Amazon.co.uk Widgets
Den of Geek

Gyllenhaal as Catwoman after all?

Martin Anderson


It's fantastically elegant, since so many have said how insipid the Rachel Dawes character was...

We were kind of joking when we cast Maggie Gyllenhaal as Catwoman two weeks back. But Hollywood may be stranger than fiction...

Published on Aug 2, 2008

BE WARNED: DARK KNIGHT SPOILERS

Well over two weeks ago Den Of Geek published 15 Contenders to play Catwoman after the Dark Knight, where various of our writers pontificated on their favourite choices for actresses to portray Batman's kinkiest love interest in Batman 3.

This was before anyone outside of Warner Bros editing rooms had seen The Dark Knight, and before we were to find out that Maggie Gyllenhaal's Rachel Dawes character was to be killed off - apparently - in The Joker's explosive Saw-style hard choice scenario. Therefore Dog's Duncan Bowles put MG forward for the role...

"Maggie Gyllenhaal would make a great Catwoman in some ways, possessing an unusual beauty and a way of expressing such varied emotions that there always appears to be hidden depths to her characters..."

Suddenly I wake up to find a ferment of net-rumours about Gyllenhaal getting slinky for the next Bat-outing (see links below); and it makes perfect sense...

One of the things I noted in my own review, and which has been noted elsewhere, was how wasted she was in TDK, and some speculated that she may have been getting on the 'one for  the money, two for the show' rhythm which has stood co-stars Michael Caine and Gary Oldman in good stead throughout their careers.

But how much more sense it makes that her almost-cameo role in Dark Knight turns out to be the dues payable on a much juicier role as Catwoman in the third episode of Nolan's ultra-successful franchise reboot.

It's fantastically elegant, since so many have said how insipid the Rachel Dawes character was - and that's always how Catwoman starts out before the revenge-motif and the mad larceny kicks in.

It also explains in a wonderfully hermetic manner just why Batman is so enthralled with Catwoman. Previous incarnations of that relationship have explained his attraction as being one of empathy for the fact that dark events in Selina Kyle's life turned her to evil, much as hard knocks turned Bruce Wayne into an avenging crusader; but not so far to evil that Batman isn't tantalised by the possibility of redeeming her.

But how much stronger the dynamic when Catwoman is actually a twisted version of the woman Wayne has loved since he was a child, and for whose transformation to the dark side he blames himself?

The death of Dawes? Pah. Total obliteration in a petrol-fuelled fireball is a classic scenario for a sequel return, and it leaves the re-emerged character with 8 lives to use up and the feeling that she can survive anything (and her survival of that impossible fireball situation is clearly the inspiration for the cat-identity).

The name? The character will have utter contempt for her former existence, resurfacing in public life as 'Selina Kyle' and inveigling her way into the halls of industry with the ambit of robbing them blind. It's a fair bet that Dawes' rabid idealism will transform into total cynicism, and her old girly notions of love into hatred for the former 'love of her life' (Wayne/Batman) who failed to help her (though she may be unaware that he was tricked by The Joker in this respect, or may not believe it).

Sure, Dawes/Kyle will know who Batman is, but she won't spill the beans: she wants to kill him herself, not see him arrested and treated fairly.

Holy shit, Batman - it even fits in with the kinkiness Maggie Gyllenhaal is most famous for to date, as James Spader's S&M assistant in Secretary (2002).

It's all just rumours of course - but it's too good not to be true...

Hollywood Newsroom
io9

Read Den of Geek's reviews of The Dark Knight: 1, 2, 3.


15 Contenders To Play Catwoman After The Dark Knight
10 things it takes to be Batman
Interview with Adam West
Would you visit the Batman Dental Surgery?
10 Things To Keep You Busy Until The Dark Knight Comes Out
Batman puts the boot in on Dark Knight trailer
A good look at the bat-bike from The Dark Knight
The Dark Knight: the best poster yet?
DVD Dungeon: Schumacher's Batman films
The Dark Knight: 12 roles Michael Keaton could have played
Batman vs The Dark Knight - why so similar?
New Dark Knight poster distinctly post-9/11

 

 

Users Comments

Re: Gyllenhaal as Catwoman after all?
Posted By Overfiend 1 August 3, 2008 02:38:49 PM

Meh. She just doesn't exude sex the way Michelle Pfeifer does :/

Re: Gyllenhaal as Catwoman after all?
Posted By twosheds 1 August 3, 2008 02:49:02 PM

Meh. She just doesn't exude sex the way Michelle Pfeifer does :/ Check out Secretary . It's just not that vaudeville-style sex appeal that worked in Batman Returns but would totally blow the realism of the Nolan Batman universe.

