Mark Pickavance
Pixar is the company that changed the face of animation. From humble beginnings it’s now responsible for the finest animation of Disney, thanks to a multi-billion deal a few years’ back. Here,
Toy Story
The film that proved you could make full feature-length animation with a computer, and a really strong start for Pixar. Excellent characters and an involving narrative make up for a slightly flat visual look in this now timeless classic.
A Bug's Life
More colourful than Toy Story and with some neat twists on a familiar narrative, but Dreamworks took the same concept and brought out Antz the same year. It’s the latter that’s the better movie.
Toy Story 2
Originally destined for direct to DVD, it actually turned out to be superior to the original in many ways. Again, brilliant performances from Tom Hanks and Tim Allen, and Kelsey Grammer as 'Stinky Pete'. Even better animation and rendering, too.
Monsters, Inc.
Exceptionally underrated movie, built around a simple but uber-cool premise. Billy Crystal and John Goodman nail 'Mike' and 'Sully' gloriously, with top-notch support from Steve Buscemi and the late James Coburn. Beautiful colours, clever sight gags and amazing character design takes this to Pixar’s top shelf.
Finding Nemo
I know some people love this film, but it leaves me cold. I've given it three stars for the technical and voice work. It's at its best in the fish tank, when it's been less predictable and preachy. It might seem heresy, but I enjoyed Bug’s Life more.
The Incredibles
In my mind there is no comparison between this movie and anything else Pixar has created. It's pretty much perfect in every respect. Great idea, awesomely executed with style and panache, with enough comic book and spy movie reference to keep a geek happy for days. I especially love the Barry-esque Bond incidental music. Pure animation gold.
Cars
Hated this with a passion, and for me it's the weakest Pixar production so far (so why, oh why does it get a sequel?). Putting eyes behind the windscreens of the cars just looked like lazy design work, and the story is overly simple for the 116 minute running time. It's bright and colourful but an ultimately soulless exercise.
Ratatouille
Back on form, with the second Brad Bird controlled movie, and the first made after Pixar became part of Disney. Actually to be fair it was partly made before Bird took control. It's technically superior to all other Pixar works in both animation and rendering, and demonstrates again some strong story telling abilities. The end result is delicious.
The Shorts…
The Adventures Of Andre and Wally B (1984) –
More of a render test than an actual film.
Luxo Jr (1986)
The iconic image of Pixar, the people who could bring an angle-poise lamp to life!
Red’s Dream (1987)
A charming short story, about the dreams of a monocycle.
Tin Toy (1988)
The origins of Toy Story, but not rendered as nicely as Red’s Dream.
Knick Knack (1989)
or
Two versions of this exist: the original 'funny' one with the pneumatic ashtray girl and the stupid adjusted one without her bust. Sadly, the original is not on the Pixar Shorts DVD. Grrr…
Geri’s Game (1997)
Superb! Simple idea but done wonderfully well. The character turns up in Toy Story 2 as the toy repair expert.
For The Birds (2000)
Simple sight gag, beautifully animated and designed.
Mike’s New Car (2002)
A humorous short created for inclusion on the Monsters Inc DVD, with Mike and Sully.
Boundin (2003)
Animated musical brilliance!
Jack-Jack Attack(2005)
A short made using some footage unused from The Incredibles. That doesn't sound enticing but it's very funny indeed.
One Man Band (2005)
Pixar showing off, as only it can!
Lifted (2006)
A totally alternative take on alien abduction…weird.
Mater and the Ghostlight (2006)
Short for the Cars DVD, not sure why they bothered.
Agree? Disagree? Then use the comments field below!
02/05/08
Posted by SebPatrick on May 3, 2008
Ratatouille surprised me. I was expecting it to be good, but not THAT good. It doesn't quite reach the heights of the Toys for me, but it's not far off. The animation is incredible, and Remy is officially the cutest character that has ever been created.
Posted by creativewriter1985 on May 2, 2008
I've seen all of the films except A Bug's Life, but have to agree that The Incredibles is a far superior film to the others, but that's not to say I didn't like them! Ratatouille comes a close second!
Loved Boundin' too - and One Man Band was hilarious, the little girl is a classic!!
Posted by DuncanMonkey on May 2, 2008
Tis a strange world, I really wanted to love The Incredibles more than any other Pixar movie up to that point, but still prefer the Toy Story movies, Monsters and Nemo... Cars and Rat were ok, but not super.
Posted by picknmix on May 2, 2008
Cheers...you can all blame me now...
Posted by twosheds on May 2, 2008
Sorry - I didn't post this particular one, and I don't know how Simon got credited for it, but I've changed it now. - Martin
Posted by picknmix on May 2, 2008
Sadly Simon didn't write this...I did...
But hey, who's counting?
Posted by Ian_Osborne on May 2, 2008
Well done, Simon. I thought I was the only person on the planet to prefer A Bug's Life to Finding Nemo, which I felt was obviously preachy and clearly-for-the-kids in a way even Monsters, Inc managed to avoid. Definite full marks for The Incredibles too.
Posted by cjlines on May 2, 2008
You don't know what you're talking about, as ever, Brew.
Cars is delightful.
Posted by SebPatrick on May 2, 2008
Definitely agree with The Incredibles (one of the greatest films ever made full stop, animated or no), but I'd have given five stars to at least one (the second), probably both, of the Toy Stories, as well...