 2009 01:08:46 AM

The thought has crossed my mind, gr81, that I am going to tire of Eli if the writers don't find him some depth and value pretty quickly. House is a perfect example of an irritating character whose depth keeps you coming back for more. Simply being an ass will get the character nowhere and possibly kill the show, unless some sort of redeemable quality gets fans cheering for him fairly quickly.

Re: Stargate Universe episode 4 review
Posted By cordas 1 October 26, 2009 10:35:58 AM

I like Eli, but I agree that they do more with him than just have him as the heart/soul who comes up whacky solutions that work (something he hasn't actually done yet).
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image
 
 
Stargate Universe

Stargate Universe

Untitled Document

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Coke Zero
Advertisement