Den of Geek

The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already

Ron Hogan


The mid-season finale of The Walking Dead jolts the season back to life, with an outstanding ending. Here's Ron's review...

Published on Nov 28, 2011


This review contains spoilers.

2.7 Pretty Much Dead Already


It's the end of an era on The Walking Dead. While the gang appears to still be on Hershel's farm for the foreseeable future, we finally get an end to the Sophia storyline.

Of course, this is also the official end of Frank Darabont's reign as show runner and the beginning of Glen Mazzara's term as the zombie master of TWD. No matter what you might say about the show thus far, the first season was riveting. The second season had a great debut, but since then, the fire has gone out of the show in a sense. It's still been good to great television, depending on the episode, but it hasn't felt epic.

Part of that is budget, and part of that is subject. There's more now, so it loses that breathless anticipation it had in the first season and the earlier episodes of the second. The budget got cut, so they're shooting indoors more and cutting back on the big effects scenes. The Sophia thing has just been a dragging anchor, and everyone knows it. This week's episode of The Walking Dead has many of the flaws of the second season so far, but the ending was so great that it made up for everything. The half-season goes out with a bang.

The secrets are being brought to light. Hershel's secret barn of zombies? Everyone knows. Lori's pregnancy? Shane knows. Hershel's plan to usher the group off of his land by the end of the week? Rick knows, thus everyone finds out in some way. Even Dale's started putting together the truth about what happened to Otis, and he's willing to take action to preserve the group's safe haven, even if that means butting bald head to shaved head with Shane.

An interesting touch to the show this week was Hershel and Rick's trip into the swamps to pluck some zombies out of the muck and mire. If you've been wondering why the farm's been zombie-free, this might be your answer. When you're surrounded by swampland, that makes walking to places a bit more treacherous. Of course, the zombies could use the road, but zombies aren't that smart and this - combined with the fact that the town is tiny - explains why they're not fully overrun with walkers. In any zombie apocalypse, they tend to gravitate to where there's food. That would be Atlanta in this case, not Doogal County. There'd be no zombies there because once all the easily-accessible people were dead, they'd wander off towards snack city. The few malingerers would get snared in the swamp and end up in Hershel's barn.

Jon Bernthal and writer Scott Gimple have done wonders with Shane's slow-burning turn towards the dark side. If nothing else, Shane has become a great semi-villain. When Shane learns of Lori's pregnancy, he responds rationally, but emotionally. He's hurting, but he doesn't lash out when Carl gives him a chance. Instead, he responds to Carl like a father would, and the look of pain on his face when he looks back at Lori and Carl was just hurting.

Yes, Shane is cruel and sleazy and evil, but he's not a one-note cackling villain. He's still a person, albeit a damaged person. If Bernthal doesn't get an Emmy nod for his work - if only for this episode - then TV critics have about as much respect for horror as film critics do.

Shane could easily become a straight villain, but so far, they've resisted that temptation and given him character. Shane's rash, but he's not a monster. Yet, Shane's simply the anti-Rick. Shane's cunning enough to know when he has to make Rick do something, yet not quite cunning enough to know when not to rush into a situation with guns blazing.

As for the other characters, there's some good moments this week for the rest.

Dale's confrontation with Shane was very well done, as was Glenn's interaction with Maggie after their initial squabble. Even Dale and Andrea address the elephant in the room in their relationship (an elephant named Shane Almost Killed His Best Friend In The Woods). T-Dog, who gets the least amount of screen time, has become the go-to character for a great one-liner. If you want one line delivered with the maximum amount of hilarious impact, it usually ends up in IronE Singleton's mouth. That may just be because I'm always shocked to see him speak, I'm not sure. Either way, for good chunks of season two he's been Mr One-Liner.

I'd like to see this continue, honestly; T-Dog may not get to say anything for hours at a time, but at least he says something to look forward to. That's more than you can say for a lot of the group.

Director Michelle MacLaren worked some great shots into this episode. Sure, it was a lot of the usual walking and talking, but she had some good crane shots, used a lot of the countryside well, and worked some great reaction shots, too. There was a killer zombie face-off in the beginning of the episode that everyone knew was coming (but was still great). There was a wonderful dolly shot of Rick's horrified face when he went to the barn to discover the truth for himself.

