Den of Geek

Green Lantern review

Luke Savage


Ryan Reynolds is Green Lantern. But is the film the suspected bomb of the summer, or is there a good reason to see it? Here's our review...

Published on Jun 16, 2011

When Warner Bros. first announced its plans to make Green Lantern its next big comic book franchise, few people would have put Martin Campbell at the top of a 'let's get him to direct it' list. Well, me, for one. Leaf through Campbell's back catalogue and the very thing that Green Lantern would seem to demand - CGI flourishes, flights of fancy, big colours and stuff - are suspiciously light on the ground. When Campbell does action, he does action for real. And when he relies on CGI, we get Vertical Limit.

So, how would he deal with purple aliens, mad scientists and yellow fear swallowing baddies? Uh, pretty well, as it turns out. Campbell's successful re-booting of the James Bond franchise in Casino Royale may just have been the thing that helped greenlight Hal Jordan and his inter-galactic friends. He brings the same 'less frills, more thrills' approach to bear here.

That's not to say Green Lantern is in the same league as either of his Bond adventures. It has far too much going on, too little time to do it, and is not quite sure what it wants to be a lot of that time. A big, bright kids movie, a bruising action film, a tongue-in-cheek superhero adventure. They're all in here, vying for your attention.

But amidst all that, it is fun, something which Jerry Bruckheimer seems to have left off his own ‘what should we put in the latest Pirates Of The Caribbean' list. And Campbell's not a man to hang around. He whips through the story's universe-sweeping set-up like it's a pre-credits Bond sequence, giving just enough to keep us interested. These green-wearing dudes are the nice guys, this big yellow thing is bad, Ryan Reynolds is cocky but good for it, and Blake Lively is never going to look anything but a movie star, even when she's flying a fighter jet at Mach speed.

Green Lantern moves fast, getting to the main attraction of a hero in a suit in half the time it took Sam Raimi to in Spider-Man. It leaves in its wake some clunky moments of family melodrama, an underused display of Reynolds' razor sharp comic timing and beautifully dry delivery (his retort to one character's clichéd "Watch your back" is priceless), and a flashback scene that doesn't quite work. 

But when it gets to the big green show, Campbell shows his true worth. ‘A knife fight in a phone box' is apparently how he sold Reynolds on his vision for the film, and he comes close to that here, often with the simplest of touches. A grounded fight outside a bar carries a mighty punch, long before a big, green CGI punch comes rolling in. 

Green Lantern's action scenes don't have the jaw-dropping, heart-in-mouth breathlessness of Casino Royale, but they do share the simple thrill of The Mask Of Zorro's. Campbell's brought in his go-to editor, Stuart Baird, (a man whose CV reads like a Christmas list of the greatest action films ever made), and the two bring a crunching realism to the shimmering green on display. 

Those early trailers don't tell the entire story. Caught in snippets, the action beats felt weightless and looked just a little bit silly. But Campbell makes the whole better than the parts, each set piece a satisfying melee of the ridiculous and the real. Even a scene featuring a helicopter sprouting wheels and driving down a giant green racetrack feels kind of right. Well, kind of.

Sometimes, the ridiculous wins out and Green Lantern veers dangerously close to a Joel Schumacher-era Batman film, with big elaborate sets that look exactly that. There's one that leaves the actors stranded in what looks like the climactic scene from Howard The Duck, with only a prop left over from Stargate to keep them company. Tim Robbins plays it far too hammy as a slimy senator, Peter Sarsgaard only slightly less so as a mad scientist (although there's really only one way you can go with that: mad, but clever). But that's okay. They're not the main draw here. 

Campbell is in such a rush to get to the good stuff (big green effects!) that he doesn't give us nearly enough of the really good stuff, Reynolds and Lively. She's straight-jacketed by her Carol Ferris being too much of a straight foil to Reynolds' wisecracking Hal Jordan, yet even that can't stop them being a winning couple. 

Their big balcony scene, that one that every superhero film has, where the girl gets rescued by the hero she knows but doesn't know she knows, is the real standout in Green Lantern. It shines brighter than any of the dazzling effects on show, funny and knowing and perfectly played (perhaps not surprising, when you consider co-writer/producer, Greg Berlanti, honed his skills at the Dawson's Creek school of movie references).

If the already written sequel does come to fruition (and it's just about worth staying for the end credits to catch the setup for this), then we need to have more of those really good bits, please. Lots more.

3 stars

Follow Den Of Geek on Twitter right here. And be our Facebook chum here.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Green Lantern review
Posted By s1m2010 1 June 16, 2011 09:02:52 AM

good review makes me want to see it more thanks :)

Re: Green Lantern review
Posted By stueyd67 1 June 16, 2011 11:31:49 AM

Taking the kids to see it on Sunday. Think their in for a treat! Cheers.

Re: Green Lantern review
Posted By ShaneAwesome 1 June 17, 2011 08:15:14 AM

I would've seen it anyways. Green Lantern rocks.

Re: Green Lantern review
Posted By smashing 1 June 17, 2011 12:05:22 PM

I think it looks bloody awful and will wait for the DVD.

Re: Green Lantern review
Posted By willturland 1 June 17, 2011 10:31:20 PM

I just got back from seeing it. This review is pretty generous. It's not awful, but I'd say it's probably a 2 star movie at best. And the CG IS as bad as it looks from the trailers unfortunately, especially the messy end sequence.

