Den of Geek

21 ways I’d make British telly better

Robert McLaughlin


Do that many people die in little villages? Well according to ITV they do and John Nettles is always there to sort it out.

Rob has some things to say about the state of British TV right now. And he's got some suggestions to fix it, too...

Published on Dec 10, 2009

It's coming up to Christmas, with the notion of peace to all men and that kind of stuff. The nights are getting longer, and supposedly the idea is for people around the country to curl up on the sofa and watch a good film or television show, against a background of dark, stormy nights. We get snuggled up indoors all comfy, look at the box in the corner of the room and just say "give us your best shot". But what's this? Yep! It's winter, and the telly is rubbish.

No matter that the weather is terrible and the audience at this time of year is theoretically more attentive than usual. The amount of dross on the telly grows as the weather worsens. You'd think that the people in charge of television would help us through the misery of a British winter by putting something good on the TV for us to watch.

So, without further ado, I will try and solve the television world's ills by suggesting 21 things that the people in charge of telly (I guess that would be Ant and Dec and Simon Cowell?) could do to improve matters.

1. Don't stop the flow of a film with the news.

This is something that has infuriated me for years. Why does ITV need to show the news at 10 in the middle of a movie? Not only does it stop the flow but also usually makes the film finish too late for a 'school night'. A 45 minute break before they put on the last hour of the movie is beyond irritating, especially so now that we have dedicated news channels rolling the news every 15 minutes. Start the movie earlier or just have a bulletin, as there are an entire generation of film watchers who have never seen the second half of Die Hard, Commando, Con-Air and such like, as they just went off to bed or lost interest or couldn't be bothered to wait for the ‘finale of our nightly movie'.

2. Stop putting celebs in jungles...

...unless you are going to leave them there

3. We don't need an ‘X-tra' show about a show that's just been on.

Having to watch it once was nightmare enough. I don't care what the coffee boys opinion of this year's talent is...sod off.

4. Put Harry Hill on more shows

Witty, funny and with a hairstyle like mine. He could go far.

5. Stop Graham Norton getting work

He was great on his naughty Channel 4 show but a watered down neutered version is stupid. You employed him to be rude, crude and edgy, but slapping a PG rating on the guy and not allowing him to do his own thing is like Robocop without all the gory bits.

6. Stop commissioning Merlin

This is for two reasons. One, I can have my Saturday evening back and not have to watch it to review? And secondly, it's just plain bad. In its place maybe try a return of Blake's 7 in that timeslot instead?

7. Watch some American telly

Broadcasters: why not join up with American production companies? America has been producing some superb shows (Galactica, Lost, 24) which are essentially 20 hour movies. Why can't we have a little money invested in stuff here too?

8. Tone down the interaction

Stop reading out texts on shows giving the general public's opinion on stuff that they know nothing about and have little concept of as its not in Heat or explained to them by The One Show (which I will come to later). The regular watcher of Jeremy Kyle has little to no knowledge of world politics, economics or socio-economic issues surrounding the Middle East, so having messages like "Trace from Notts texts us ‘Get R Boyz home from fitn bddys in desrt, Luv U Lots xxx LOL, LTR'" doesn't really add to the debate.

This type of pandering to idiots just encourages them that their vacant statements will actually do something. Whereas, in fact, they'll just lose them money which they could be spending on scratch-cards.

9. Quiz show phone-ins

Stop making quizzes on telly aimed for people with brains like infants, for which life is just shapes and colours. Taunting the mentally inept is just cruel. Just because people can't do the probability on their chances of winning a rigged quiz (allegedly) doesn't give television channels a right to use them as walking cash converters. I will make it easy: PHONE INS ARE A MASSIVE CON (just like fruit machines). It's like them giving me a pound every day for the rest of their life and then maybe in some distant future I will get a fifty pound note back to them (maybe).

Building up their hopes to then dash them is like telling a primary school kid that Santa isn't coming. Surely the clue to how deficient the phone-in quizzes are can be exposed by the quality of the questioning.

Stuff like....

The Sky is what colour?

A - Blue

B - It's A

C - Its Still A

Send us money now, with no chance of winning. Go on, do it, do it now, or we will take your benefits away.

