Den of Geek

10 ways DVD content creators pwn you

Martin Anderson


Have it ... their way. Here are some of the most pernicious bugbears built into your film collection...

Published on Jun 9, 2008

Gone are the semi-good old days when you could wind through the arse-aches that issue from the marketing and legal departments of film companies when they finally permit you to watch major motion pictures in the comfort of your own home. All these apply (often with added bells and whistles) to Blu-ray...

10: Region control
The public explanation for region coding on DVDs was that since movies have different release dates worldwide, their availability on DVD needs to be staggered and disabled in zones where that movie has not yet come out. In this age of multi-region DVD players and the increasing frequency of simultaneous release dates worldwide (to obviate the rapid distribution of pirated copies, particularly in region 5 - China), the remaining justification is revealed as the primary one: enforcing the price differentials in the wildly varying economies of different countries. Why should the denizens of rip-off Britain pay £3.50 for a legal DVD when they can potentially be gouged for three or four times that?

(Interestingly, there are two sub-branches of the region 2 code that have relevance for the United Kingdom - 'D1' is UK-only whilst D2/3 exclude the sceptred isle).

9: Criminalisation of end-users
Reversing the common principles of western justice, DVD-watchers are presumed guilty until...ah what the hell, who cares if they're not guilty? All must sit through the same demonising featurette depicting anyone who runs a DVD through a cloning process as cloven-hoofed paedophile terrorists. This is psychological blanket-bombing, where the superlative imagery is almost - but not quite - absurd enough to make the piece humorous in nature. The unskippable nature of these one-minute-insults issues from the delightful technology of User Prohibited Operations (or UPOs), and there are many other examples of it in this list. A UPO simply sets a flag on the feature/video-section that tells the DVD player to not allow the end-user to skip (and in some cases even to fast forward or gain access to a previously-viewed root menu).

8: Auto play
This is particularly aggravating for the arguable majority of users who leave their screens off whilst the film companies bombard them with unskippable accusation, ads and legal admonitions. Once all this tosh is done with, dawdling too long at the 'play' menu will start your film off on its way. Why? Why take the choice of when the movie will begin away from the end user? The answer, as usual, seems to be 'because its possible'. As Richard Attenborough said in Jurassic Park, it's 'kind of a ride'.

7: THX and other unskippable pre-film Corporate Wanks
Why would a company imagine that pissing off its end-users is good for product awareness? On the rare occasions I ever chance to consider George Lucas's THX surround-sound system, the associations I come up with are discomfort and coercion, as I have to trawl my way through his latest - often excessively long - render-fest lauding THX to get to the movie itself. This would at least be justifiable if I could go down the road and buy a packet of THX to snort at home. The truth is, this technology has no point-of-sale for the likes of me except in a cinema or on a DVD - where I have already paid money for the fecking thing.

6: Blocking 'on the fly' access to subtitles and alternative soundtracks
If anything demonstrates that DVD content creators delight in using utterly superfluous features in the DVD control-set, it must be when they stop you using the 'audio' or 'subtitles' button to gain access to a commentary, or to check out an inaudible word that you would like to see spelt out on screen in order to better understand what is going on. Worse yet is when you are forced to return to an overblown, tea-inspiring menu-wank to select a new soundtrack or title...only to press 'resume' and be taken back to the start of the film instead of the point you left it at!

There are variations of subtitle control-freakery; I have an Italian copy of Dune where turning on the English soundtrack also turns on a forced Italian subtitle - no doubt employed to discourage grey imports into the US and UK from the rights-negotiators in Italy, and this is relatively common practice among lower-price or giveaway discs in that country.

5: Ads for other DVDs and for non-film products
One of the most offensive aspects of having unskippable movie trailers burned into a retail copy of a DVD destined for a home collection is how awful some of the movies are - why should American Pie 12 be in any way enshrined in my DVD collection, particularly in a form that is resistant to the 'skip' button it so richly deserves? Still, at least Pie 12 (or whatever) is arguably a movie, unlike the lifestyle products, soft drinks and other commercials that invade the movie pre-amble just as stubbornly in the sleaziest DVD releases.

