The Screen Robots Ready Reckoner

Martin Anderson


Metal acres of roboty goodness in our mammoth Reckoner of the best (and worst) mechanoids to grace the silver and small screens

Middle-Eastern inventor Al-Jazari is credited with the first ever programmable robot in 1206 AD; it took LEGO approximately 801 years to catch up, and it looks like it will take Sony as long again to give their otherwise impressive ‘Asimov’ robots the ability to run down the stairs and catch milkie before he leaves that fecking clotted cream again (Sony say that this must ultimately be accomplished without killing any milkmen, which is creditable).

The tripping, flat-on-yer-face Sonybots were named after science-fiction writer and legend Isaac Asimov, whose laws of robotics crept out into fiction and movies beyond his own. The laws are:

- A robot may not injure a human being, or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.

- A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.

- A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.


Hollywood robots often run under additional directives:

- When faced with an irreconcilable dilemma, a robot must blow up instead of taking any advice on the matter.

- Even the most sophisticated and highly articulated robot will, if severely damaged, reveal itself to be an almost empty tin can with a few wires and sparklers inside.

- A robot must retain totally human appearance if the producer has shoved most of the special effects budget up his or her nose.


- [CLASSIFIED]


Robots have to be natively articulated to get into this list, hence HAL 9000 is absent, along with the Proteus from Demonseed and the bombs in Dark Star. We’ll also be passing over robots in the ‘android’ category, i.e. robots designed to look totally human who never significantly ‘unmask’, such as the well-endowed Katherine-Ross-bot from The Stepford Wives, Lt. Data, Rem from the TV Logan’s Run series and the robots from the Alien films and from A.I. – Artificial Intelligence. But that still leaves us loads of roboty goodness…


Gort – The Day The Earth Stood Still (1951) 3 out of 5
GortRobert Wise’s seminal and luminously pacifist film introduces us to the robot-behemoth which was to influence the covers of pulp sci-fi novels for the next twenty years. Cowboy and jobbing actor Lock Martin – seven foot seven in height – passed exhausting vigils in the bendy Gort suit. The robot was intended to be totally motionless unless undertaking an order, so a pristine mannequin could often stand in. Martin, not an overly strong man, was weakened by the stress of long shooting days in the suit and Patricia Neal had to be suspended on wires (still clearly visible in the film) for the scene where Gort carries her towards the ship. For a successive shot, Neal was herself a plastic dummy!

One of the most frightening and powerful cybernetic screen creations ever, its visor-shielded death-ray was the undoubted inspiration for Cyclops in the X-Men

Robby The Robot – Forbidden Planet et al (1956- ) 5 out of 5
Robby The RobotThere are flesh and blood actors who would kill for Robby’s credit list. A cross between the Michelin man and a particularly fetching Swiss time-piece, this masterpiece of fifties styling seemed built to last when it made its debut as Morbius’s amanuensis in Forbidden Planet, but a string of lesser films and TV appearances took its toll, and Robby was ultimately recreated by the Barton brothers in 1975 and launched back into a life of popular convention and TV appearances (even guesting in Columbo).

They don’t make them like this anymore. Voiced by announcer Marvin Miller, played (in FP) by the diminutive Frankie Darro and designed by Robert Kinoshita, Robby succeeded in manifesting both the requisite industrial heft and anthropomorphic appeal of a credible robot made to sturdy 1950s standards. Plus he could synthesise 60 gallons of whiskey just by sampling a nip.

Robot Monster (1953) 1 out of 5
The horror.Sometimes quantum leaps come from the cheap seats, and it took small-time director Phil Tucker to solve the age-old problem of how to make a robot look like a gorilla wearing a diving-suit helmet. But solve it he did. If there is any one image that encapsulates the cross-genre madness of splicing horror and sci-fi, it must be the gorilla/robot/alien from Phil Tucker’s 1953 treasure Robot Monster. Basically a man in a moth-addled gorilla suit and a diving helmet with a TV ariel welded onto it, Tucker spared all expense in bringing the demons of his imagination to life. And the horror doesn’t truly begin until the Robot Monster goes into his cave and turns on his deadly bubble-making machine…

The Terminator (1984/90 | 2003) 4 out of 5
He's back!We’re not allowing any cyborgs that started out human into this Reckoner, such as Murphy or Robocop 2, but the fleshy component of the Terminators is manufactured from scratch. Icy and amoral killing machines, the ‘bad’ Terminators in the films so far comprise some of the most exciting robot prosthetics and armatures ever seen on screen, with the exception of the now-dated Robert Patrick quicksilver-bot. Stan Winston’s studio created an extraordinary contribution to big screen robots, the full potential of which was finally tapped in the extra-ordinary ILM ‘blend’ effects in the under-rated T3. But would a machine so advanced really need such an elaborate logic-process to work out that he should tell his moaning landlord to fuck off?