I might be vitriolic and evil saying that, but those who control the quizzes are a lot, lot worse.

10. The Beeb's over reliance on the costume department

You've tapped Dickens and Bronte enough; try some contemporary authors instead (Neil Gaiman, Bernard Cornwell etc...) to make an adaptation of. It will cost you a lot less in frilly knickers and ruffles.

11. Stop relying on past glories

Del Boy can only fall though the bar so many times (unless you're watching Dave, when it appears to be a weekly occurrence).

12. Let Steven Moffat write everything

It might not be practical, but it would be great.

13. Call Joss

Give Joss Whedon a ring, a lot of money and get ‘Ripper' on the telly.

14. Stop the singing

Get rid of karaoke shows on Saturday nights judged by leprechauns, shop dummies, mime artists and the man who gave us Robson and Jerome.

15 . Let creative people have a go

Long gone are the days when Lew Grade took risks with The Muppets and Thunderbirds. Can we get someone of his ilk back please?

16. Please, please, please...

... stop allowing Tango-coloured women with space-hoppers on their chests to tell the world the state of their gutter press relationships on prime time TV.

17. Murder Mysteries.

Really, do that many people die in little villages? Well according to ITV they do and John Nettles is always there to sort it out.

18. Take off ITV2/3/4 etc....

....or as they should be called ‘channels that have shows and presenters on them that aren't good enough for real telly'. You can keep E4 while it's making shows like Misfits, though...

19. Make Stephen Fry a knight...

....with the title ‘the King of telly'.

20. The One Show

Having to endure Adrian Chiles while I am having my tea is just wrong. Adrian, stick to the footy, mate. At least with that you look as though you know what you are talking about and seem to be having a bit of fun doing it (even though we all know the Baggies are hardly ever on).

21. The One Show (again)

Who allowed Gyles Brandreth back on television? Can someone sort that out?

Add your own suggestions below...

Click here for a list of ALL the lists at Den Of Geek...

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By cordas 1 December 10, 2009 09:27:15 AM

22. The lowest common denominator isn't a goal that should be aimed for! A little bit of aspiration can go a long long way.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By cordas 1 December 10, 2009 09:32:38 AM

23. Tension and drama are things that work best when they come from a decent plot, script, good acting and appropriate direction and musical score. Quick camera cuts, loud music, constipated actors face, ticking clocks, 'defusing the bomb at the last second' are just cheap tricks that don't work on any viewer with more than 3 functioning brain cells.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By cordas 1 December 10, 2009 09:35:19 AM

24. Drama should be intelligent and thought provoking, not turgid ill conceived garbage. Yes Auntie I am looking at you, if you want to look elsewhere for inspiration look to C4 not ITV!

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By cordas 1 December 10, 2009 09:37:33 AM

25. You can hold the camera still and do action without a million camera cuts a second... If you don't believe me then go and watch Children of Men, there is a scene at the end of the movie that is full of action and was filmed with one camera in one take that is minutes long and simply awe inspiring!

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By cordas 1 December 10, 2009 09:40:58 AM

26. Probably the most important point.... Just because something works once doesn't mean that you have to repeat it endlessly. The reason it probably worked so well the 1st time round is because IT WAS NEW AND IT WAS DIFFERENT! When it has been plagiarised for the 28 millionth time... its no longer new, different or interesting!

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By cordas 1 December 10, 2009 09:41:36 AM

27. Bring back Robot Wars!

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By miladyblue 1 December 10, 2009 10:13:47 AM

Uh, be careful what you wish for with the request "more American television." There are probably hundreds more channels of pure dreck than you have over in the UK. From the sound of it, with your luck, you would be getting crap we Americans wouldn't watch on a bet.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By Feefers 1 December 10, 2009 10:27:46 AM

I concur fully with Miladyblue and also 13. give Joss a ring, Joss Wheadon is a bigger hack then Russell T Davies, oh look at this awesome i've created, really why has it been cancelled after only 1 season then, oh becuase it was utter tosh that only devoted Wheadonites were watching. I do at least agree with 4, 15 and 19.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By stuxmusic 1 December 10, 2009 10:54:30 AM

