Den of Geek

Alternate Cover: the three superhero movies Marvel would rather forget

James Hunt


Marvel has had more success than anyone with its canon of superhero films. But here are three it's understandably shy about...

Published on Aug 10, 2009

Over the last few years, Marvel has become as popular for its high-budget summer blockbusters as it has for its comics – but that wasn’t always the case. As recently as 1998 – two years before the X-Men film brought Superheroes back to the big screen – Marvel was still trying to make it big with the movies. Let’s take a look at a few of the pre-X-Men efforts.

Fantastic Four (1994)

Years before Jessica Alba, the bald one from The Shield and the other two brought the Fantastic Four to life (debatably) a film was produced featuring the first live-action appearance of Marvel’s premier family.

Don’t worry, you didn’t miss it – it was never actually released. Produced by low-budget genius Roger Corman for less than $2 million, the film was announced for a theatrical release in 1994. In 1993, it was pulled, and a promised transitioning into a TV pilot itself failed to materialise. Predictably, the film was terrible, but that wasn’t the reason behind its absence from screens. The reality was that the producer and distributor, Constantin Film, would’ve lost its option on the characters if it hadn’t made a film featuring them. According to reports - and unbeknownst to the actors and director - there was never any intention to release the film. A decade on, it’s an oft-bootlegged convention favourite, available online – if you know where to look.

Watch it if: You refuse to believe any F4 film could be worse than Tim Story’s efforts.


Generation X (1996)


Based on the comic which featured the “junior” X-Men team in training, Generation X was a 90-minute TV movie that, if successful, would have lead to a series.

Clearly, that didn’t happen. It’s not hard to see why. Perhaps the biggest insult to X-Men fans was casting All-American Heather McComb as the Chinese-American Jubilee, though the film also badly mischaracterised Monet “M” St. Croix, one of the few characters who actually endured past Generation X’s cancellation.

Although the new character additions, Buff and Refrax, were fair replacements for the too-expensive-to portray characters, Husk and Chamber, the film’s dialogue was excruciating, and the plot failed to address the central themes of being a mutant (the prejudice metaphor) in favour of having Matt Frewer play a cartoonish villain (can he play any other kind?) with a magic chair that let the users invade people’s dreams. The concept could’ve been Buffy-esque in its appeal, but ended up looking like Party of Five with slightly more CGI.

Watch it if: You really like bad comic movies.


Nick Fury: Agent of SHIELD (1998)

In this film, Nick Fury was portrayed by David Hasselhoff, who was fortuitously snagged at exactly the point where his popularity from Baywatch had waned, and his ironic nostalgia market had yet to mature. His music wasn’t even popular in Germany anymore (probably.) It’s fitting, then, that Marvel should portray the absolute nadir of their small-screen adventures with an actor in the nadir of his career. The made-for-TV movie was predictably crap, with Hasselhoff sporting some unconvincing stubble and an equally unconvincing attempt at gruffness. The plot saw an evil terrorist organisation committing evil terrorist acts because they are evil terrorists, which was thinner motivation than even Transformers 2 gave to its evil robots. A thoroughly miserable film.

Watch it if: You’ve watched everything else. Literally, everything else. And even then, give it serious thought.


Let that be a lesson to us all. Next time you complain about the quality of Daredevil, just dig one of these out and think yourself lucky, and try to imagine what superhero films would be like without a budget. Then realise that you don’t have to imagine - they’d be exactly like these films.

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Alternate Cover: the three superhero movies Marvel would rather forget
Posted By Robmac 1 August 10, 2009 08:09:56 AM

I have seen all of these and you are right, they are dreadful. Generation X had some good moments in it, like the bit where 'skin' is shaking hands with somebody out of a window of a cab and it pulls off and his arm gets silly-puttied down the road. Also Gen X starred Matt Frewer from Max Headroom as a cheap knock off of Edward Nigma from Batman. Also the 'Things' make-up from the cheap Roger Corman movie is still bettert than the big budget counterpart, at least they have the iconic brow right!

Re: Alternate Cover: the three superhero movies Marvel would rather forget
Posted By stuxmusic 1 August 10, 2009 11:01:04 AM

Im having a tough time getting my hands on Nick Fury. Which is the one I really want to see. I didn't even know that it existed! Hasselhoff! WHAT? Mental. I may come back once I've seen them :P

Re: Alternate Cover: the three superhero movies Marvel would rather forget
Posted By Reformed_Geek 1 August 10, 2009 12:23:05 PM

I agree with Generation X, that was very poor. I seem to remember it being very... neon. The Corman Fanastic Four film isn't all that bad. The costumes and effects are poor, but I prefer to the plot to that of the two big budget FF films. As for the Nick Fury film, I recall it being watchable and that the entire budget was spent on one pretty cool shot of the SHIELD Helicarrier.

Re: Alternate Cover: the three superhero movies Marvel would rather forget
Posted By stuxmusic 1 August 10, 2009 11:16:08 PM

Currently watching Generation X. I have the following points... Why are all the cameras Tilted? What was that farting scene all about People are either overacting or underacting... weird. Where is Xavier? This plot is rediculous, and some of it's even stolen from Batman Forever! Why invent a character who is 90% Cyclops, and not have him be cyclops? Somehow though... it's kindof enjoyable :S

Re: Alternate Cover: the three superhero movies Marvel would rather forget
Posted By elvisvanhelsing 1 August 10, 2009 11:26:07 PM

No mention of the 1990 Captain America movie starring Matt "son of J.D." Salinger and directed by Albert "Kickboxer 2 and 4" Pyun? Cap's mask had rubber ears!

Re: Alternate Cover: the three superhero movies Marvel would rather forget
Posted By picknmix 1 August 11, 2009 07:55:08 AM

Isn't there also a really bad TV Thor movie???

Re: Alternate Cover: the three superhero movies Marvel would rather forget
Posted By Robmac 1 August 11, 2009 08:05:53 AM

The Thor film is actually an Incredible Hulk TV movie that has Thor in it. There is also one with Daredevil in it.. and guess what they are both utter rubbish too!

Re: Alternate Cover: the three superhero movies Marvel would rather forget
Posted By Robmac 1 August 11, 2009 08:09:55 AM

There is a film however that puts all of the above to shame - the Justice League Movie. While it is DC and not Marvel really is is one of the worst made for TV pieces of crap you will ever see - bits of it are you Youtube (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pb-9JORZYCs) very very bad indeed

Re: Alternate Cover: the three superhero movies Marvel would rather forget
Posted By Missing 1 August 11, 2009 11:52:54 AM

Please, let us not forget to include the Dr Strange made for TV movie. It had decent special effects for the late 70s, and gave a little insight into the origins of Dr Strange. While it may not be in the worst 3, it certainly deserves an honorable mention.

Re: Alternate Cover: the three superhero movies Marvel would rather forget
Posted By atheistgirl 1 August 11, 2009 06:52:44 PM

I quite liked the Nick Fury film. It was rubbish, but in that 'so bad it's funny' kind of way.

Re: Alternate Cover: the three superhero movies Marvel would rather forget
Posted By capt_1ntens0 1 September 4, 2009 09:40:14 AM

I remember flipping onto Channel 5 one night and there was the Hoff donned up as NIck Fury. I spat my drink out in surprise and split my sides laughing for the 10min it took me to realise that I couldn't actually endure 90min of that. Genius. Thank God Marvel have started to get it right by DIY.
Post a Comment
 
The version of Fantastic Four you never got to see... The version of Fantastic Four you never got to see...

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!

Click Here