Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments

Rob Mclaughlin


Sometimes, movies just make you want to crawl out of your skin in embarrassment. Here are 10 terrible moments in comic book films

Published on Jun 12, 2008

Seeing your favourite hero on screen can often turn into a nightmare when the dialogue or action they are involved with leaves you squirming with in embarrassment. Here are some of the worst offenders:

1. Superman's big plastic S (Superman 2)

By far the best Superman adaptation put to screen, and for nearly two hours as a viewer you find yourself completely captivated by the fight between Superman and the troops of Zod. However, when the action moves to the Fortress of Solitude, the awe-inspiring fight scenes take on a rather daft edge when Superman, out of nowhere, envelops his nemesis in a big plastic sheet with the Superman symbol on it. Now I have read many, many Superman books, and have never come across a story where he has power over plastic bags. Presumably, they weren't even bags for life.

2. Daredevil and Elektra's playground fight (Daredevil)

Daredevil is half a decent superhero film that has a lot going for it in the form of Colin Farrell's scene-chewing Bullseye. And, to be fair, Ben Affleck's take on the man without fear was okay. However, the complete tonal change of the film comes about halfway through, with a truly jump-the-shark moment where Matt Murdock and Elektra spar in a kids' playground. Not only is it embarrassing to watch, but it ruins the film's premise that Murdock is blind. So how the chuff is he supposed to balance on a see-saw and dodge numerous kicks and punches from the ever-lovely but hollow-eyed Jennifer Garner? Surely at the end of the fight the dialogue should be changed to:

Elektra: Wow, you can really fight! Your wire-fu work is excellent! I bet you're not blind at all, are you? Hang on, let me guess: are you Daredevil?

Matt Murdock: Yes... yes, I am.

3. "When a toad is struck by lightning" (X-Men)

X-Men is one of the better series of comic adaptations, and while the fight scenes between the X-Men and the Brotherhood were generally handled well, the film was let down by a line that was delivered so badly there was a collective groan given out by the entire cinematic audience at the screening I was at. Donning a laughable wig, Halle Berry's Storm has done nothing of note for the first hour of the film, and when it was time for her to deliver the goods and provide the proverbial smackdown on the bad guys she comes out with "Do you know what happens to a toad when it gets struck by lightning?" Shudder! It's a good job that that director Bryan Singer didn't give her much screen time or that much to say in the rest of the film. She's supposed to be an Oscar winner, for crying out loud.

4. Bat iceskates (Batman & Robin)

Only ten minutes into the film we are treated to 'bat-booties', in a scene that would make the makers of the very worst neon-filled 80s nightmare rock video cringe. And it goes downhill from there. There's no excuse for this entire film. It should be wiped from our collective consciousness. If I ever see the producers of this excremental piece of cinematic tat, I've got quite a lot I want to talk to them about...

5. Banner vs Father (Hulk)

Nick Nolte and Eric Bana on screen, debating issues in front of a large power generator thingy? Wow, that's some action they've put there on the screen in this lamentable superhero flick. While it is debatable whether or not Ang Lee's Hulk is a masterpiece or a great big pile of gamma-dung, what was needed from this was action, adventure and a bit of fun. However, what we got was a father and son waxing lyrical about life, the universe and everything until Nick Nolte bites through a bit of cable and we are left with an incomprehensible, unwatchable pile of pixels getting thrown at each other for the big climatic pay off. Dull, boring and just plain silly, this scene was the nail in the coffin for the Hulkster and unless the new Incredible Hulk film knocks it out the park, then it will seem that the best on-screen Hulk work remains in the 70s.

6. Doctor Doom & Susan Storm (Fantastic Four)

Another attempt by Marvel to get its icons on the screen that well and truly got a drubbing by fans and critics alike. While watching the slow death of Marvel's First family on screen, head-in-hands viewers were then given the proverbial kick in the happy sacks when the limp-wristed Dr Doom (as portrayed, without any hint of menace, by Julian McMahon) asked his former partner (the peroxided and dead-eyed) Susan Storm to stop fighting. Bad. So, so bad. We all know Doom in the comics would have blasted her to cosmic ray dust without a second thought.

