Den of Geek

The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check

Simon Brew


It is a duty of entertainment media to deal with real life issues, however frightened that might make people who have 1000 words to write before their copy deadline hits.

The latest media furore about videogames has centred on Modern Warfare 2. But can we not just get a grip?

Published on Nov 10, 2009

In common with virtually all of those railing against Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 in the news at the moment, I haven't played the apparently offending section of the game that's causing such controversy. I haven't even seen the leaked, out of context YouTube footage that's doing the rounds, because I believe if you take anything of that ilk out of said context, then your thinking and reaction to it becomes instantly skewed. But unlike many of those critics, I'm actually going to level with you and admit this up front, rather than react to said clip, or to what a tabloid newspaper tells me to think about it, or what some rentaquote MP has to say.

So then. Isn't it about time some people got a grip?

This morning, I've awoken to a radio station telling me all about this game where you play a terrorist shooting down innocent civilians. It took me a matter of minutes to confirm that the truth of that statement is that you play an undercover agent who has infiltrated said terrorists, and is looking to bring them down. But that doesn't make for as good a headline, and it doesn't allow you to drag in a variety of talking heads to condemn this no-doubt "sick" game. Nor does it seem to bother some of those ranting on that the footage concerned, that most seem to be basing their views on, was leaked last week.

Here's a flavour of some of the other reaction over the last day or two:

"Outrage as new video game lets players kill civilians in terror attacks"

"Modern Warfare 2 accused of promoting terrorism"

"New game lets players massacre civilians"

Shall we all just play Tetris, then? Or can we accept that there is a market for grown-up videogames, that are labelled with an 18 certificate, that challenge us in terms of their storytelling, their visuals and their drive? Are we allowed that? Without coming up with hysterical and, at times, nonsensical headlines?

Seriously: you can open up a book and read such a story. You can sit through episodes of 24 and watch TV dramas that cover similar ground. You can do the same with movies. But when a videogame dares to do it? A videogame? The shutters are down in double quick time.

Because videogames aren't allowed, according to many in the mass media, to confront such issues, or introduce challenging storytelling of this ilk. That's not how the world should be. Videogames should have stayed back in the days when we used to guide a yellow blob around mazes to eat up tablets. After all, because videogames are more interactive than being sat on the sofa and watching reality TV for hours at a time, that's going to wave some sort of magic wand, break down our defences and convert us all overnight into terrorists.

That's what games do, don't they? Heck, if we were to believe every tabloid tale of the influence of videogames, we'd all be out every night beating innocent bystanders to shit.

But let's have a reality check. The vast majority of us who play games just want to play games. And surely it's right and proper that games do explore differing narratives, do touch on complex subjects, and do go into ground that may not be comfortable. Every other form of media does that, and rightly so. That shouldn't be a blank canvas to deliberately go out and make deliberately vile and unpleasant games, but that's never been what the actually really respectful Call Of Duty franchise has been about.

If there was any hint that the team working at Infinity Ward, whose World War II games I always thought got across far more the horrors of war than playing Commando in the 1980s, were glamourising terrorism through the game, I'd happily stand in line to condemn them myself. It's a deathly serious subject, and one that doesn't deserve trivialising. Yet, as another gaming witch hunt kicks into gear, once more we find ourselves in a world condemning something for trying to be realistic in its depiction of real events. After all, isn't it right in a game that when a bullet flies, it should have an impact, and that impact should be put across with definite visuals and - crucially - realistic sound? If we're to be morally responsible about such things, then surely showing the real world impact of a bullet, for example, is a good thing? That's not glamourising. That's just showing people facts.

Yet facts are scary things. And with Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 the fact is that the game does confront an issue. It does tell a story about fighting terrorism, that also accepts that the very fight that many soldiers across the world are bravely battling for is not black and white. It's not a case of knocking on the door, shooting, and walking away job done. Modern Warfare 2's narrative, whether you like that or not, addresses this. Reality isn't nice. You could argue even that Activision has even copped out by allowing the controversial segment of the game to be skippable.

