Sleepy Hollow season 1 finale review: The Indispensable Man & Bad Blood

Review Caroline Preece 22 Jan 2014 - 09:25

A rip-roaring finale makes the wait for Sleepy Hollow's second season an excruciating one...

This review contains spoilers.

1.12 The Indispensable Man & 1.13 Bad Blood

Now that was a finale! Even if your expectations for the final two-parter of Sleepy Hollow’s first season were sky high, I doubt you were expecting the sheer amount of excitement, adventure, information and cliffhangers that were given to us in the end. The Indispensible Man and Bad Blood often came off like the writers wanted to cram half a season’s worth of story and intrigue into just eighty minutes, and though that resulted in the whole thing feeling a tad overwhelming, it also means that there’ll be no dallying around when we return for season two (though, with FOX abandoning normal US scheduling practice, who knows when that will be?)

So much went down that it would be a fool’s errand to actually attempt to craft any sort of recap, so I’ll stick mainly to overall thoughts. We started the episode started in the middle of the story, with Abbie having received a new message from Moloch, prompting the mission to decipher Washington’s bible, find his grave, find the map and enter purgatory. By the end of the two-hour extravaganza, Irving had confessed to Evil’s crimes to protect his daughter, Jenny’s fate is unknown after a pretty nasty car accident, Katrina has been taken by the Horseman, Ichabod is back underground and Abbie has found herself stuck in purgatory with no way out.

Emerging from this episode was like coming up for air, and the various precarious positions our heroes have been left in just means that the wait for season two is going to be excruciating. Not content to just surprise and unseat us, the big twist of the season came in three parts – Parish isn’t what he seems, Parish is Jeremy and Jeremy in the second horseman. Most fans knew going into the episodes that War would most likely rise over the course of the night and Jeremy was going to turn out to be alive, but kudos to the show for amalgamating three of the questions we had into one big and very satisfying answer.

Anyone who has followed my reviews this season will know that the pre-holiday episode in which Ichabod discovered his son’s sad story was my favourite of the run, so his enactment of bitter revenge in this instalment couldn’t have been more perfect. Unlike the story behind the first horseman, Jeremy’s story was so unflinchingly horrible and tragic that you can almost get behind him in his hatred (though destroying the world, as always, might be a bit extreme). Add that to the fact that he’s being portrayed by John Noble, and you have an incredibly credible and compelling villain for season two.

It was hard to make out the details in the rush of action and reveals that went on, but there were a few things that stood out. John Cho’s complete (if we can assume it’s complete) story was more than a bit underwhelming and, especially in this episode, far sillier than anything else on screen. In contrast, the scenes in purgatory between Abbie and Corbin and Ichabod and his father were really well constructed and the very idea that all four horsemen might be people who have been wronged by our heroes makes for a very interesting show. Ambiguous, flawed heroes are the best kind, after all.

After the hype and momentum that Sleepy Hollow had built up over the preceding ten weeks, there was a good chance this two-part finale would be a letdown. It definitely wasn’t, and the big Jeremy/Parish reveal was satisfying yet tantalising enough to see us through to next September (or hopefully before). Sleepy Hollow was the best kind of show, and has proven that leaving us wanting more is a viable option for a network drama. Now, let’s wallow in the fact that one of the least anticipated series of the year actually turned out to be the most entertaining, and that entertaining doesn’t necessarily have to mean dumb. Now let the long, long wait for the new season commence.

Read Caroline's review of the previous episode, The Vessel, here.

Follow our Twitter feed for faster news and bad jokes right here. And be our Facebook chum here.

Disqus - noscript

Absolutely my favorite show of this season, and probably my favorite show in a long time overall. I absolutely cannot wait for next season, and will likely be preordering this season the INSTANT it is available on Amazon.

Well i must say, that was a pleasant surprise. I was enjoying the freshness of the show until episode 9-10 which i commented that it seemed to have lost some of its magic but things started to get back on track and i am delighted. Didn't see that Parish/Jeremy reveal coming at all and i loved it. Lets hope the writers can keep the pace and good work they have done here.I will be back.

really loved this season just a shame we have to wait for season 2

I am LOVING this show, I haven't been this excited about a show in a LONG time!

I loved most of this episode, but then it got to the Jeremy/Parrish thing and I was seriously unimpressed.

It's really similar to the ending of season of 3 of Angel, right up to the tortured son waves bye-bye to his dad buried in a box bit.

The similarity isn't what bothers me though. I just didn't particularly like the way it worked out in Angel and I'm not entirely looking forward to seeing what they do with it here.

Sleepy Hollow

The math doesn't add up. I knew Jeremy would return, I had no doubt about it. But this is where the math doesn't add up here. Jeremy was a young man, lets say on his 20s when was buried. Moloch raised him from his grave 13 years earlier. That would make him in his early 40s right now. But he appeared at least in his 50s, maybe in his 60s.

I think the answer to this is that his role as a Sin Eater has aged him before his time (if we assume that he didn't age while he was buried, which judging by the age of the actor in the flashback of him being raised by Moloch he did not).

I love the fact that John Noble has a recurring role with so much weight to it, he is a fantastic actor and I have only seen him in guest spots since Fringe ended. I predict that his character will be redeemed at the end, and the Cranes will have a positive conclusion to their son's fate.

I don't think that sin eating is the answer. I went back and looked at the close up of Jeremy's face when he was raised and it looks like it is Noble in that scene, specifically when it zooms on the heavily wrinkled eye. He came up as an already old man, because he did not stop ageing when he was buried, as he said he didn't die, and sustained himself on roots. This was because of his powerful blood, remember that he is a warlock, the priest that resurrected Washington and was beheaded was also a warlock and he didn't age in over 200 years as he kept guard over Death's head. So it is safe to say that any latent magical power in Jeremy's blood slowed the ageing process naturally.

WOW - Normally I hate season cliffhangers but this one was worth it for the finally reveal. So wasn't expecting that.

Sleepy Hollow caught me from the word go. I was initially concerned that it wouldn't be able to keep its initial momentum, let alone survive the whole 7 yrs it so arrogantly proclaimed from the start.

Here's hoping that this acutely intelligent show continues to deliver.

Let's say that while he was away and his heart stopped, he aged a bit. you can see the difference of b4 he was buried and after he was resurrected; A little different (maybe older) I donna why but this was the BEST cliff hanger ever!!! I hope they start the new one soon since its already been a month :(

Plot Twist, Death makes Washington the 3rd horseman :D or someone else Crane liked

I think it's more valuable to see the 7 as mythical than arrogant, especially consideing how 7 is used in the bible in general and Revelations in particular.

Sponsored Links