Re: Green Lantern review
Posted By Colee0 1 June 17, 2011 11:24:54 PM

I didn’t know much about GL until I watched some of the animated episodes on DISHonline.com. What a great character; I just wish that the movie could’ve portrayed that a little bit better. I work for DISH Network so I like looking at a movie topic from all angles. I still enjoyed the movie and I recommend checking out the clips of interviews with some of the cast http://bit.ly/dJzWgo .

Re: Green Lantern review
Posted By GARZIE 1 June 18, 2011 02:32:11 AM

Saw the film today. I think the review is a fair assesment, it is not awful by any means but it just doesent gel together and is a bit all over the place. Especially the CGI and the acting is pretty inconsistent. Plus as the reviewer has already indicated the director is in such a rush to pack so much in , key scenes and themes which could and should have been expanded on are passed over far too quickly.

Re: Green Lantern review
Posted By Nephie 1 June 18, 2011 05:05:12 PM

Just saw it yesterday, and I agree with Garzie, the review is very fair. Could be better. Could be worse. Not boring, but not overly impressive. The CGI was passable, only distracting when they tried doing humans. (Well, Ryan.) All in all, it was a fun little hour and a half. There were some excellent little moments here and there, like Hal's "watch your back" reply (priceless indeed!) and, THANK THE HEAVENS, the balcony scene. That could have been the cheesiest point in the entire movie, but it wound up being one of the most believable.

Re: Green Lantern review
Posted By pinoysw1mmer 1 June 18, 2011 09:36:58 PM

I would have to agree that the balcony scene was gold. I really enjoyed the movie, but I find movies that take refuge in audacity to generally keep me happy, so I will be the third person to agree that you had a good review. I think other reviewers recently have forgotten that there are more than just 1 star and 5 star movies out there. There are a lot that fall somewhere in-between. I just loved how they let loose with GL's constructs. I think I wouldve shanked someone if he just shot laser beams at everything.

Re: Green Lantern review
Posted By AbsoluteVirtue 1 June 19, 2011 08:09:04 PM

I saw the film yesterday and I liked it. I do think this review was fair to what I thought of the the film after I had a chance to make a judgment. They did put too much exposition into the movie, which made the plot jump around a lot. But it wasn't a bad movie I was entertained throughout, which is what a movie is supposed to do. If I were to compare this movie to another superhero movie I would go with the first Spider-man movie. That movie also suffered from too much exposition and bad CGI, however with some good performances and art design it has turned into a classic. If this movie makes some good money maybe Warner Bros. will give more money to the effects budget for the sequel. That's what happened with Spider-man and its sequel Spider-man 2 was far more polished. Green Lantern is a fantastic story and it should be expanded upon. Especially the relationship between Hal and Sinestro. All in all a good first effort.

Re: Green Lantern review
Posted By TheBlur214 1 June 20, 2011 09:17:54 PM

Saw it this past weekend and I would say that overall, it doesn't work as a movie at all, and I get why the critics are being so hard on it as we live in a age where the stuff DC tried to pull with the story and characters in Green Lantern just won't cut it with other superhero movies, especially Thor and X-Men First Class. Marvel truly is ruling the summer. Having the hero and the villain know each other already either through being friends is fine as long as you make their relationship compelling (like Charles and Eric) or the downfall from watching the birth of the villain worthwhile (like Loki). And visual, super powered moments are important, but we have to care about the buildup to the moment when it happens in order for it to be exciting (like Magneto's submarine lift). Green Lantern was lacking either one of these, but I will say it had some redeeming moments. Reynolds was just fine, and I'll even say that Lively didn't bother me nearly as much as I expected her to. As many have mentioned, the balcony scene between them was nice, and to me it proved why they were picked to costar with each other, as the chemistry did feel natural and showed it wasn't hard for them to be romantic with one another. Mark Strong looked like he needed to be in his own solo or spinoff movie, his Sinestro is way too good for the bad script he had to work with. And the final battle with Parallax is fun once the movie finally gets to it, but that's the movie's biggest problem. Again compared to Thor or X-Men First Class, Green Lantern has very underwritten characters and story beats that make you want to just fast forward past their scenes to get to the somewhat cool action and CGI moments, even if the journey with the characters didn't feel worth taking once you finally get to them. Oh and my pick for the 2 worst scenes were when Hal called Tom for him to show up at the crashed alien site, the dialogue and jumps in logic in that scene were just terrible, and the scene with Hal, Tom, and Carol in the apartment trying to figure out what Parallax is was just dreadful, even the actors in that scene felt like they knew the dialogue was just plain bad. I would love to see Reynolds and Lively get a another chance at playing the characters, even though the movie itself doesn't actually deserve a sequel. Trying to have hope that if DC actually does get to a Justice League movie, Reynolds will still be up there as GL.

Re: Green Lantern review
Posted By Pontificator 1 June 21, 2011 12:55:13 AM

There is a fine line between a good movie and a great one – and this film flirted with that line but didn’t quite cross it. It couldn't decide if it wanted to be story driven or a summer blockbuster. And while trying to be a blend of both, became neither and left me feeling like there should have been more. It was a good time that had all the potential to be a great time...see my full review at The Boxed Office.
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image
 
 
Green Lantern

Green Lantern

Untitled Document

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Coke Zero
Advertisement