ABC Warrior - Judge Dredd (1995) 4 out of 5
Love it or hate it (I seem to be alone in the former category), Danny Cannon’s screen adaptation of Dredd features one of the coolest ‘industrial’-style bots ever, in the form of the ABC Warrior. A decommissioned soldier robot, ABC has a pointlessly large chin, glowing red eyes, stands over nine feet tall and is ludicrously easy to reprogram, as villain Armand Assante is pleased to find out when he is on the lookout for a new bodyguard. Grungey, piston-bursting, steam-driven tech you can believe in.

ED-209 – Robocop (1987)
5 out of 5
ED209This is the only mechanoid in the Robocop films that we can allow, since it’s all robot. Envisaged as a cross between a Huey helicopter from ‘Nam and an overdesigned, high-concept luxury American car, ED’s design concept is lusciously, lickably authentic, from its clumsy external hydraulics to its lumbering and dinosaur-like gait.

In repose the droid is a full-scale prop, but is brought to life in action sequences using the Go-motion technique that Phil Tippett perfected for the finale of the otherwise disappointing Howard The Duck. Go-motion is explained simply as ‘jogging’ the model to provide a little blur on each animated frame, avoiding the stroboscopic jerkiness associated with stop-motion. Ed’s fierce roar is a tiger’s played backwards, while his utterly commanding voice is that of Robocop producer Paul Davison, a ‘temp’ vocal stand-in that was ultimately never replaced.

This is technology without warranty: if it goes wrong, the owner won’t be around to complain anyway.

Hector - Saturn 3 (1980)
3 out of 5 stars
HectorOh, and if you like external hydraulics, you’re gonna love Hector. Psychopathic Harvey Keitel arrives on the Tethys research station around Saturn to wake up idle wrinkly Kirk Douglas and his lover, the too-young-for-Kirk-Douglas Farrah Fawcett. Trouble is the drug-addled, black-clad looney wants Farrah for himself, and his desires infiltrate his programming of the ten-foot robot that he has brought with him to help get the research back on track. Before you know it Keitel has bitten the dust and the robot is chasing Fawcett round the lonely outpost, presumably with no clear notion of what it will do if it catches her (it doesn’t seem to be fully equipped for the contingency).

Hector himself is a walking exoskeleton with an angle poise lamp for a head and an externalised vein-structure containing blood-like fluid which is presumably some kind of oil. His brain is made out of genetically engineered human brain tissue in a cylindrical container in his chest. British effects maestro Colin Chilvers based the ‘flayed’ design of the robot on a Da Vinci painting, and presumably on the church-banned Italian anatomical studies of corpses that informed it.

AMEE3 – Red Planet (2000) 3 out of 5 stars
Amee3 - Red PlanetWriters often stretch robot acronyms beyond endurance (see entry for the Black Hole robots below) in the effort to enhance the anthropomorphic aspect, and ‘Autonomous Mapping Exploration and Evasion’ is a bit of a thin excuse to humanise the haywire military robot in Red Planet. Nonetheless it’s a lethal-looking beast that fares better under the CGI treatment than organic enemies. Bipedal or quadrupedal depending on terrain and circumstances, AMEE3 is military technology gone wrong on the surface of Mars, hunting down the stranded astronauts ‘she’ has mistakenly identified as enemies

Type 3 – Screamers (1995) 3 out of 5 stars
Unfriendly, I think.Second Variety, Philip K. Dick’s short story about soldiers fighting the insidious, mindless and apparently evolving robot-‘mines’ that they originally laid for their enemies was turned into an under-regarded Dan O’Bannon-scripted film that has some shocking twists and visuals. The most alarming of these is when the ‘type 2’ Screamer unmasks; masquerading as an orphaned boy, the type 3 plays on the sympathies of roaming soldiers in order to be shepherded safely into enemy camps, where it will unleashes its lethal spinning saws. Though ‘android’, human-looking robots are banned here, the one-shot transformation of the adorable boy’s face into a malevolent and nightmarish rictus of sharp knives qualifies as a notable ‘unmasking’.