7. The emo dance (Spider-man 3)

Spider-man 3 was two quite good films edited down to make one piss poor movie. And while Sandman, Green Goblin 2 and Venom all helped make this hotch-potch of a movie completely unwatchable, on a second viewing it was the sight of Peter Parker strutting his funky stuff complete with emo hairstyle and hideous perverted sneer that makes the movie so very unlikeable. Sam Raimi, we all know that the studio pushed you into adding all the elements they needed to sell toys and such, but really? It was completely on your shoulders that this abominable piece of work ever graced the cinema screen. Shame on you Sam, and if it wasn't for Evil Dead your days in the my personal hall of fame would be very numbered indeed.

8. Giving the finger (Ghost Rider)

Having been chased by police and various other emergency services, the Spirit of Vengeance does the only thing a flammable, skull wearing demonic bail-bondsman could do in a situation like that. He turns round and gives them a single, middle-digit salute. How very hellish...

9. Shredding Hendrix (Howard The Duck)

Poor Steve Gerber was plucked, stuffed and well and truly basted in this insane (and yet enjoyable) romp from Lucasfilm. However, no matter how much Leah Thompson love there is in the world, and no matter how cute and sexy she looks decked out in 1980s pop paraphernalia, there is no excuse for a vertically challenged man in a duck suit pretending to play Jimi Hendrix on a guitar. None whatsoever.

10. Everything Mr Freeze says (Batman & Robin)

A second mention for Batman & Robin, but so very, very deserved. It's surely reason enough to let Joel Schumacher nowhere near even a comic ever again. The icing on this particularly unsavoury cake though was Arnie as Mr Freeze, whose every word left you wondering just how it could get worse. The answer, sadly, was usually just minutes away. Whether it's “Adam and Evil” or “A new age is coming...an Ice Age”, every word muttered from the blue painted lips of the Governator is just one sad puerile pun after another. It’s no wonder that he took up politics shortly after this mess, as surely any British actor would be obliged to hand in their Equity card.

More superhero stuff:

The Incredible Hulk review
10 ways to improve The Incredible Hulk
Why Ang Lee's Hulk rules
Hellboy II: early footage review
12 roles Michael Keaton could have played in The Dark Knight
Recast Your Franchise!
Iron Man review

Click here for a list of ALL the lists at Den Of Geek...

 

Users Comments

Re: Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments
Posted By SebPatrick 1 June 12, 2008 10:26:50 AM

It's rare that you see a top ten list where most of the things that you think of upon seeing the title are actually in there, but... fair play, you got the plastic S, you got the ice skates, you got the "toad" line... there's another B&R moment I'd have had, though, and that's the "credit card" bit. Sighhh.

Oh, and Superman I is better than II, clearly ;-) But have you ever seen the Family Guy riff on the plastic S bit?

Re: Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments
Posted By cjlines 1 June 12, 2008 10:48:44 AM

Numbers 8 and 10 are some of my favourite moments in superhero movies!

Re: Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments
Posted By Grrr 1 June 12, 2008 10:52:11 AM

You forgot the bit in Hulk when Hulk changes to Bruce Banner in one shot & you see his trousers shrinking down 2 size at the same time. The playground fight at the end of X-Men: TLS is also worth a mention, especially Vinnie Jones delivery of the line: "Im the Juggernaught Bitch!"

Re: Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments
Posted By DuncanMonkey 1 June 12, 2008 12:02:03 PM

Good call on the "Juggernaut bitch!" line, jeeze that line didn't just make me want to cringe but actually puke, in fact it might be one of my most hated things in a movie ever.

