Den of Geek

Doctor Who: Flesh And Stone spoiler-free review

Simon Brew


Ready for some good news? Flesh And Stone is another really strong episode of Doctor Who. Here’s our spoiler-free take on it…

Published on Apr 30, 2010


“If I always told you the truth, I wouldn’t need you to trust me.”

Flesh And Stone is easily the trickiest episode of Doctor Who to write a spoiler-free review for thus far, and not just for the obvious reason of it being the concluding part of a two-episode story. We’ll come to why a little later. Rest assured that we’ve sucked out anything coming close to a story spoiler here, but for this one in particular, it does mean you’ll have to bear with us while we’re a little bit vague in places. We'll have the full dissection as usual once the episode has aired on Saturday night.

Firstly, the news you came here to find out: Flesh And Stone, at its best, is just brilliant. It feels like an exciting back end to a really tense movie, sandwiched into an episode of Doctor Who. It also lays things down for the future, and adds on an intriguing ending that’s likely to generate a lot of discussion afterwards.

It picks up immediately after the cliffhanger we were left with in The Time Of Angels, and it’s an episode that then gets down to business very quickly. The cliffhanger is resolved in a fun way, but it doesn’t leave the Doctor, the clerics, Amy and River any safer.

Instead, it escalates, as you might expect, the ongoing threat of the angels, and sets up some terrific, really very tense scenes. There’s nothing quite as outright scary as the angel coming out of the television last week, although there are one or two moments that run it very close, and we jolted upright on more than one occasion too. Expect to remain on edge for most of the running time here.

What we love about the angels is that the Doctor is basically fighting a turn-based foe. It thus weaves in some strategic moments. Not deep ones, granted, but it brings the idea of consequence very much to the fore. If you turn off the lights, those angels there are going to move. If you take your eyes off them for a second, then they’re going to do something. Moffat has a lot of fun with that here, and continues to make the statues a thing of nightmares.

Thus, Flesh And Stone, for most of its running time, is tense, thrilling, and has a very real feel of peril about it. It might be down to the fact that we’ve still not seen the angels too many times in Doctor Who (they’re hardly at the stage where they’ve become diluted like the Daleks), but there are moments here where you really do buy that they’re as dangerous and utterly threatening as they are clearly intended to be. There aren’t too many Doctor Who monsters you can say that about.

Steven Moffat’s on fire here, too, matched toe-to-toe by director Adam Smith, taking full advantage of the fact that the angels are in greater supply than we ever saw them in Blink. What’s more, there's space and time here to have them do just a bit more, and it's very well utilised.

Moffat focuses more on the angels than he does with River Song this time, but there are things about her worthy of dissection once the credits have rolled too.

Flesh And Stone also gives us a real chance to see how well Matt Smith’s Doctor handles a proper, full-on crisis. He’s got a lot to puzzle out here, and he’s quite on edge as he does so (at one point in downright rage). Smith’s Doctor isn’t a controlled creation by any measure, and there’s an unease, a casual harshness about him that continues to impress, and takes a little bit of the comfort zone out of the heart of every episode. That's a good thing.

A quick word too for Murray Gold here. He gives Flesh And Stone an action movie score that fits the episode entirely appropriately. Appreciating that not everyone warms to the intensity of the music in modern Doctor Who, he really deserves credit for some excellent work here.

There are, on top of what we’ve discussed here, a few other threads in Flesh And Stone that you might not be expecting from an episode that you’d assume is just about closing off a two-part adventure. And there are continuing signs of some very dense plotting going on. Our take on that will have to wait for the spoiler-filled review coming on Saturday night.

For now, the news is good: Flesh And Stone is really, really good, the latest episode from a series of a show that nearly five decades after it first appeared, is in the midst of an excellent run of form.

Not for the first time in recent weeks, we can’t help concluding that it’s a brilliant time to be a Doctor Who fan…

The spoiler-y review will be here Saturday night...

Check out the new and ever growing Doctor Who page at DoG, where we are marshalling all the Who content at the site, including interviews, DVD and episode reviews, lists, opinions and articles on our favourite time traveller...

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Doctor Who: Flesh And Stone spoiler-free review
Posted By Interference 1 April 30, 2010 02:45:59 PM

shame next week is a pile of crap.

Re: Doctor Who: Flesh And Stone spoiler-free review
Posted By kev86 1 April 30, 2010 02:59:04 PM

Next week we have The Vampires of Venice. The Vampire Craze hits Doctor Who. But after reading the review I can't wait to see this week's episode and I have hope for the next one because has you said in your review it has been an excellent run.

Re: Doctor Who: Flesh And Stone spoiler-free review
Posted By gingeryoda 1 April 30, 2010 03:46:18 PM

Loved last week's.If this is as good as you say and the new series is out on blu ray,there should be the option to watch them both edited together.hey presto Who movie.

Re: Doctor Who: Flesh And Stone spoiler-free review
Posted By SpiritMuse 1 April 30, 2010 04:12:20 PM

I wish people would stop judging things they haven't even seen yet. It's so nonsensical. Yes, there are "vampires" in Vampires in Venice, but that doesn't automatically make it bad. You don't even have a clue what's going to happen in the episode! Unless of course you've had the privilege of seeing a super special preview version, in which case, please tell us how and where!

Re: Doctor Who: Flesh And Stone spoiler-free review
Posted By enzymion 1 April 30, 2010 06:20:05 PM

Am I the only one actually looking forward to Vampires of Venice? If you've watched any Being Human you'll know Toby Whithouse's vampires are less sparkly angst-ridden teenagers and more rip the throats out of an entire train full of people badasses. Though I'm pretty sure he's not going to go that far at half-six on Saturday night, he's still a great writer. He's proven it in Being Human and he's already proven it in Doctor Who itself, with School Reunion. So, seriously, stop moaning and just wait for the episode. We've already got two weeks to wait, and if I have to hear one more idiot whining about how Doctor Who is being turned into Twilight I may be forced to throw myself out of the nearest window.

Re: Doctor Who: Flesh And Stone spoiler-free review
Posted By Codgin 1 April 30, 2010 09:10:10 PM

doctor whos already had a werewolf and a ghost story, so those moaning about vampies, really? It only fits the continuing pattern. Anyway back to more pressing matters, thanks for another awesome spolier free review, excitement esclated woop!

Re: Doctor Who: Flesh And Stone spoiler-free review
Posted By sigsig 1 May 1, 2010 12:07:22 AM

@Interference - So you're a time traveller too? You've seen the episode? Obviously I can't say if it will be good or not, but you've just assumed they are following in Twilight's footsteps, when there's no evidence they have at all...

Re: Doctor Who: Flesh And Stone spoiler-free review
Posted By speakillkid 1 May 1, 2010 11:02:32 PM

To all these people whinig about vampires in Venice, you do realize there were vampire stories long before Twilight and Anne Frank right? Plus doing the Tom Baker years he had a vampire story called the State of Decay. So shut up with the moaning

Re: Doctor Who: Flesh And Stone spoiler-free review
Posted By ztom6 1 May 2, 2010 03:29:42 AM

Interference, pardon me for stepping out here, but do you really feel the need to talk about future episodes you've already seen in the comments section for spoiler-free reviews. I've noticed this a few weeks running and I'm not a fan.
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image
 
 
Doctor Who series 5: Flesh And Stone
Untitled Document

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Coke Zero
Advertisement