Most impressively, there was the entire final five minutes of the episode.

It was incredibly well crafted. There was a great mix of reaction shots with the violence, and the violence itself was handled with ballet-like beauty. Plus the use of sound (or lack) was spot-on. That one scene and that one gutsy decision has pretty much saved the first half of season two. It was stellar and gave me flash-backs to Bonnie and Clyde's final car trip in a way. That haunting last scene of the episode was perfect, both in tone and execution.

The Walking Dead is now officially off the air until February 12, 2012. They've given us a reason to come back for episode eight and beyond, and in the process they displayed more bravery with their writing than I would have expected. If they'll cross the lines they did in this single episode, who knows what'll go down in the final six of the second season?

Read our review of the last episode, here.

US Correspondent Ron Hogan is glad to see some forward momentum on the second season of The Walking Dead. Find more by Ron daily at Shaktronics and PopFi. Find more by Ron daily at Shaktronics and PopFi.

Follow our Twitter feed for faster news and bad jokes right here. And be our Facebook chum here.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By bobsuncorp 1 November 28, 2011 09:24:44 AM

ohmygodjohntravolta completely ruined this episode for me by detailing exactly what happened throughout the entire ep in the comments of last weeks review. Thanks a lot for that. Moron.

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By Slikkdikk 1 November 28, 2011 10:22:05 AM

If your talking about the review above smart one, he clearly stated "Spoilers" at the top, and also... Watch the show before reading a review. "reviews" typically talk about the show... Hmmmm..... All in all though, great season, great ending. I'm anticipating the next season!

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By joely7 1 November 28, 2011 12:28:01 PM

ohmygodjohntravolta you are a tool, how about you get lost over a cliff or something

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By paulychilds 1 November 28, 2011 12:35:22 PM

SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS --- The relationship with the comics is indeed a strange one since it veered wildly from the source material by removing a character who is very much alive and kicking on paper to this day. The ending was a tremendous shock, and very well done. It reminded me of The Mist - Frank Darabont's other shock ending involving the death of a child.

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By fennyfenn 1 November 28, 2011 03:16:22 PM

best episode of the season, the last 20mins was heart racing

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By janiac83 1 November 28, 2011 05:29:43 PM

Does this site not have moderators/admin to delete troll/spoiler posts? It's clear some bell ruined this week's ep for readers in the previous episode's comments box (without announcing spoilers were in his post) so maybe sort it out in future yeah?

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By Shilling 1 November 28, 2011 11:18:17 PM

Yes, luckily I realised what ohmygodjohntravolta's post was so didn't read all of it - but leaving the post there and not banning ohmygodjohntravolta is a major oversight by Den of Geek's controllers. If you don't want my page hits then you are doing a good job of making me stay away.

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By charlatan 1 November 29, 2011 08:12:17 AM

I was lucky enough to skip over ohmygodjohntravolta's post last week after reading just the very start of it, but I'd be very disappointed if his account doesn't get blocked by the Den of Geek moderators too. Pouring out spoilers for the whole next episode in a review of the previous one? Uncool, and uncalled for.

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By Graygray 1 November 29, 2011 10:35:46 AM

Fortunatly, since DoG reviews have gone downhill I only occassionally read them - and thereby missed the spoiler. Part of me knew that Sophia wasn't going to make it, although the reveal that she was in the barn was a total WOWSER!!! Seems to be a lot of hate for the idea that she was in the barn all along but Hershall never mentioned it to Rick... Seems more likely that either Otis (who Hershall states WAS their zombie catcher) grabbed her before Shane shot him leaving no time for him to tell anyone... or alternitivly, she took shelter in the barn and was killed there. Either way, it was a totally tragic moment - although I thought that the real power in the scene was the way that Rick regained the power in the group, not by killing a horde of zombies (as Shane did) but by simply having the strength to kill Sophia. // I guess her time was numbered, the comics have been running for over 5 years now with only a 18 months passing in the story. For a child actor, it would have been impossible to maintain the illusion of being a 9 year old over 5-6 seasons of a show... Have to wonder how safe Carl really is!