Special mention should also go to the ‘Type 1’ stop-motion screamer that precedes this scene, a rotary-saw with legs, and possibly the last example of good stop-motion work in sci-fi after the advent of Jurassic Park.

‘Maria’ Gynoid - Metropolis (1927)
5 out of 5
Maria in MetropolisFritz Lang’s extraordinary masterpiece defined a great deal of the visual landscape of science-fiction film in the eighty years since it was made, and the design of the ‘raw’ robot gynoid, a mimetic android that can transform into the appearance of any human, not only pre-figured T2 and C-3PO, but remains an influential template for cybernetic elegance. An extraordinary achievement whether you consider the limited technology of the time or not.

C3P0 & R2-D2 - Star Wars films (1977-2005) 3 out of 5 stars
The DroidsThey’ve been separated enough over six films (often from their own body parts), so who are we to split them up in this Reckoner? George Lucas created the prissy protocol droid and his intrepid but dumpy beep-speaking partner as the ‘chorus’ in the Star Wars space opera, as well as positing the golden C-3PO as the ‘fool’ of the piece. This instantly-loved comedy duo comprise the only consistent characters in the saga, played in both trilogies by Anthony Daniels and Kenny Baker (though ‘prop’ R2s probably represent the majority of the diminutive robot’s appearances).

If Darth Vader is Threepio’s father/creator, Maria The Gynoid (see above) is certainly his mum, whereas tripedal Artoo is of such original design that imitations (like V.I.N.C.E.N.T. in The Black Hole, see below) are hard to pull off.

Huey, Dewey and Louie - Silent Running (1972) 4 out of 5
Drones in Silent RunningRobot designs often require operators of non-standard size. R2-D2’s Kenny Baker is a little person, whereas Lock Martin (Gort, see above) was a giant. The bipedal and very squat service drones in Douglas Trumbull’s ecologically-sound Silent Running were played by amputees Mark Persons, Steve Brown, Cheryl Sparks, and Larry Whisenhunt. The difference in their injuries explains the varying design of the drones. The vacuum-formed shells and dressing weighed twenty pounds each, and convey an authentically mass-manufactured aesthetic. The sussurant language of the drones among themselves is a clear predecessor to the chirpy beeps of R2-D2, and they have been acknowledged as a template for the character.

Optimus Prime – Transformers (2007)
2 out of 5
Optimus PrimeMr. Prime will have to stand in for many of his friends and enemies here, so numerous (and often indistinguishable) are the robots in the Transformers universe. As you can probably tell from the points awarded, I am not a Transformers fan, though if you are taking the authenticity of the special effects in the 2007 film into account, you can add two stars.

My problem with the transmuting robots is that it was a cool idea for a (young) child’s toy to which no plot should ever have been attached. No amount of creativity can justify the absurdity of the premise itself: why would a robot that powerful need to disguise itself as a truck? Volume compression is another problem with the Transformers – there’s no way a 40-ton robot can compress itself into a one-ton car. Add to that the rather ugly design of the robots’ faces – it may be more appealing in Japanese culture - and I can only resign myself as having been too old when the Transformers were a hit in the 80s to really appreciate them now.

Demolition Robot - I Robot (2004)
5 out of 5
Demolition BOtAndy Chung’s ‘demolition bot’ stands out in the patchy but frequently dazzling Will Smith vehicle as an example of a robot so close to ‘available technology’ that it is hard to believe you can’t order one. The grizzled chevrons and flaky paintwork hint at the heritage of ultra-realistic futurists such as Ron Cobb and Syd Mead. This thing has destroyed a lot of houses; it’s probably not the latest model and is approaching the end of its serviceable life. As with Ed 209, over-sized industrial robots are often the most convincing, bespeaking a state-of-the-art that still needs room to manoeuvre in terms of design…

Sonny - I Robot (2004) 2 out of 5
…for which reason tightly packed, ergonomic droids like Sonny are a harder sell. The conceptual artists behind I, Robot’s cybernetic protagonist are obviously well aware that it will be a CGI creation operating in protracted close-up among real actors, and have used ethereal-looking smoked Perspex to avoid expensive reflection issues and bridge the reality gap. The truth is that Sonny needed a grittier and more practical look, and successfully rendering something which wouldn’t have looked ‘real’ even if it had actually been there is a pointless evasion.

