Penny Dreadful episode 2 review: Seance

Review Becky Lea 28 May 2014 - 06:45

Penny Dreadful continues to impress with more nightmarish intrigue in its second episode. Here's Becky's review...

This review contains spoilers.

1.2 Seance

The second episode of Penny Dreadful begins with another horrific murder on a foggy London street and whilst not mentioned again for the rest of the narrative, it re-affirms that the city at night is a dangerous place. The focus then shifts to the characters we were introduced to last week, but with some new faces in amongst the familiar. Chandler (Josh Hartnett) is still coming to terms with the events he has just witnessed and finds himself drawn to Brona Croft (Billie Piper). Meanwhile, Murray (Timothy Dalton) continues to work with Vanessa (Eva Green) to search for his daughter whilst Frankenstein (Harry Treadaway) introduces his new creature, Proteus (Alex Price) to the world for the first time.

If the first episode was merely a taster of the kind of nightmares that John Logan was willing to unleash with Penny Dreadful, then Séance is a hearty main course full of sex, intrigue and lots of death. There still haven’t been any major progressions in terms of plot, but what is teased is enough, particularly where Vanessa is concerned. Logan is far more interested in seeing these characters operate within this world, or rather on the fringes of it. The Gothic as a genre has always been concerned with what happens in the shadows, on the borders of respectability or that place between life and death. It is where these characters reside, linking back to the demi-monde Vanessa spoke of with Chandler.

The series is setting itself up to explore some of these intriguing binaries and the spaces in between. It's hinted at towards in the excellent opening credits, a series of images that clearly relate to plot developments. Like all good credit sequences, it perfectly establishes the dark atmosphere of the show, but it is also carefully constructed to reflect some of the wider themes that are emerging in the first episodes. Each shot is an image of two halves, filmed half in shadow and half in light. The colour scheme also reflects the murky society that the characters reside in as well as the fact that each of them appears to be hiding something, caught in the middle between shadows and light.

The episode makes much of the idea that these characters exist on the borders of this world from broader strokes like Vanessa’s communion with the dead to little textual references scattered throughout the characters’ interactions. For example, the poem Frankenstein and Vanessa quote is Wordsworth’s Lines Written In Early Spring, a time between the death of winter and the burgeoning life of spring. This theme of life and death was established swiftly with Frankenstein’s speech to Murray in the first episode and further emerges as an important strand here. Each character is tied to death in some way or pursuing the prolonging of life.

Another emerging theme is that of consumption, literally in the case of Brona who bloodily coughs and splutters her way through scenes both risqué and tame. Murray is consumed by his grief and it is influencing his every decision. There is clearly something from his past that Chandler is running away from whilst Vanessa is consumed wholly by another entity during this episode. Each character is being consumed by something from within, a monster they have to keep hidden. For Frankenstein, there is a physical representation of this in Proteus, but the final scenes reveal that Frankenstein too has something else that threatens him.

Alongside this is the introduction of the enigmatic Dorian Gray. In a wonderful reference to his literary counterpart, Gray is first seen positioned within a frame of a portrait behind him. Reeve Carney is every bit the louche aesthete, but he stands opposite to the other characters in that he appears to be the one consuming rather than the other way around. Art surrounds him in his home and he actively engages in creating it with photography. He observes other characters and deduces from their appearance and even tastes them at one point. His scene with Brona suggested a fascination with death and, if he is true to his literary counterpart, he has also discovered a way in which to prolong life, a motivation which is shared amongst various characters existing within that boundary between the two.

All of these themes clash spectacularly at one mesmerising point in the episode. The séance is a breakdown of these boundaries where life and death collide to torment the living. Eva Green’s performance in this scene was simply astonishing, combining some excellent vocal and physical work into a chilling, almost heart-stopping scene. Director J.A. Bayona produces something very unsettling in the way he shoots Green, opting for high and low angle shots and range of close-ups, cutting quickly around her performance. Coupled with Vanessa’s possession and the constantly shifting perspective, the scene is highly unpredictable and as a result, wholly captivating. In fact, it’s so good it nearly overshadows the rest of the proceedings and it certainly eclipses Helen McCrory’s Madame Kali (though I am looking forward to seeing more of her in future).

Perhaps the séance would have overshadowed the episode if it hadn’t been for the closing moments. Connecting back to the idea of something threatening from within, poor Proteus is ripped apart from the inside by Frankenstein’s first born creature. The episode had previously built up Proteus’ relationship with his creator into something quite tender, aided with the tranquil sensory perception scene in which Proteus discovered the outside worked. The arrival of the first creature shatters that instantly, along with the nerves of the audience.

With that cliffhanger and the narrative preceding it, there is an overriding sense that everything is shifting and uncertain, making it wonderfully unclear what Penny Dreadful will unleash on us next.