Sadly, once this particular witch-hunt has died down, it's just a matter of time until the next game comes along to move into the crosshairs on an increasingly hysterical tabloid media. In the case of Modern Warfare 2, most people with brain cells running into the plural accept that, just because there's a segment such as the one described in the game, it's not going to get people signing up for terrorism, nor is it going to desensitise people to genuine real world horrors and atrocities. Is it making entertainment out of terrorism? Or is it confronting and presenting an issue? The answer may well be all of the above to an extent, but I can't call that, as I've not played that segment of the game. I do, however, believe that it is a duty of entertainment media to deal with real life issues, however frightened that might make people who have 1000 words to write before their copy deadline hits.

And finally, as for the nonsense that children will be playing this game, and isn't that terrible? Well, yes it is. But then - what's that on the box? In the UK, there's a certificate that clearly states that the game is for 18-year-olds. It's hardly Activision's fault if bad parents let 12-year-old kids near the game, is it? But then, once more, it's far easier to pin that on the game makers than it is to deal with a genuine, underlying real world issue.

You could argue that that's a bit of an underlying theme here...

Get Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 from just £32 at the Den of Geek/Amazon Store:

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By cremebrulay 1 November 10, 2009 10:54:14 AM

erm, doesnt the gta series effictively let you do the same thing, ie gun down innocent bystanders for fun? ffs its a video game, the emphasis on game. but then, being a gamer from the birth of modern computing, acusations like this have always been levelled at computer games

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By Geordie2004 1 November 10, 2009 03:15:55 PM

Well said, Simon, you've hit the nail on the head. There have been plenty of films and TV series about terrorism made with (almost) no fuss, and with far more of a focus on the actual terrorists, but because this is a computer game, people are panicking about it. It's hypocrisy of the highest order, and is truly pathetic. If anyone's interested, here's a link to a fledgeling protest group on Facebook which is pro-gamer: http://www.facebook.com/home.php?#/group.php?gid=189974734041&ref=ts

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By Zurom 1 November 11, 2009 06:06:45 AM

Thank you for such an eye opening article. Non-gamers and tight-ass parents need to chill out and put their noses in shit that actually stinks. This was said in this article, but it needs to be further emphasized because it's clearly overlooked on a regular basis. GAME RATINGS ARE NOT FOR COSMETIC PURPOSES! Holy shit people! This game is Rated M (for mature) for a reason! If you're a parent who buys your children games that have an M-Rating and are underage, you need to question your parenting skills. SECONDLY, upon loading the game for the first time, there is a "Disturbing Mission Content" warning. This warning naturally warns players of the content that may experience if they choose to. Having said that, players can in fact choose to skip the missions with disturbing content. So like Simon said....GET A GRIP!

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By Vinnydoz007 1 November 11, 2009 02:51:35 PM

Zurom, your dead on. Its funny that when it comes to, even movies lets say, there is a reasonably strict follow the code rules, we dont allow 7 or younger in r rated movies and yada yada yada. Yet with games, people argue about the influencing power of them, yet people seem even less inclined to actually follow the ratings when they purchase games for their children. I saw a women buying COD MW2 for her 10 year old. And even the guy at the store selling the game said to her, are you sure you want to buy this for him? Its pretty violent. She just shrugged and said its ok, its only a game. Now to her credit, she may be a good mother who knows that these things can onl influence if you dont contextualize what is happening. And maybe she is a good parent. And wont complain a week from now saying its too violent. But the fact of the matter is, people, parents especially, do not respect video game ratings and thats why games like this end up in the hands of young impressionable kids.

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By Hike1138 1 November 11, 2009 08:27:11 PM

The difference between movies and video games is that you are directly in control of a video game. you decide who lives and who dies. In my opinion there needs to be more responsibility on both sides of a game disc. Yes parents need to actually pay attention to what their kids are doing, but there is far too much 'oh we put a warning on it' and walking away going on these days. Playing COD on xbox live for more than 10 min is all the evidence you need that well over 50 percent of the gamers playing arn't even old enough to drive. Hats off to Infinity Ward for making the best multiplayer game of all time, but something that graphic needs more than a warning. There are plenty of other ways they could have achieved the jaw dropping suspense of that level. As far as GTA4 goes it might as well be doom 1 when compared to the graphics, voice acting, motion capture, and overall 99 percent real environment IF has created within Modern Warfare 2. I don't think it's going to adversely effect kids who arn't already screwed up in the head. I just think it was bad taste, and i pity the soon to be emotionally scared 10 year old who's older brother bought it for him.