Johnny 5 - Short Circuit | 2 (1986/88)
4 out of 5
Johnny 5Joy. Johnny 5 only loses a star because his personality can grate on you after he gets kid-friendly, but in terms of design, he is exquisite: he is basically a bomb-disarming robot with recognisable but sketchy anthropomorphic qualities, and something of the ‘revealed’ exterior styling of Hector from Saturn 3. With war robots deployed in Iraq, military mechanoids are a current buzz, and J5 certainly looks the part.

Bender - Futurama (US TV, 1999 - ) 3 out of 5 stars
Bender - FuturamaWho can’t love a cigar-smoking, hard-drinking, porn-loving, farting kleptomaniac robot with an acid-tongue? Originally built to bend girders for suicide booths, Bender has clearly never heard of Isaac Asimov or any of that three-laws rubbish. Matt Groening plays on the ‘reliable robot’ stereotype to paint Bender as the most human –and certainly the most fallible – of any of the future-dwelling dweebs in Futurama.

Marvin, The Paranoid Android – Hitch-Hikers Guide To The Galaxy, (1978 – 2006) 3 out of 5 stars
I'm so very depressed...A clinically depressed robot with a brain the size of a planet and a scathing riposte for the masters he holds in open contempt, Marvin was arguably the prototype for Bender (see above) and an instant cult hit when Hitch Hikers hit the big time on Radio 4 in the late seventies. Though very effectively voiced by Alan Rickman in the long-awaited 2005 movie adaptation, the role will forever be associated with the monotone provided by Stephen Moore. The 1981 TV adaptation featured one of the worst robot designs ever, but Marvin was more agreeably rendered as a giga-cranial kitchen-appliance in the recent movie (in which the aforementioned TV ‘Marvin’ makes a thankfully brief appearance).

Twiki - Buck Rogers In The 25th Century (US TV, 1979-81)
1 out of 5
Bidi bidi bidiTwiki was a disco-dancing Artoo clone foisted on Gil Gerard in the Buck Rogers movie (Europe only) and US TV series. Tempted to completely ape the incomprehensibility of R2-D2 with an annoying ‘Bidi-bidi-bidi’ refrain, it seems that Glen A. Larson ultimately decided that this would prove problematic in advancing storylines, and had him speak English too, in the gruff tones of long-time Looney Toons artist Mel Blanc, who blended Yosemite Sam and Porky Pig to achieve a streetwise, Noo Yoik cadence. Apparently inspired by Shogun warriors, the short-arse droid was played physically by Felix Silla.

Metal Mickey (UK TV, 1980-83)
1 out of 5
RubbishAnother fecking disco robot. Not even original enough to rip off Artoo directly, Mickey Dolenz’s annoying and faintly simian sit-com robot drew his inspiration from Buck Rogers’s Twiki (see above), substituting ‘Boogie boogie boogie’ for ‘Bidi bidi bidi’. Writer Colin Bostock-Smith’s long tenure with Terry And June was an ill-omen for this tale of a domestic robot cooked up by a swotty kid, and raised nary a titter nor a chortle. It ran for three years anyway.

K-9 – Doctor Who et al(1977 - ) 2 out of 5
K9Despite the temptation to have a robot dog leave little batteries everywhere, the plastic pooch was treated fairly seriously as one of Tom Baker’s assistants, though he often had to be diverted away from the main action as his laser-shooting nose threatened to become an easy escape for any plot-entanglements. Built as the replacement for a dog that a scientist was unable to bring with him to an asteroid research station, The Doctor asked if K9 might like to accompany him on his travels at the end of the tin pooch’s debut in The Invisible Enemy. K9 enjoyed a popular 3-year tenure in Who, going on to star in the failed pilot K9 And Company, and now resident in The Sarah Jane Adventures.

A 26-part live-action children’s show is currently being produced in Australia with a radically restyled CGI-based version of the character.