"Give Joss Whedon a ring, a lot of money and get ‘Ripper' on the telly." YES! "why has it been cancelled after only 1 season then" Because Fox are douches and don't promote his shows and then put it on a friday. Simple. Fox cancelled the second season 2 episodes in! Oh aye, give em a chance! They gave him firefly, cancelled it, THEN COMMISION A FILM. They clearly have no idea what they're doing.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By Kahotep 1 December 10, 2009 11:47:40 AM

Stop letting internal politics affect programming. How many potentially successful, good shows have been killed off because they were the babies of the previous regime, and now that a new Programming Head or somebody is in charge, they want to make a clean sweep and stick said shows in ungodly time slots? They're your babies now, you don't have to act like the new Alpha Male of the pride and eat the offspring of the one you replaced!

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By evanjdooner 1 December 10, 2009 12:41:41 PM

/rant. That is all.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By michaelbush 1 December 10, 2009 12:46:14 PM

9. There are rules about the difference between giveaways and 'quizzes' that make doing a question that everyone knows the answer to a much more viable option. I don't know what these rules are, I just know that Simon Amstell used them to explain the fact that Popworld's multiple choice answers were always hysterically funny. 13. Maybe, during that phone call, you'd have to say, "Really, Joss, your best days are behind you... I know, I know, it's sad, but Dollhouse really was a load of old arse and the fact that every fifth episode shone through is simply not good enough... No, really, are you going to cry executive meddling on all your failed projects? And one might ask quite why you signed a deal with Fox in the first place if you're so against them... What the world needs now is for you to shut up, dig out your old notes, and write that nice thing about Tony Head and a load of old ghosts that they've been waiting for... And get a decent script editor who can make your depiction of the English something other than laughably bad." I don't know. I actually think TV is... kind of... doing alright?

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By atheistgirl 1 December 10, 2009 12:47:56 PM

Someone should tell Simon Cowell no.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By bazellis 1 December 10, 2009 01:25:22 PM

Start showing the latter seasons of The Office (US)

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By crawledoutofthesea 1 December 10, 2009 01:34:52 PM

Midsomer Murders is class.Though I used to live in the area they film some episodes in, and it lent an extra terror to walking home in the dark. I was always waiting for a deranged octogenarian dressed as a medieval knight to jump out and murder me in some wine-themed manner, because I was about to sell his ancestral home to hotel developers who would desecrate his orchid plantation. Or something.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By gudge 1 December 10, 2009 02:00:38 PM

28. Put Lost on every channel, 24 hours a day.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By edip1976 1 December 10, 2009 02:34:06 PM

Now just hold on one second. As an American, I usually sit in envy of British TV. Our shows are nothing but reality shows, CSI and Law & Order, with 5 nights of Jay Leno chat in the 10 PM drama slot. Lost, BSG & 24 are good, but they are absolutely the exceptions, not the rule. American Tv is far more inclined to appeal to the lowest common denominator the the Brits. I'd much rather watch Life on Mars, Ashes to Ashes, Doctor Who, Jekyll, Torchwood, Coupling, Black Books, Not going out, Mitchell and Webb, etc, than most things appearing on US Network TV. If anything I wish we would take a cue from the UK, shorter seasons, tighter storylines and yes...Steven Moffat writing everything..

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By Nocturne 1 December 10, 2009 02:39:04 PM

29. Live public executions, starting with Jeremy Clarkson!

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By chewedmelon 1 December 10, 2009 02:43:41 PM

How about a British remake of The Office: An American Workplace? :P

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By Shadowcat 1 December 10, 2009 03:27:44 PM

I agree with miladyblue and edip1976. I live in the US and most of what is US television on is pure garbage. The only US televison shows I watch are Lost, BSG, Stargate Atlantis, and Ugly Betty. I own a lot of UK televison shows like Shameless, In The Thick of It, The IT Crowd, Foyle's War, Spaced, Gavin and Stacy, Coupling, Skins, Black Books, Primeval, Dr. Who, and The Office on DVD. I am a woman of color and US televison shows are full of negative sterotypes about women and minorities. TV shows full of idiotic "ghetto" humor is what passes for diversity. Dr. Martha Jones from Dr. Who and Torchwood is my favorite character. There are no Black female characters like her on US televison. The reality shows are horrible. Hollywood blockbuster movies are rubbish for the most part. I opened an account on Amazon UK so I can order UK films and televison shows that aren't released in the US. I would rather watch BBC, Channel 4, or ITV than ABC, CBS, TBS, or TNT. I have about 100 digital cable channels with nothing but mindless crap. I mainly watch BBC America and Sundance Channel.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By DavidFullam 1 December 10, 2009 03:54:07 PM

7 and 12. WTF?