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By gudge 1 November 29, 2011 12:09:35 PM

I noticed the spoiler, but figured it was one man rambling to be "funny" or posting spoilers to be a dick. Regardless, skipped it. To be fair, i was already positive i knew what was goign to happen cos of the books (i was wrong).

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By gudge 1 November 29, 2011 12:11:07 PM

Also, when i noticed the possible spoilers I looked online to find the episode and couldnt. Also, Aintitcool didnt even see it before Sundays episode, so how did he get that information already?

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By chewedmelon 1 December 1, 2011 04:52:38 PM

ohmygodjohntravolta didn't spoil anything. I read the first line of his post realised it was a synopisis and STOPPED reading. If you read the whole thing you spoily yourself. Idiots.

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By janiac83 1 December 1, 2011 05:01:37 PM

It was a cursory glance whilst scrolling down the comments at the offending post when I saw the words "Kills Sofia". I therefore didn't know how she died until the episode aired, rather I just knew that she did thanks to the post which anyone could have seen the spoilerific part of rather than read through the whole thing, which I was not so "idiot"ic to do as you so charmingly phrase it :)

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By avoidz 1 December 2, 2011 02:33:13 PM

I'd given up on this show a few episodes into season 2 (the writing and pacing is TERRIBLE). But I'd heard about this episode and decided to find out what happened on the farm, and to Sofia. Hershel is a complete idiot keeping zombies as pets, and Dale wants to throw their guns in the swamp?? IDIOT! That said, the final minutes of this ep were great. I half expected someone to shoot Shane, but thankfully they followed his advice and did what had to be done. He's the only sensible one in the group. Not a bad way to end a mid-season.

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By bobsuncorp 1 December 3, 2011 12:08:43 AM

Avoidz, I don't think Dale intended to throw the guns in the swamp, he was just hiding them there temporarily so that Shane couldn't get them. Hiding guns from the guy who is rapidly going off the deep end seems like classic Dale type wisdom to me (like not telling anyone he'd fixed the RV so they wouldn't "start doing math". Also you bring up a point about the difference between Shane and Rick that I wanted to address: many people (in the audience and in the show) seem to be of the opinion that Rick is naive and Shane is realistic. I think that Rick's idealism is what is keeping the survivors from turning into bad guys. When you look into the darkness, the darkness looks back. In the world they live in, it would be incredibly easy to only look out for yourself and your family, but that is not a long term solution, and by doing so you would ultimately become just as much a monster as those that try to eat you. The reason our survivors are people worth rooting for is because that idealistic example Rick sets balances out the nightmare they are living in. It is the reason why nearly 100 issues into the comic they are still worthwhile human beings whereas nearly every other survivor they have met has been in one way or another a bad guy. And Rick is still able to make the tough decisions when he has to too, he was the one that shot Sofia after all. I firmly believe that if Andrea had left with Shane, they would have made a good team right up until the point when he Otis'd her.

FX - it's driving me nuts!
Posted By Monkey_thumbz 1 December 3, 2011 12:40:22 AM

A fantastic hour of television - a really good pay off for the slower than expected pacing of the middle episodes. *However*, does anyone else watch this show on FX? I'm sick to death of the way this channel treats its shows. Firstly, that awful joop sponsorship is so damn intrusive, spoiling the end of any quiet scene with a crash of noise and garish colour. Then there's the credit squeeze at the end of every episode where they show spoilers for the next episode. Finally, the bloody voiceover!! At the end of tonight's episode there wasn't even a pause after the dramatic reveal before some woman was telling me what was on next. It completely spoiled the dramatic impact of the unexpected ending. Surely I'm not the only one that's bothered by this? I know a lot of channels do this sort of thing but FX seem much more intrusive than most. Any thoughts?

Re: The Walking Dead season 2 episode 7 review: Pretty Much Dead Already
Posted By hoopla 1 December 8, 2011 05:43:40 AM

Great episode. Great review, apart from the use of the word "malingerer". I do not think that word means what you think it means.
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image
 
 
The Walking Dead
Untitled Document

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Coke Zero
Advertisement