V.I.N.C.E.N.T. – The Black Hole (1979) 2 out of 5
VINCENTThe most blatant of the R2-D2 clones, V.I.N.C.E.N.T. stands for ‘Vital Information Necessary, CENTralized’. Or maybe they just wanted a cute acronym, you call it. With a swivelling, retractable head and an unconvincing Hammerite finish, this floating caricature with Bambi eyes was the biggest clue that Disney were behind The Black Hole. Worse yet, what the hell is a machine doing with telepathic powers?

The strings were hard to hide, and most of the successful suspension shots were achieved by armature support from behind or below. A previous and even-more-annoying model of this droid appears in the film, the beaten-up BOB, voiced in a cartoon manner by Slim Pickens. On the plus side V.I.N.C.E.N.T. himself is voiced by the reliable – but uncredited - Roddy McDowall.

K1 – Doctor Who, “Robot” (1977 - ) 3 out of 5 stars
K1The experimental K1 robot is arguably the most impressive mechanoid in pre-Ecclestone Who. Standing at over eight feet tall and with very cool art-deco styling finished in aluminium, the gigantic robot suit was impressively mobile, with extending pincers that elongated the arms and diminished the ‘man in a suit’ factor. K1 is a conflicted robot trying to be faithful to Asimov but being used, to his torment, to murder people and further the ambitions of his maker.

Gunslinger – Westworld (1973)
3 out of 5 stars
I said PICK IT UP!Though a ‘fully-disguised’ android, the murderous renegade cowboy from Michael Crichton’s 1973 techno-fear classic is facially damaged for long enough to qualify as an ‘exposed’ robot. Yul Brynner’s icy stare and shaven head sold the artifice of the character up until the point where it loses its facial covering. The moment where Richard Benjamin realises that he is in trouble (Brynner has just shot his friend dead in what was supposed to be a fake duel at a cyber-enhanced holiday resort) remains utterly chilling.

Vectrocon robot spiders – Runaway (1984) 2 out of 5
When Meccano goes wrong...For a film that is all about robots, Runaway has few of note. Tom Selleck’s nanny-bot is a ludicrously outdated-looking box on wheels, and most of the robots Selleck hunts down are simple agricultural drones with stripped gears. Blade Runner this ain’t. Nonetheless, the film is enjoyable, featuring a deliciously scenery-chewing turn from Gene Simmons of Kiss fame, as a villain murdering his enemies with bullets that can fly round corners and with metal spiders that inject acid into their victims.

The Vectrocon acid-spiders are most effective in the film’s finale, as they pursue a vertigo-plagued Selleck around a precariously balanced lift that is hanging 100 storeys over the city. Aesthetically they look pre-alpha: the Meccano-like construction and pull-toy movement mean you do have to get out and push in order to suspend disbelief.

Cylons – Battlestar Galactica (US TV 1978 | 2004)
1978
2 out of 52004 3 out of 5 stars
CylonsThere is something ‘flared’ about the trim on the original 1978 Cylons that makes them look as dated as the titles in The Goodies or bell-bottom jeans (before they were ironic or ‘retro’). The remodelled Cylon warriors in the Galactica reboot wisely follow the art-deco route used for the K1 robot (see above) and the fascist-style robot-giants in Sky Captain And The World Of Tomorrow (2004).

Box - Logan’s Run (1976) 1 out of 5
Box in Logan's Run“Overwhelming, am I not?” boasted Roscoe Lee Browne under a paltry veneer of aluminium foil in the ‘ice-caves’ sequence of Logan’s Run. Well, really…no. This particular droid is aptly-named at least, since it is basically just a shiny box trundling around with a remote controlled air and a fine actor sticking out the top of it, safe in the knowledge that no-one will recognise him anyway. But you have to remember that back in 1976, aluminium trim and shiny tin-foil looked like the future, since the shop-worn production design of Star Wars was a year away.

If anyone out there has any pictures of Box’s infamous ice-sculpture of Jessica and Logan (excised from the final film as a bit racy), do please get in touch. It’s strictly for research purposes.

The Iron Giant (1999) 3 out of 5 stars
The Iron GiantAnother great art-deco cyber-giant, though a rather more benevolent one, in this under-rated animated feature from 1999. What is it about Art Deco that makes it such a good choice for robots? The influence of Metropolis’s ‘Maria’ Gynoid (see waaay above) is still apparent and still irresistible.

