Den of Geek

Chuck season 3 episode 8 review

Billy Grifter


Chuck season three returns to our screens with the weakest episode of the run so far...

Published on Mar 3, 2010


3.8 Chuck Versus The Fake Name

Coming back after its enforced Winter Olympic break, I was hoping that Chuck would be firing on all cylinders, but to be honest this story didn't exhibit the low rumble of a V8, or even the chirp of a two-stroke.

Having seen where Chuck was heading earlier in the season, I could see a potential sticky patch ahead, and we ran smack into it here. The difficulties it encompasses are that they started with the premise that Chuck and Sarah break up, when Chuck decided - entirely at odds with the first two seasons - that he wants to become a real spy.

Given that their relationship was the dynamic that drove the first two seasons, that was a brave move, and one that they only took on with the assumption that they'd reverse that by the end of season three, presumably.

So they broke them up, and then matched them with new partners. Chuck got the million-dollar-smile of Hannah (Kristin Kreuk) and Sarah toughed it out with the man-with-the-charisma-of-office-furniture Daniel Shaw (Brandon Routh).

I've come to the conclusion, underlined by what happens in Chuck Versus The Fake Name that one of these relationships was broadly believable and the other wasn't remotely. If you didn't guess which, it's the one that, at the end of the story still exists, much to my increasing incredulity. The other unceremoniously ends before it's ever taken a real pay-day, and with a three story bar tab to its credit.

But it's not the only problem I have that's connected to Brandon Routh. The other is that his introduction appears to have had a detrimental impact on the show's budget, or rather they're having to make savings to accommodate him. The two obvious ones this week were the disappearance of both Morgan and General Beckman, with only Mr Grimes getting a rather lame reference to him being at a 'leadership seminar'. This felt generally like a cheap episode, and I can only hope they're collecting war chest funds for a splurge later on.

I could mention how poorly the Buy More was used, and that the scenes with Awesome and Ellie didn't deliver a fraction of their potential, but there were still some elements that worked very well.

Going undercover posing as the world's most lethal assassin, Chuck encounters two of the dumbest wise guys ever, played brilliantly by Tony Sirico (who really served time in prison for armed robbery) and Louis Lombardi (Edgar Stiles in 24). These two are so entertaining that it came as a big disappointment when they both ultimately got whacked.

For me, and others might disagree, this was a seasonal low point for Chuck. But it's only episode 8, so there is plenty of time for them to get back on track. What I'd like to see is a strongly themed episode, like some of the best from seasons one and two, and the Jeffster really need a proper outing soon.

I've got a feeling that once Routh leaves this show (please, let it be soon), then it might turn a corner, but then I am assuming he's at the heart of the show's issues.

Check out our review of episode 7 here.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Chuck season 3 episode 8 review
Posted By Odoakar 1 March 3, 2010 02:42:27 PM

I couldn't agree more. The romantic relation between Sarah and Shaw seems so out of place and forced. Even more, the fact she revealed him her real name, something she hasn't done with Chuck over a course of 3 years, not even coming close that that, shows how much this show jumped the shark with the last two episodes. The absence of Morgan, and general lack of any memorable Buy More scenes in this season, is really leading Chuck to becoming a mediocre series at best. And I don't get the whole Sarah falling in love with Shaw. She did the same with Chuck but always made sure not to get her personal feelings in front of the job. Now she suddenly disregards all that?

Re: Chuck season 3 episode 8 review
Posted By vasces 1 March 3, 2010 06:13:36 PM

Is it me or is Routh literally a charisma black hole. He actively sucks it away from other actors.

Re: Chuck season 3 episode 8 review
Posted By Slacker 1 March 3, 2010 06:34:01 PM

As Odoakar mentioned, Sarah revealing her name to Shaw was really forced, it also made any feelings/love she had for Chuck look second rate and misguided at best. Not a good move.

Re: Chuck season 3 episode 8 review
Posted By TheTeacher 1 March 4, 2010 08:00:53 AM

I don't think that Chuck jumped the shark, but in hindsight this episode was kinda strange. It nullified the relationship between Sarah and Chuck over the last two seasons and I don't get why they did that. Hannah seems a much more likeable character, but Chuck ditched her? Unbelievable. Still got hopes for this show, though...

Re: Chuck season 3 episode 8 review
Posted By Slacker 1 March 4, 2010 09:25:37 PM

One thing that I forgot, was the possible bone they're throwing to the (underused)Casey character. The 'Alex Coburn' flash might be a sign of good things to come!

Re: Chuck season 3 episode 8 review
Posted By chuckfan123 1 March 5, 2010 05:00:26 PM

I don't see why you and some think it's entirely at odds that Chuck now wants to be a real spy. First of all 6 months go by that we don't fully see and Chuck very convincingly explains in the beginning of this season why he has changed his mind. And the fact that he even uploaded the new intersect into his head in the season 2 finale is all because Sarah made him realize he is a heroic person and that combined with the fact that he knew they needed the intersect to have the upper hand against the Ring or any other bad guys is why he did it. And I disagree with most of the other points you and people make but this one is especially, in my opinion just wrong. And I love that they are very slowly turning Chuck into a spy. Because hopefully by the time he becomes a full out spy we will be a few more seasons into the show and it will have had it's fair run.
Post a Comment
 
Chuck Versus The Fake Name

Chuck Versus The Fake Name

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!