4: Spreading 9GB of data over two discs
One two-hour movie, a grab-bag of 4-minute TV docu-slots and a (small) bucket of deservedly deleted scenes can comfortably fit on a single 9GB dual-layer disc, yet these bland and very cheesy extras morsels frequently migrate to occupy 25% of a second disc in an 'ultimate' edition.

3: 'Ultimate' collections that offer no – or inferior – content to previous editions
Drawing on the far superior reputation of the 'Laserdisc' extras of the 1990s (many of which have crossed over to DVD editions) and the obsessive, geeky detail of first-class releasers such as Criterion and Anchor Bay, these cynical editions seek to shake down some more shekels from completists who probably have already bought the most definitive version. For instance, the pointless 2001 'director's cut' of The Exorcist replaces William Friedkin's perfectly competent commentary with an appallingly pointless one wherein the director simply speaks out loud what is happening on screen. The other 'extras' are as risible as the re-cut is pointless and cynical - and there's a lot of that about.

2: Huge 'extras' lists that boil down to mere junket-morsels
A Chat With Dirk Caribou, star of 'Zombie Rodeo':
"Hey Dirk - how was it working with Zak Hardly, director of Zombie Rodeo?"
"Zak's a guy I'd work with anytime, anywhere. We bonded real well on set, and everyone was real great. It's been a real great experience and I think we've all pooled together to give 110% and produce a major motion picture that's going to really find its audience quickly - and which, to boot, has something to say to all of us."
© SuperKwik DVD Productions, 2008, all rights reserved.

Rinse and repeat 15-20 times until the list on the rear DVD jacket is bursting.

1: Button responses
An increasing plague, where user-input is required at some point in the locked-down preamble shambles other than right at the start. Many users will be familiar with the 'select language' button-choice common enough on multi-region discs in Europe, but other 'user choices' are beginning to crop up in the middle of all that crud that you are letting play itself out whilst you make the tea or do something else more interesting, like rubbing lard on the cat's boil. Will we have to answer questions on the chocolate commercials soon before we are allowed to see the movie?

More lists...

28 Sequels Later: more films you didn't know were coming
23 TV shows heading to the big screen
13 videogames being made into films
7 shots horror filmmakers should never be allowed to use again
30 Upcoming Movie Sequels You Didn't Know About
10 most depressing movie endings
22 added sequels and remakes that you didn't know were coming
If Terminator 4 can be PG-13, then why can't these?

Click here for a list of ALL the lists at Den Of Geek...

 

Users Comments

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By picknmix 1 June 9, 2008 09:43:36 AM

head, nail, hit, the, on - make your own sentence. The dumbest extra I've seen recently is a trailer for the movie on the disc in the unskippable trailers...'hey let's buy that!, Oh...we did...and we even put it in the DVD player!!!' - what dicks.

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By tenacious-dell 1 June 9, 2008 12:58:41 PM

i really hate it when websites have useless banner ads for loosely related products but all capitalist ventures have to make concessions if theyre to continue pushing product out. well done for just misunderstanding and insulting the dvd industry.

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By RonHogan 1 June 9, 2008 02:54:05 PM

Concessions? You mean like not subjecting me to trailers for other movies I chose not to buy in front of the movie I bought legally? Or pointless antipiracy warnings in front of the movie I bought legally? Or the fact that I can't fucking buy a copy of fucking Garth Marengi's Darkplace on fucking DVD because I live in fucking America, even though it's been on TV here repeatedly?

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By WeakLemonDrink 1 June 9, 2008 03:11:37 PM

Surely absolutely everyone who's ever used a DVD knows all of this already?