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By Bassthang 1 December 10, 2009 05:03:35 PM

British TV seems to have got progressively worse since the early 80s. American TV on the other hand seems to have improved massively over the same period (anyone remember "Jigglevision" in the late 70s?). I don't watch TV much these days, but when I do catch a British drama show it's often aping the conventions of American shows to some extent (yes, even our beloved Doctor!). Comedies? Again we seem to have lost the knack since the glory days of the 70s (which explains why Porridge and Rising Damp seem to be permanently on the air again). Maybe I'm just getting old and crotchety, but most modern British comedies just seem coarse. The last show that I found really intelligent and funny was Blackadder (maybe with Red Dwarf just hanging on in there - if only because of the lighbulb joke). News in the middle of films: yes, bloody annoying, especially when the news seems to be so dumbed down on most channels now. Graham Norton: yes, get rid of the annoying twit! He's taking over from Terry Wogan as TV's main camera-hogger (or is that Jonaton Ross?).

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By Tlotoxl 1 December 10, 2009 07:58:53 PM

Somebody got up the wrong side of the bed didn't they? American telly looks good simply because us in the UK only see the best of it - for every Battlestar Galatica there is going to be plenty "Bold and the Beautifuls", likewise the reverse - if any American watched "Big Top" they would probably gouge their eyes out after 2 minutes rather than have to watch the entire show._________________________________________________ Personally I think UK TV is in fine heath - QI, HIGNFY, The Thick of it, Top Gear, Doctor Who, TV Burp, James May's Toy Stories, The History of Scotland, Meercat Manor, Life... all quality and on in the last couple of weeks. The 70s were no golden Age either, interminable, long since unfunny series like Hi-de-Hi, Allo Allo and abominations like Heil Honey I'm Home!, Brighton Belles, Curry and Chips, Little and Large, Celebrity Squares and many others.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By edip1976 1 December 10, 2009 08:34:10 PM

And for those of you who prefer drama - there's sport.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By Martinus 1 December 10, 2009 09:04:51 PM

A sporting event should be on no more than one channel at a time. Coverage should stop at the scheduled moment, no later. Even if a British player is about to be knocked out.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By Carbontoe 1 December 11, 2009 08:27:08 AM

Don't stop the flow of a film with the news - I vote with my finger - I don't bother watching the films that span the news.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By picknmix 1 December 13, 2009 09:51:30 PM

I'd like a show where you get to hunt celebrities with your weapons of choice. I'll happy to hunt Davina McCall with a AC130u-Spectre Gunship for the pilot show, or Ant & Dec with knitting needles if the budget is less.

Re: 21 ways I’d make British telly better
Posted By essjayar 1 December 21, 2009 09:13:23 PM

As you can see by the comments above, both British and American TV have their successes and their flaws. Don't forget they are commercial enterprises, in the main, and live or die by their audiences. The exception is of course the BBC which can afford to take chances - and frequently does. American subscription channels such as Showtime also have that flexibility. There is room across the wide range of channels for both mass audience pleasers such as reality TV and X-Factor and it's ilk, as well as the standout genre hits such as Lost, 24, Doctor Who, Dexter, Fringe, Battlestar Galactica, etc. The future - as I see it - will be more collobarations between international partners, such as that which saved Primeval. There we will see our favourite "geeky" hits thrive, with DVD sales and merchandising also serving to boost the finances. I understand the audience of this site is undeniably biased but please be aware that the success of stuff like X-Factor and Celebrity finances the things we love to see :-) It's a shame ITV has become a shadow of itself, but the BBC (whether you agree with the licence fee or not) and C4 continue to bring us quality drama. Maybe this is all obvious, but whenever I see rants about the decline of British TV or the failure of US TV to support it's genre series I feel obliged to comment...
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image
 
 
broken TV
Untitled Document

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Coke Zero
Advertisement