Read Becky's review of the previous episode, Night Work, here.

Follow our Twitter feed for faster news and bad jokes right here. And be our Facebook chum here.

Disqus - noscript

Well golly, that seance was sweary! I dropped me monocle don't you know!
I am loving this series so far. Quite often with what we feel are classic series (GoT, The Wire, The Walking Dead) they take a couple of episodes at least to properly bed in but have enough of a hook to keep you watching. Penny Dreadful so far, even with 2 episodes has me utterly hooked.
All of the actors are great so far and slip into the archetypes perfectly. Hell, even Josh Hartnett is great and I was never overly enamoured by him on his first go around in the later 90's/early 00's. Seems a few years in the relative acting wilderness has done wonders for him (purely in my opinion).
Oh and I hope they keep the Egyptologist around, he slays me.

Splendid episode,Eva Green simply steals the show with a cracking portrayal of a woman possessed.
Fish wives everywhere would be proud of her effing and jeffing.

Papyri,Papyri, I cant stop bloody well saying it now. Loved him,his voice is awesome.

I am shocked at how good this is, I watched it kinda expecting cliched ideas but I now await each episode like I do with GOT's. I've just watched ep3 and it gets better...however I find Hartnett and Pipers characters pretty much window dressing and not too deep compared with the other characters. That said I can already see whats gonna happen to Brona...

Nothing has twisted my nerves like this in a long time.Kudos to Eva Green & the crew for scaring me shitless!

Great show. I've always rated Eva Green as an actress. I've really enjoyed this show.

So the reason for all the swearing in this show is...??? Other than to make the show "edgy" and seem to be "cool" and get it on past the watershed hour I mean. Sort of like "Touch of Cloth" were they start out with a funny and good idea and then spoil it by having dirty gross jokes thrown in. Russell Brand fans must be pleased I guess.

Woooow, do you get dizzy in the thin air being that far up on your high horse?
Saying that, I do think think the swearing was rather overdone in the episode, but it did sell it well as a proper demonic possession.

It's also deeply historically/ pseudo-historically inaccurate. Nobody in England, even in extremis, swore until 1967. I believe it was a Tuesday when it started.

Simon Russell Beale is fabulous in it, isn't he. was an f-ing Wednesday at 4pm. Can't you get your sh!t together on facts man. :):) I am just lamenting how such a fine show becomes un-viewable to large segment of the population when they pull silly stunts like this to seem "cool." The show, actually both shows, would be better without so much swearing and more people would be able to watch them.

The dizziness is from the manure that comes out of some TV scriptwriter's minds sometimes. But you are right about the possession scene. Saying "Darn" and "Heck" and "Pee Pee" would not be quite the same. :)

"Oh gosh, I think I am horribly possessed, and I will pee-pee on you. I saw you Sir Malcolm having relations with her and her front lady bottom!"
Actually that kinda works.

Ha it! Cheers mate.

Is this coming to the UK iTunes at all? I really want to watch but I don't have Sky

Have you seen the Exorcist? Stick to Eastenders.

Yep...but would not let my kids see it until they were older. That was a movie though. Not really a good comparison for a more accessible television programme.

I effing suppose I am a little more effing dubious about what effing proportion of the potential tweting audience are likely to be effing put off by an excess of cuting language.

Effing right. :)

If a little bit of swearing is going to put people off then they're not that into the shows(s) anyway. And presumably they never leave the house except to go to church. I hear more swearing in a half hour bus ride than Penny Dreadful managed in 3 episodes (and GoT in the entire show to date).

Real people swear.

I don't swear. I'm real.

You dont take the bus, and you tell porkie pies. ;-)

Loving this so far, although I couldn't understand an effing word Billy Piper said. That accents a bit thick, I thought she'd be asking if anyone liked degs at any minute, ala Brad Pitt... ;)

Truly terrible, plotless show, all blood and sex used to cover up lack of any real content. Reminds of the last couple of years of True Blood

Yeah, pretty much.
Eva Green's performance this week was pretty show stopping, though.

I don't know if I agree with it being plotless - there do seem to be some interesting threads starting to appear - Murray's search for his daughter (and why she ran away), Vanessa's apparent demonic destiny.
I do agree with you about the blood and sex though - too much at the expense of moving the story forward. I thought I'd seen it all with GoT, but PD is even more graphic. What with this and just watching the episode of Da Vinci's Demons that saw the camera lovingly zoom in on a man getting his head repeatedly smashed in and I'm starting to wish for the days when programme makers had to find more creative ways of depicting violence without glorying in it so much.

Yep - awful attempt at an Irish accent! I don't know why they didn't get an Irish actress to play the part. Someone like Nora Noone would have been better.

Sponsored Links