View Archive |
Home
| Blogs
The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?
Sarah Dobbs
Sarah's new weekly column is all about horror movies. This week: why are there going to be two more Saw movies?
Saw has got to be the most creatively bankrupt horror franchise still going. Unfortunately, it's probably also the most profitable horror franchise still going, which means it's going to keep going, and going, and going...
According to the wisdom of the Internet, Lionsgate is planning to make Saw V and Saw VI. They'll be filmed back to back, and will be directed by David Hackl, the guy who was the production designer on Saw II, Saw III and Saw IV. (But the good news is, there might not be a new Saw movie out in 2008.)
My attitude towards the Saw movies is a bit hypocritical, since despite being completely baffled by the box office success of these monstrosities, I've actually seen them all. In cinemas. Saw III was going to be the absolute last one I bothered with, but I loved Feast, and the guys who wrote that also penned Saw IV, which means I'll (reluctantly) give it a go. But we already know I'll watch any old shite - why does the rest of the world bother? Figuring out why Lionsgate keeps making them is easy; they're cheap and they make money. But figuring out why they make money, that's the hard part.
It's not like there's anything remotely original about them any more. The first one, sure, was a bit different, it was at the beginning of the torture movie trend (possibly actually caused that, but it can't be blamed for tapping into a cultural phenomenon) and there was a spark of originality in it. Plus it was kind of scary. But Saw II was bollocks and Saw III was approximately 90% flashback, and ended with the two serial killers seeming for all the world to have been killed off. Death might not have stopped Freddy Kruger, but... wouldn't you expect it to have stopped Jigsaw? And since there were no ideas left in Saw III, how the hell can there be enough juice left in this franchise for ANOTHER THREE MOVIES TO GET MADE? I can't get over that. I just can't.
I'd make up a nonsensical list of stupid ideas for more Saw movies - Jigsaw in space! People drowned in vats of custard! 100% flashback! Idiot movie producers being forced to actually watch the nonsense they've created! - but I'm a bit wary about doing that. Because ... well, did you know that some of the ideas for torture scenes in Saw III were contributed by Internet forum users? Seriously.
Think about that for a second.
Yeah, so putting nutty ideas on the Internet suddenly seems like a bad plan, because they might actually end up in the film. James Wan and Leigh Whannell did, after all, create Dead Silence, a film so disjointed and stupid it might as well have been written by committee. A committee that was playing that children's game where you write a sentence on a piece of paper, then fold it over and hand it on to someone else to write the next bit, without knowing what you wrote. That's how bad that movie was, and they should be ashamed.
But I bet they're not. Just like I bet you're going to go and see Saw IV, aren't you? Yeah, I probably am, too. I might as well just shoot myself in the foot right now.
Official Saw IV website. Wahhhh.
User's Comments
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?I couldnt agree more. Finchers Se7en did this type of thing over a decade ago and this type of film evolving into Saw which when it came out was intelligent, original and well fun ( if you like that type of thing) and showed that with a bit of originality you could make a good decent B-movie horror film that would appeal to the mainstream. However just because you made one does not mean that you have to make a entire genre out of it. Hostel was ok.. but everything since then has just beena top trump in gross-ness... wow whoopie if i wanted to see fake limbs and such i would watch Casulty on BBC1...this type of 'horror' has had its day. I am looking forward to the resurrgence of fantasy horror with Clive Barker and such once again getting a shot at the horror genre and films like Midnight Meat Train hopefully leading once again into a golden age of horror and a new set of boogey-men horror icons such as Freddy, Jason, the cenobites and the Candyman all making a welcome return to the mainstream screens | |
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?Hell, we should try to get jobs making tea on Saw V - by the time Saw VII rolls around, we'd be in prime position to direct! | |
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?I was really surprised when I went to see Death Proof this year - it was no where near as good as I expected it to be. | |
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?I really liked Saw 1, didn't mind Saw 2, but the third one was risible, and thuddingly rubbish. Also: I love it when a crew member suddenly gets a director gig. What next? The Catering Manager directing Saw 9? | |
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?Like Robert, I feel the torture genre is tired. I'll go further; it's quite literally retarded. The contempt for its characters is sociopathic. The lack of empathy is autistic.
While Saw was an interesting little indie puzzle - like Cube before it - simply poring more gore onto each subsequent installment only appeals to the basest audience; 15 year old boys (whether they're that age physically or just mentally). | |
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?My theory is that new Saw movies should have the suffix of the corresponding Police Academy movie. Saw 5: Assignment Miami Beach. Saw 7: Mission To Moscow. | |
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?I like Simons idea - Saw2 - Electric Boogaloo!, Saw3 - Rise of the Machines, Saw4 - the Voyage Home!
coat on... and out the door :-)
| |
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?I can't wait for Saw Takes Manhattan. A Saw Christmas Carol. Saw's European Vacation. | |
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?Saw X better be in space. That's all I'm saying. | |
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?I Saw What You did Last Summer...? | |
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?I'm not ashamed to say I'm too shit scared to see any of them. The last remotely scary film I saw was The Descent. I still get jumpy in caves now... even ones full of bloody tourists. | |
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?Here's what I have... | |
Re: The Sarah of the Dead column: won't someone make Saw stop?Can I just say, that the Saw IV marketing image might the most nausea-inducing shot ever. I don't know why, it just unnerves me. Maybe it's just the queasy thought of wasting my life by sitting through it. |