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By miladyblue 1 June 9, 2008 04:28:20 PM

Er, shouldn't that be 11 ways? You forgot the infamous "double dipping" wherein a hotly anticipated DVD is released, makes big money, and 6 months later, the "Director's Cut" or "Ultimate Edition" is released, making it seem like you would be a fool to miss it. You get the next edition, only to find the difference is two minutes or previously unreleased footage, a 10 minute documentary or something equally pointless is the ONLY addition. It's then that you realize you were a fool to part with your money, AGAIN, for what amounts to the same DVD.

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By twosheds 1 June 9, 2008 04:57:45 PM

miladyblue - Double dipping is certainly worth an entry. Another related entry that there wasn't room for was 'vanilla flooding' (I don't know the accepted term for this, so I invent), where the market is saturated with a very basic vanilla edition of a film that is about to be given the five star treatment in a new release. Only thing is that it can be a useful way of knowing that the new edition is coming out. In the case of Reservoir Dogs , the special edition that was signalled by the flooding of the 'vanilla' edition was really worth waiting for. WeakLemonDrink - the more you let shit situations become the 'status quo', the easier it is for them to add extra shit later - you ate that much, why not some more? Apathy costs. - Martin

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By twosheds 1 June 9, 2008 06:37:37 PM

tenacious-dell - you didn't pay a damn thing for this website. Give me a free DVD and I'll tone down my criticism of the ads on it.

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By WeakLemonDrink 1 June 9, 2008 07:10:22 PM

I'm not apathetic, but I'm dubious as to the amount of impact a small site can have telling its readers exactly what they already know just so there can be a round of back slaps.

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By simonbrew 1 June 9, 2008 07:28:29 PM

But from small acorns... :-)

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By twosheds 1 June 9, 2008 08:23:53 PM

WeakLemonDrink - you're a very cynical cat. If I want hits (or plaudits), there are plenty of 'guaranteed' subjects I can write about. But I give a damn on this particular one. When content-creators amuse themselves (literally) at my expense, it's not okay with me. If it's okay with you, put up with it, say nothing about it and don't give a damn. Nice and easy.

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By WeakLemonDrink 1 June 9, 2008 11:38:54 PM

Of course it's not ok with me. I've never said it was. All I was doing was questioning the validity of a list article that doesn't really say or do anything useful. This has gone on too long, anyway, and I'm all too aware I'm looking like a petulant trouble maker, so I'll shush.

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By twosheds 1 June 10, 2008 12:01:00 AM

WeakLemonDrink - it's a rant, not a news item. Know why I wrote it on Saturday night? Five minutes earlier I'd put in a DVD and was again being accused AGAIN of being a thief in one of those prelim movies. I'll stop complaining about it when the manufacturers acknowledge that my hard-earned cash should buy me a movie, and not an arena wherein they can advertise and preach at me. If they're going to do that, DVDs should be a HELL of a lot cheaper. As for usefulness, is it useful when you complain about a tax-hike to your mates in the pub or a bar? I'm just using what voice I have to address something I have always seen as a valid consumer issue. If that voice ain't CNN, shall I just shut up?

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By MinneytheKid 1 June 13, 2008 07:12:29 PM

I actually would steal a handbag. There I said it! (Plus the DVD he nicks from the rental shop would clearly have been empty; thieves are such tools.

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By girlord 1 September 3, 2008 07:19:15 PM

-On the latest Harry Potter DVD if you click Australia straight to main menu if you click UK 10 minutes of unskippale ads then the same menu -another DVD extra wehre 15 second interviews which told you nothing without a play all button - anime dvds that give subs for the japanese that doesnt match the english or vice versa JUST GIVE A SECOND OPTION -That bit at the end in 600000 languages

Re: 10 ways DVD content creators pwn you
Posted By moviefan101 1 December 16, 2011 02:57:18 PM

You can fast forward all ads including No 9 above
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image
 
 
piracy You wouldn't steal a handbag, but what's that got to do with the price of fish?
Untitled Document

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Coke Zero
Advertisement