Am I alone in actually hating Batman Forever more than its sequel? Forever was such an awful let down, but at least by the time B&R came out I was already aware it would be beyond awful (and therefore downed a bottle of wine on the way to the cinema and enjoyed it immensly, like some kind of tramp who shouts "BOLLOCKS!" at passing cars).

Leah Thompson love can conquer all. Fact.

Re: Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments
Posted By PeaJay18 1 June 12, 2008 12:48:33 PM

Surely the whole USP of Daredevil is that he is blind - the movie didn't do anything Murdoc hasn't done in Marvel's pages.
Anyone complaining about the Electra fight has missed the point - he does these thing despite his handicap.
Does the whole of "Catwoman" make this list though?

And is it me or is every other article on this site "Ten Things I Hate About The Genre I Profess To Like"
How about some "best of" top tens?

Re: Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments
Posted By Grrr 1 June 12, 2008 12:52:57 PM

Both JS Batman films were fraking awful if u ask me

Re: Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments
Posted By stuxmusic 1 June 12, 2008 01:11:38 PM

Most of these I agree with. But the emo dance, I don't. While it was slightly cringy, it was hilarious, and it was exactly the kind of thing I've come to expect from Raimi. I have determined the worst bit of Spiderman3, and that is Eddie Brock. What a tool. And so when he and Venom mix, god it just gets bad. If you take brock out of the film, It instantly becomes better.

Re: Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments
Posted By Midnighter 1 June 12, 2008 01:46:34 PM

Surely all of Ghost Rider should be mentioned? It's one of the worst films I have ever seen. I liked the dance scene in SM3 if only for the impact it gives the scene straight after. And I agree with PeaJay18, how about more positive articles on here? I started coming to this site for news but am getting put off by the amount of negative articles moaning about things. How about some articles celebrating whats good in sci-fi/comics/etc etc

Re: Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments
Posted By DuncanMonkey 1 June 12, 2008 02:06:53 PM

Fear not, I am currently typing out Rambo love, with more Geek love to follow... one of which I'll be curious for other peoples opinions on as it'll be quite personal...

Re: Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments
Posted By MadOvid 1 June 13, 2008 01:37:22 AM

Catwoman deserves its own top ten list. And Howard the Duck is a classic!

Re: Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments
Posted By picknmix 1 June 13, 2008 08:04:21 AM

I can live with the Daredevil sequence. But the bit of Batman and Robin that really gets me is when Robin is being attacked by the vines...and they worked out they they didn't have a good shot of him been pulled underwater, so they play some later footage of him coming out backwards!!! It also makes me laugh how bad the Bat-girl headgear looks, which she then ditches at the earliest opportunity. Most of Ghost Rider and Electra made me cringe...especially the 'Ol'rider' rubbish in Ghost Rider. The cooking scene in Superman 2 is also diabolical, and the whole of Super-girl and Superman 4.

Re: Top ten cringe-worthy superhero movie moments
Posted By Kal_El_W7 1 September 4, 2008 04:34:59 PM

That Superman 2 moment was bad but for those who love their Superman films you have to watch Superman 2 the Richard Donor cut. It is how the film was supposed to be made. The Saldkins basically sacked him and brought in that joker that made the Three Musketters films that is why you have the comedy moments in 2 and 3. Seriously though the Richard Donor cut will change your life. It's darker, more serious how it was supposed to be. Also the whole bomb in the lift in France is crap, the missiles from one are what cracked the phantom zone. The film is badboy FACT!!!
Post a Comment
 
Ghost Rider
Ghost Rider: somehow, his middle finger isn't the most intimidating thing about him.

Tags: You may have noticed that tags have started appearing on new Den of Geek articles to make it easier to point you to other relevant content on our site. We are in the process of adding tags to all our archive of 5,502 articles. We hope to complete the tagging process by the end of the summer. Meanwhile all content can be reached via Search.

Check out the new classic Star Trek channel on Den of Geek
Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!