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By Zurom 1 November 11, 2009 11:33:06 PM

Valid point(s) Hike, but also take MW2's airport mission and compare it to the complete gameplay capabilities of the GTA series. GTA makes all of MW2 look like child's play considering you can kill any civilian in any form or fashion over and over and over. Also, the warning MW2 provides upon loading it for te first time is a very explicit warning. I was partially dumbfounded by this warning because I've never seen anything like it, so it was a sufficient warning in my opinion.

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By Vinnydoz007 1 November 12, 2009 04:47:16 PM

Movies have ratings. And they are typically followed. People dont scream and cry when a violent movie comes out, and if they do, they are usually ignored or supressed quite quickly. If people are worried about games influencing kids, follow the damn ratings. Thats why they exist. There was a time when they didnt, and frankly, ive never noticed a difference.

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By Zurom 1 November 13, 2009 06:16:25 AM

In the end, I happy with how MW2 turned out. It's become a very intriguing, epic and very unique game. Primarily because IW went in a direction no other developer dares to go.

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By dalbeattieboy 1 November 13, 2009 06:57:32 AM

This is just more publicity for the game. It is not real life for gods sake. Why dont you all grow up and get a life.

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By Zurom 1 November 14, 2009 01:01:02 AM

You should find the person who shit in your cornflakes

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By SoreThumbs 1 November 17, 2009 06:56:19 PM

LOL – my parenting skills are ones of careful watch and ‘teaching’ versus just handing a game over and saying here. There aren't a lot of parents out there that play the video games with their kids whereas I do. They use video games as a baby sitter. They use TV as a baby sitter. So… if I monitor and teach them right from wrong, I believe it does not matter if it is rated “M” because it’s a video game. Pokemon Revolution is rated: for everyone. And that’s a pretty violent game too. Here’s the big difference. Tell a video game kid that is 9 years old about the Disturbing Mission Content and I guarantee most will say “SO? I WANT IT ANYWAY” I told my kid about it and he said, “I DON’T THINK I WANT IT.” That made me proud of him. He’s smart, he understands right from wrong, and that is a good reflection on parenting skills. Video games are a treat - after school and after what we call in our household: "First Things First". I played with army men as a kid. I played Cowboys and Indians as a kid. I have 'killed' many people in my fantasy world as a kid. I've even been killed many times as a kid. Do you know how many times I've chopped off Darth Vader's head or wanted to completely destroy Storm Troopers as a kid? This is in the 70s. Here's the drama. Reality check. If a kid thinks video games are real, then there is an issue. if you teach them how it relates to real life but it is a game, you are on the right track. My son loves CoD Modern Warfare. I get tips on how to shoot from him. My kid does not want to go to Iraq, or Afghanastan or be in the military. He wants to be a baseball player. If he lived in a CoD fantasy, then yes, I have a problem with my parenting skills. But he lives in a - fantasy where he is the best skateboarder, mountain bikeer, martial artist, baseball player, or best snow boarder in the world. Yet, he plays COD a couple of hours a week. He doesn't have time for more than that. My dad wanted me to be a doctor. I did not want to be a doctor. I wanted to be a writer. He forced me to study medicine my first few years of college. I wanted to write. I then hated college and quit! My dad wasn't around because he was in medical school while I was a kid. Then he moved to different parts of the country to get his residency... Where were we? With my mom. How's that for parenting skills? I quit college, then went back and got my screenwriting certificate at UCLA and a business degree at another University. The reality check: yes, "M" is a perfect rating for CoD. But kids are going to get a hold of this game at their friends house or cousin's or somewhere. So teach them well. Because if I wanted to play CoD as a kid - I would have found a way.

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By Zurom 1 November 17, 2009 11:16:32 PM

SoreThumbs, I'd like to thank you for such a wonderful post. I hope other parents see this post of yours and learn from it. I just can describe into words how much I agree with what you've had to say.

Re: The Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 controversy: a reality check
Posted By orlandoseo 1 July 14, 2010 08:47:01 PM

yet another article out yesterday about a murder committed by someone who claims inspiration from video games, more specifically MW2 orlando seo
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image
 
 
Untitled Document

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Coke Zero
Advertisement