Den of Geek

Caprica episode 4 review

Mark Foster


Caprica keeps laying down its narrative foundations, but manages to throw a bone or two to feast on right now in its latest episode...

Published on Feb 22, 2010


4. Gravedancing

Okay, now that's a bit more like it.

For the last two episodes, Caprica has been sowing lots of seeds without really throwing much at us to wrap our heads around right now. Episode 4? That really began to address that with some style.

Before we got to the main highlight of the episode, we had a pre-credits explosion in an empty café, and suspicion inevitably heads in the direction of the STO. With that in mind, Sister Clarice gets a message out just in time so that the school locker of Keon has its explosives removed just before a police raid.

There's also the police search of the Graystone property covered, which we'd been promised in the last episode. The magic bullet wasn't there, but the ball has clearly been set rolling, and the investigation continues. No one seems to have come close to the idea that Zoe wasn't the bomber her mother thinks she was yet, though. It stands to be the great untruth at the heart of the Caprica story.

Then there was the Adama angle, most notably Joseph and his decision to order a hit - through his family contacts - on Daniel. He's given an opportunity to pull out of this, which he fails to do. It seems the contract was on, even though I was never really convinced that this was going to pan out quite as outlined.

But the centrepiece of the episode was the interview with Daniel and ultimately his wife Amanda on the Backtalk late night discussion programme. This was terrifically handled, exposing not just the fractions and disagreements between the Graystones, but also the necessity to keep public opinion on their side.

The balance of Daniel Graystone's life, and his family and business conflicts, was clearly thrown up. Thus, you had the build-up, and the coaching for Daniel, with his business people in the wings while his interview started to flounder. Eventually, Amanda stormed the show too, and Daniel announced he wasn't taking any more profits from the holoband. He also put out in the open the information that he'd been in contact with his dead daughter through an avatar version of her. That's bound to have ramifications.

It also certainly got Daniel and Amanda talking properly at last, but not before Joseph's hit nearly goes ahead. For the assassin, Sam Adama, takes Amanda for a ride, with Joseph desperately trying to call off the hit. Again, I never really bought for a second that Amanda was for the high jump, but we did get a scene where Sam let Joseph think that she was dead, which basically proved that Joseph had made the wrong call in ordering the assassination in the first place. Granted, I don't have one eye on how the storyline for the season pans out, but I wonder if Caprica should have taken the unpredictable turn here and had Amanda killed. Can you imagine how the tensions between the Adamas and Graystones would be ramped up then?

As it was, the tease didn't go on for very long at all, before Sam told Joseph the truth, and basically let him off the hook for the time being.

The episode did give us some time with Zoe, and Lacy too had a bit of minor work to do, but their roles were minor here. More beefed up was the character of Joseph Adama's mother-in-law, playing utterly against the idea of the friendly granny by declaring that she could happily kill Amanda Graystone with her bare hands. We believe her, too.

Still, this was very much a Graystone episode, and I really quite enjoyed it. I'm not utterly convinced that Caprica has yet managed to resolve its issues of balance between present and future storytelling, but I did enjoy the central narrative mechanic of the talk show, and having something of that ilk to hang the episode around certainly did the show a favour.

We're still some way from firing on all cylinders, though...

Read our review of episode 3 here.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Caprica episode 4 review
Posted By bytat 1 February 22, 2010 11:06:19 AM

that explosion in the beginning looked really bad.. if you don't have the budget to do it believable in cgi, don't do it.. better to do it the old fashioned way with some smoke and mirrors.

Re: Caprica episode 4 review
Posted By stuxmusic 1 February 22, 2010 12:00:30 PM

Sigh. Really, I want things to actually start happening in this series. It seems like everybody is just waiting for things to happen. I think it's going to be a while before it truely becomes good.

Re: Caprica episode 4 review
Posted By MarvMarble 1 February 24, 2010 01:44:48 AM

" wonder if Caprica should have taken the unpredictable turn here and had Amanda killed. Can you imagine how the tensions between the Adamas and Graystones would be ramped up then?" If that had happened due to Joseph unable to get through, or Sam going ahead regardless, then yes. Although I wouldn't have found that less predictable (shows do killed off main characters in the past on occasion.) However, I'm glad Joseph had the change of heart. I just didn't find that choice particularly believable from that character's point of view.