Re: Gyllenhaal as Catwoman after all?
Posted By Davros 1 August 3, 2008 03:51:12 PM

Noooooooooo I really hope this report is wrong, she has no sex appeal what so ever. 1. Catwoman should not know Batmans identity (well not till way down the line) 2. Catwoman is Selina Kyle 3. Michelle Pfeifer isn't really to old is she? Oh well maybe so but no no no to MG

Re: Gyllenhaal as Catwoman after all?
Posted By PeaJay18 1 August 3, 2008 04:06:21 PM

Whilst I think Gyllenhaal would indeed make a great Catwoman, I have some reservations about it being Rachel Dawes. Having her survive the explosion would undercut Harvey Dent's character arc to an almost "Hicks-and-Newt-die-right-at-the-beginning-of-Alien3" level. So I'm glad Maggie got to replace Katie Holmes, and if she hadn't already appeared in the DK universe she'd be a good Selina, but Dawes belongs dead.

Re: Gyllenhaal as Catwoman after all?
Posted By Overfiend 1 August 3, 2008 04:59:50 PM

For me, it doesn't really matter who they find to play Catwoman because that role was done to perfection by Pfeifer, and it's one of the reasons Batman Returns remains the best in the series to this day, in my opinion.

Re: Gyllenhaal as Catwoman after all?
Posted By Dartfin 1 August 4, 2008 05:25:59 AM

First of all the role of Dawes was HARDLY insipid. She was the one who turned Bruce from a life of revenge against Falcone to the present one he leads and also for turning Dent from the hero to the villain. I fail to see how she wasnt used to her full potential? She was there enough to show the love that Dent had for her. I suppose there's just no satisfying some people. On subject: I think it'd be a terrible idea for Dawes to become Catwoman AND adopt the Selina identity. No one recognizing this new Selina Kyle woman looks damned near identical to the former assistant to the DA is almost as bad as Scott Summers not recognizing Madelyn Pryor as a clone of Jean Grey.

Re: Gyllenhaal as Catwoman after all?
Posted By SarahDobbs 1 August 4, 2008 09:34:30 AM

This ... really doesn't sound plausible.

Re: Gyllenhaal as Catwoman after all?
Posted By twosheds 1 August 4, 2008 10:23:32 AM

the role of Dawes was HARDLY insipid The Dawes character has one non-insipid scene in both movies - where she takes Bruce Wayne for a drive to show him the dark side of Gotham in Batman Begins , Otherwise she has proved a boiler-plate save-me save-me 'girlfriend'.

Re: Gyllenhaal as Catwoman after all?
Posted By michaelklouda 1 August 4, 2008 06:31:15 PM

Yuuch. She was the worst part of The Dark Knight. Bad casting. She is a fine actress, but not for this part.

TWO-FACE KILLED IN DARK KNIGHT?
Posted By tim0076 1 August 5, 2008 01:59:36 PM

i'VE SEEN THE DARK KNIGHT TWICE AND STILL DONT KNOW WHAT MY NOLAN INTENDED TO DO WITH AARON ECKHARTS' HARVEY DENT. HE PLAYED HIM WELL, BUT AFTER BATS SAVES THE COMMISSIONERS SON FROM TWO-FACES EVIL CLUTCHES YOU SEE HARVEY LYING ON THE FLOOR OF THE BUILDING THE JOKER INTENDED TO KILL HIM AND RACHEL IN. THE QUESTION I ASK IS, "HAS CHRISTOPHER NOLAN KILLED OFF TWO-FACE ALL READY?" THIS SHOULDN'T HAPPEN AS TWO-FACE PLAYS AN INTEGRAL PART IN DICK GRAYSON'S/ROBIN'S LIFE AS SEEN IN BATMAN:FOREVER AND IN THE COMIC BOOKS. WILL NOLAN BRING ROBIN IN TO HIS THIRD INSTALMENT OF THIS NEW AND BETTER VERSION OF THE BATMAN FRANCHISE. AND IF SO, WHO WILL PLAY HIM?

Re: Gyllenhaal as Catwoman after all?
Posted By LizLemon 1 August 7, 2008 08:05:03 AM

I'm now kind of hoping this is true because I'm getting very tired of totally disposable female characters being trashedwhen their tiny parts have served their purpose. Maybe it was too soon after Penny's demise but expendable women seem to be getting killed off for loving the wrong man a bit too often. A harsh penalty for something we've all done at some point, I'm sure. :/
Post a Comment
 
Doh! Now I see it... Doh! Now I see it...

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!