Model B-9 Environmental Control Robot - Lost In Space (1965/68 | 1998)3 out of 5 stars
Robot in Lost In SpaceRobby The Robot creator Robert Kinoshita was asked to design the Robinson’s house-robot for the 1960s series, but the discordant result suggests that he had some trouble understanding the new sixties aesthetic. While bulky and Robby-esque, ‘robot’ is a clunky creature, who makes a slightly re-designed re-appearance in the 1998 movie after the far more beautiful Deco robot is trashed in an accident and clumsily re-assembled by Will Robinson.

Cybernauts – The New Avengers (UK TV, 1976)
3 out of 5 stars
CybernautClad in hats and long coats that Philip Marlow himself would have thought were too noir, the plastic-faced, karate-chopping Cybernauts threaded in and out of the Avengers shows, but the 1977 episode "The Last of the Cybernauts?" found them at their most ferocious. Expressionless, with murderous single-stroke slayings, these are highly efficient killing machines, and the sound of them doing their worst is very scary indeed. Far as robot design goes, they are, admittedly, pants.

Click here to check out ALL the lists at Den Of Geek...

 

User's Comments

Re: The Screen Robots Ready Reckoner
Posted by cjlines on January 11, 2008 10:41:39 AM

Hahah! Awesome idea for a ready reckoner. :) Great stuff.

The only one I'd've liked to have seen there that isn't is the wee robot from 'Cinderella 2000' - his musical lament about robot sex (the charmingly named "Where Do I Plug It In?") is a classic cinema moment. Sadly, the movie seems nigh on impossible to find these days and even YouTube doesn't have a clip of the song. :(

Re: The Screen Robots Ready Reckoner
Posted by kestrel1977 on January 11, 2008 12:17:41 PM

Good lord this is thorough! But what about the robots from 'Heartbeeps'... now there's an obscure film..

Re: The Screen Robots Ready Reckoner
Posted by Robmac on January 11, 2008 01:50:57 PM

Thems some good robots. I thought I was the only person on earth to have seen Runaway which is the only film I know of that has Gene Simmons from Kiss as a bad guy who can control shoe box looking robots. It makes you wander why they dont make films like that any more. There is one you might have forgotton though check out Rocky3 for one of the best 1980s robots ever!

Re: The Screen Robots Ready Reckoner
Posted by garlicsmack on January 11, 2008 01:57:00 PM

Man alive, that's thorough. Personally, I found the Cybernauts one of the most terrifying TV villains of my childhood, second only (in sci-fi terms) to that episode of the Time Tunnel where some aliens take over an American town. Jeepers.

Re: The Screen Robots Ready Reckoner
Posted by simonbrew on January 11, 2008 09:32:56 PM

Rob: Rocky 4, surely?

Re: The Screen Robots Ready Reckoner
Posted by Robmac on January 12, 2008 12:25:09 PM

oh yeah, Rocky 4... still its a great Robot. Back when Rocky 4 came out when I was at Primary school there was a TV spot for Rocky 4 and I am sure that Robot was in it. It also had a bit where Dolph and Stallone smashed gloves into each other and there was an explosion which of course being 7 and 8 led a lot of playground rumours that Ivan Drago was a robot a la Terminator.

Re: The Screen Robots Ready Reckoner
Posted by DuncanMonkey on January 14, 2008 04:54:13 PM

I love robots and this article. Now that was an extensive Ready Reckoner!

However, you lose big points for cussing Optimus Prime, regardless of the updated design, as he is like a god to me. Luckily you didn't lay into Bob from the Black Hole or me and you would've come to blows.

Hmm my brain also seems to have stuck on the scene from Runaway where Ms Alley gets scanned for bugs...

Re: The Screen Robots Ready Reckoner
Posted by twosheds on January 14, 2008 09:44:21 PM

Duncan: Whoops, I mixed up BOB with STARR. Corrected now [assumes the position]...
Post a comment
 
Johnny 5 and Marvin The Paranoid Android
Any day now...
Related Articles

Search

Den of Geek. Shortlisted for the Launch of the Year 2008 by the British Society of Magazine Editors