Re: Caprica episode 4 review
Posted By MarvMarble 1 February 24, 2010 01:48:35 AM

I'm curious of the whole "Caprican mind in Tauron body" thing though. On one hand Taurons are victims of racism, yet Sam seemed to be suggesting they're predisposed towards vendettas and vengeance. The granny seems to support that! It's almost as if they've earned the prejudism they suffer. I'm glad characters like Joseph are there to bring some balance.

Re: Caprica episode 4 review
Posted By cordas2 1 February 24, 2010 09:51:38 PM

I just love how this show is building, this is obviously meant to be an in-depth drama (even more so that BSG) with the way they are building characters and drama, I would put this more in line with shows like the Sopranos and The Wire than the likes of Trek or Stargate.

Re: Caprica episode 4 review
Posted By capt_1ntens0 1 February 25, 2010 01:42:27 PM

I really want to like this show but its really not giving us enough at the moment- you can say all you want about putting pieces in place but 1 or 2 good scenes per show do not a thrilling show make. Mainly so far this show is a bunch of navel gazing and it had seriously better dish up some meat soon or I'll lose interest. The thing with the Wire is everything was important to the overall narrative whereas you could lose half of the scenes in any Caprica episode easily and still follow exactly what's going on- the fact is this is snail pace writing because they don't have enough plot to fill a season. Also, and I suspect I have many people agreeing with me, unlike cordas2 I don't want to see the Wire in space, I want to see the rise of the Cylons. If I wanted gang politics I'd just watch the Sopranos. Aspirations by Ronald Moore to be the next Heavyweight TV Drama is exactly the reason the last season of BSG sucked ass.

Re: Caprica episode 4 review
Posted By GoldbergV 1 February 25, 2010 02:56:56 PM

I'm dangerously close to giving up on this show. As a massive fan of BSG (don't agree with capt_1ntens0, I liked S4 way better than s3) I thought I owed Caprica a chance but after 4 episodes its just not doing it for me. I thought the cylon dancing scene in this was just terrible, complete with the oh-so-hilarious "thats a nice chest" line, it just sucks. The idea of Zoe in the Cylon body is a crap narrative device, as the actress can only react and none of the other characters can see her anyway, so there's no connection for the audience. Then you have the whole issue of a massive heavy robot trudging round the house and no one hearing it or it being detected by the no doubt advanced security system. The only characters who are actually interesting are Sam Adama and Polly Walker's, although that may be down to the actress rather than the writing. I like slow-burn dramas like The Wire and Mad Men, but as said above, what makes them so compelling is that EVERYTHING MATTERS, whereas here very little happens and most of time quite unconvincingly too. I don't think Caprica has a clear idea of what it wants to be, is it a thriller, a soap, is it about artificial intelligence, religion, politics, terrorism, what? BSG had alll those elements, but its core premise was Robots That Want To Kill You. That was a killer hook. Caprica just seems meandering and unfocused by comparison. Sorry about the wall of text but DoG doesn't allow paragraph breaks

Re: Caprica episode 4 review
Posted By cordas2 1 February 26, 2010 10:27:38 AM

I found that the 1st time I watched The Wire that it took at least 4 episodes before I 'got' the show and that was watching episodes back to back, and it wasn't until the end of the 1st season that I realised how truly great the show was/is (the same applies to the Sopranos). The thing about slow burn and in depth drama is that it takes time to mature and having only seen 4 episodes of Caprica its far to early to start making judgement calls about how good it really is (or isn't). Personally I am doing what I did with much of BSG, I am sitting back and trusting that they know what they are doing , in BSG they rarely disappointed (and when they did it tended to come good anyway) so... yes Caprica is slow but I (want to) believe that its intentional, and that its part of the plan. If they had jumped in feet 1st and kicked off with Cylons smiting all and sundry then it would be a very different and I suspect unfulfilling show.
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image
 
 
Caprica: Gravedancing

Caprica: Gravedancing

Untitled Document

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Coke Zero
Advertisement